• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

I assembled this class D TPA3118 sub amp a couple of years ago and it cost under $20. I ran four 15 inch Alphas from it's single 100 watt mono output. Now four Alphas in parallel from a mono amp equals 2 ohms and that's a difficult load in anyone's book. It was however very stable although the Alphas literally wanted to jump out of their baffles.

This would have been ideal for OB woofers except for it's sorry ass crossover. It was so touchy there was no way to set and maintain the same frequency. I've learned this is a shortcoming in many of the Chinese cheap sub amps.

In those OB's where I don't use an electronic crossover and standard stereo amp for the woofers I like the Yung SD100 plate amp. It's crossover is actually useable.

P1010011.jpg
 
The amp with the green light is a Yung plate amp in a DIY frame. I use plate amps in gear racks like any other amp. It's not hard to build a four sided open frame for them to drop in. Plate amps are mono and it takes two for stereo but IMO stereo subs aren't worth the effort. In my case I'vs never been able to hear any difference or improvement.

P1160002.jpg
 
Here are a couple of class D Yung plate amps. I've seen some folks mount them in a deep dish picture frame. A rectangular box with the opening cut out works. Class D's make so little heat ventilation is not a problem.

P1010016.jpeg
 
I've seen them popping up also though their frequency response is nothing to get excited about.

I am intrigued by some of the Chinese Diatone P610 clones. Have a little 6" one coming to try. The 10" one looks fantastic for the cost too.

View attachment 1585379

The vintage alnico full range drivers keeps my interest these days. They're affordable and sound better than much of the current offerings. But here's the new alnico version of the excellent Betsy's that I'd like to experience.

https://www.audiocircle.com/index.php?topic=160489.0
 
Through extended listening tonight I realize I've no shortage of bass. It just doesn't jump out at you like it does on box speakers. Much better for later night listening sessions without disturbing anyone else in the house.

Funnily enough the thing really made a difference was swapping from my Litz copper to Neotech UPOCC copper interconnects between my preamp and the FU32 power amp. It emphasizes bass ever so slightly. Just enough to make that difference.

Funnily enough organ music sounds bloody amazing through these things. Really deep and rich. There's organs in music I never previously knew had them, so it's definitely reaching deep enough. Likewise the changes made to the FU32 amp have improved bass :)
 
I feel like I'm missing out, I'll keep trying to break in the new setup, but it's coming along slowly and I'm not really enjoying the sound very much at the moment. I'd like to add some big 15" woofers in an H box to support the low end, but until I can figure out why I'm getting such piercing frequencys I don't want to spend the money on them incase I can't overcome the problem.

It was recommended that I try adding some tweeters, but I don't know if masking the problem with more speakers is the answer.

Any further guidance on this would be greatly appreciated.
 
It was recommended that I try adding some tweeters, but I don't know if masking the problem with more speakers is the answer.

Any further guidance on this would be greatly appreciated.

You mentioned the Zeniths screech at you at 8kHz.
Those old console stereos usually had some sort of high frequency drivers be it horn or paper cones. I suppose it would safe to assume the 10" driver by itself is not really a full-range driver.
By 8kHz, most the sound is coming from the center of the driver with an aggressive ragged response.

Using some sort of a tweeter, (cheap cone or whatever) will help quite a bit.

A Zobel network may help attenuate the ragged upper response of the 10" woofer, and then cut in a tweeter at 8-10k.
Or cut-off the 10" driver with a passive network at 6kHz or so, and then cut-in the tweeter. So the aggressive upper response of the 10" is cut-off, and then the tweeter is lashed-in.
 
I feel like I'm missing out, I'll keep trying to break in the new setup, but it's coming along slowly and I'm not really enjoying the sound very much at the moment. I'd like to add some big 15" woofers in an H box to support the low end, but until I can figure out why I'm getting such piercing frequencys I don't want to spend the money on them incase I can't overcome the problem.

It was recommended that I try adding some tweeters, but I don't know if masking the problem with more speakers is the answer.

Any further guidance on this would be greatly appreciated.

The Zeniths should sound excellent straight off the amp. That's not just my experience but it's also Mr Glow-in-the-dark's preference. That's the way he configures his. Have you listened to each speaker separately and can you determine if one or both are faulty? Be reminded your Zeniths are at least 62 years old and bad speakers can play music but still be faulty.

If they don't sound good by themselves which they should, tweeters or woofers will not improve things.

We use the term full range driver but we really mean wide range driver as no speaker is truly full range. The Zeniths can however cover a bunch of octaves on their own.
 
The Hammond B3 tube organ is the best jazz organ of all time. It uses big alnico full range drivers just like the ones we covet in our OB's


Nope. The Leslie 122 and 147 used with the B3 uses a square ceramic magnet, 15" CTS woofer.

LESLIEinside.jpg
 
The Zeniths should sound excellent straight off the amp. That's not just my experience but it's also Mr Glow-in-the-dark's preference. That's the way he configures his. Have you listened to each speaker separately and can you determine if one or both are faulty? Be reminded your Zeniths are at least 62 years old and bad speakers can play music but still be faulty.

If they don't sound good by themselves which they should, tweeters or woofers will not improve things.

We use the term full range driver but we really mean wide range driver as no speaker is truly full range. The Zeniths can however cover a bunch of octaves on their own.
They both seem like they are working OK, and I agree about the tweeter business. I'm hoping it's the amp needing to be worn in a little. I don't have another low watt amp to test them out and I'm weary to try them out on my big amps. But at this point they don't sound like they should.
 
Just becaue CTS made an AlNiCo magnet doesn't mean they were used in the Leslies commonly used with the B3 (122/147). Can you show a pic of one mounted in a Leslie 122/147?

Leslie 147:
images


Leslie 122RV (optional 16 watt reverb amplifier and 6"x9" jensen). I had a 147RV and 122RV and both used the pictured CTS woofer. If you hear a B3, chances are this is what you are hearing.
549703472_tp.jpg
 
Last edited:
Wimpified Magnavox version.

It isn't hard to guess which one has a lower Fs, higher xmax, along with more power handling.
 

Attachments

  • DSCN3308.JPG
    DSCN3308.JPG
    63.8 KB · Views: 13
  • DSCN3309.JPG
    DSCN3309.JPG
    86.6 KB · Views: 13
toddy,

Take a look at the Alnico speaker in this Leslie. It looks like the CTS above. The Jenson P12 Alnico was also used in the Leslie.

86b7cf873661941c74eb97d555673269--leslie-speaker-hammond-organ.jpg
 
They both seem like they are working OK, and I agree about the tweeter business. I'm hoping it's the amp needing to be worn in a little. I don't have another low watt amp to test them out and I'm weary to try them out on my big amps. But at this point they don't sound like they should.

Mmmm, you're not using them for near field listening or anything like that? They lack coherency while up close....

Which amp are you running? My little Chinese amp didn't begin to sing until I changed the coupling caps and got rid of the ALPS27 pot.

You can test with your big amps no worries. Just set volume to zero and gradually increase from there. Sounded spectacular with my 150WPC darTZeel NHB-108B though it was too loud for regular listening. My preamp has ladder based attenuation so impossible to find tune.

Wimpified Magnavox version.

It isn't hard to guess which one has a lower Fs, higher xmax, along with more power handling.

Mmmm, I find my 15" Magnavox work well for bass. The cones look like those on the Zenith 49CZ though.
 
Last edited:
Jensen , Heppner, CTS, Rola...Alnico, Ceramic...
I won't say there is no wrong answer...But there are a lot of the right ones ;)
Seems to me that just like with Fender, what was available at the best price/quality is what was used.
After all, in the end, it's all about making a profit, otherwise it's bye bye.
 
Back
Top Bottom