• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Crime, these just keep getting better and better. Hearing so many details I've never heard in music before and presented a completely smooth, refined manner. I don't think I'll ever own another pair of speakers, and when it's time to downsize in another 30 years or so they'll make the move with me.

My prediction, within 5-years you'll be listening to something completely different :p Just kidding, but I've had that happen to myself many times...

On top of that my original assessment of the sound stage was incorrect. I thought it to have less pin point accuracy than my Aurum Cantus speakers however that's just not true. The sound stage is wide and natural in a manner I've never before experienced. Things are still where they should be just a little more less clearly defined as they would be in real life. The richness of instruments is such as I've never heard before adding to the sense of realness more than detail alone could ever do. Then there's a sense of depth behind darn near everything.

I think that's the magic of taking a speaker out of it's box, or at least making the box open :) I'm not sure it's entirely more accurate presentation than a boxed speaker (probably not), but I don't think it's necessary less accurate either... just a different set of compromises, and ones that are arguably more enjoyable.

That said I've come to recognize what I originally thought was deep bass is really not as deep as I thought. It's more better articulation of what bass is present. End result is I've a RSL Speedwoofer 10S on order with the wireless option. I'll situate it behind my listening position where there's free space.

Another thing that shocks me is how well this performs at low volume. I was unable to sleep last night so tested out how low I could go without compromising treble, bass, midrange, dynamics, tonality etc. Turns out the second position on my LTA MZ3, with an average SPL of 35db. That's a full 10db lower than ambient room levels during the daylight hours. Means I'll get in trouble with my wife less often ;)

Yeah, my original open baffle experiment had no audible bass below 80Hz or so... it really fell off a cliff at about 100Hz. Yet the bass was one of the first things I was amazed by. It's just phenomenal to hear the bass breathe so freely, while "normal speaker bass" pressurizes and interacts with the room a lot more, or at least in a different way, making the bass a lot more unnatural sounding. It's like with open baffle, the bass is in the room, but with a normal speaker it often almost feels like the room is "in the speaker" and you are listening to the bass from the inside, if you get what I mean. Every once in a while I do enjoy listening to my boxed speakers and hearing and feeling that bass all the way down, and the dynamics they have, but overall I vastly prefer the bass from my open baffle setup.

Low volume is interesting, I recently noticed that with a phono cartridge - how a better cartridge keeps the presentation 3 dimensional and coherent all the way, until you finally can't hear no music. But all the way to that point, you hear all the good stuff, it just keeps going lower in volume. With lesser (even some quite good) cartridges, the presentation doesn't hold together through a fade-out, at some point you lose the soundstage and everything else that makes a piece of music sound belieavable. Open baffle speakers I think really help with this as well, even if in some ways that back wave might be coloring in a space that perhaps didn't exist in the original recording up to that extent - but no room is perfect, and overall (at least for now...) I find the open baffle presentation more believable and realistic.
 
Crime, these just keep getting better and better. Hearing so many details I've never heard in music before and presented a completely smooth, refined manner. I don't think I'll ever own another pair of speakers, and when it's time to downsize in another 30 years or so they'll make the move with me.

On top of that my original assessment of the sound stage was incorrect. I thought it to have less pin point accuracy than my Aurum Cantus speakers however that's just not true. The sound stage is wide and natural in a manner I've never before experienced. Things are still where they should be just a little more less clearly defined as they would be in real life. The richness of instruments is such as I've never heard before adding to the sense of realness more than detail alone could ever do. Then there's a sense of depth behind darn near everything.

That said I've come to recognize what I originally thought was deep bass is really not as deep as I thought. It's more better articulation of what bass is present. End result is I've a RSL Speedwoofer 10S on order with the wireless option. I'll situate it behind my listening position where there's free space.

Another thing that shocks me is how well this performs at low volume. I was unable to sleep last night so tested out how low I could go without compromising treble, bass, midrange, dynamics, tonality etc. Turns out the second position on my LTA MZ3, with an average SPL of 35db. That's a full 10db lower than ambient room levels during the daylight hours. Means I'll get in trouble with my wife less often ;)

I can't get over how this system is getting better every single day I listen to it. That said it's getting a good 14 hours non-stop use every day right now and will continue to do so until I'm back at work at the end of this month :)

One of the strengths of a flea watt single ended amp powering highly efficient FR speakers is the resolution of detail at low volume. It's quite jaw dropping to hear the spit building up in Mile's trumpet.
 
My recommendation to try adding a tweeter was based on the premise that the speaker by itself might not go all the way up to 20k. If the freq response falls off rapidly somewhere between 10k - 15k or so, at least for me that kind of frequency response creates an impression of a screetchy and shouty treble, that's really fatiguing to listen to. I can even simulate this, applying a lowpass filter to a music file and listening to it. Now in the case of full range drivers, many of them can be a bit forward in the upper mids / lower treble to begin with, and this is highlighted by any beaming. When you combine the lack of high frequency extension with the forward lower treble/mids, I find the end result really uncomfortable to listen to. Even with a well behaved speaker, cutting out the highs produces uncomfortable results for me, it just might not happen instantly, but the listening fatigue will kick in sooner or later, usually rather sooner.

So at least for me, adding a tweeter to provide full frequency extension up to my hearing limit, is not at all about masking a problem, it's about psychoacoustically making a speaker listenable for me, as I find any speaker, no matter what buttery smoothness it displays between 200-10k or whatever, will sound fatiguing over time if it doesn't go up as far as I can hear, or at least very close to it.

I'm not saying what I describe above is going to be a problem for everyone. I do know many people seem very happy listening to "full range" drivers that go up to 12-13k only, so I'm sure this is not an issue for all people, but I'm sure I'm not the only one who experiences this, and for people like me, I want them to know that they can still enjoy the coherency of a good full-range (or rather wide band) driver, but they need to provide their ears the full frequency spectrum up to 20k or whatever is their personal limit, to be able to enjoy that and should only judge a driver after they have heard it in that context - just like you don't judge a midrange of a 3-way speker by listening to the midrange driver alone.

I don't get your post. Are you saying missing highs ( from lack of a tweeter ) can sound fatiguing?
 
Probably why I was so sensitive to the lack of perceived detail with these. Checked my hearing in the past 2 weeks. I can still hear up to 17040hz. Not too shabby for 40. The Zenith are magic with a tweeter with a single 3.3uf cap on it, or 3.333uf in my case as the cap is bypassed. :)

I don't get your post. Are you saying missing highs ( from lack of a tweeter ) can sound fatiguing?

I imagine it could for some. We all hear differently. I just found it insanely boring until I added the planar. I'm used to incredible detail from listening to Aurum Cantus ribbons the last few years. While the planar isn't at that level it's close enough that I don't feel I'm missing anything. Besides I didn't find any ribbons at 98db efficiency. Granted I didn't look to hard;)

The bullet tweeter alone just didn't cut it though does a wonderful job of making things sound more open and atmospheric.
One of the strengths of a flea watt single ended amp powering highly efficient FR speakers is the resolution of detail at low volume. It's quite jaw dropping to hear the spit building up in Mile's trumpet.

Damn, wish I'd discovered it years ago
 
Last edited:
"My prediction, within 5-years you'll be listening to something completely different :p Just kidding, but I've had that happen to myself many times..."

"Low volume is interesting, I recently noticed that with a phono cartridge - how a better cartridge keeps the presentation 3 dimensional and coherent all the way, until you finally can't hear no music. But all the way to that point, you hear all the good stuff, it just keeps going lower in volume. With lesser (even some quite good) cartridges, the presentation doesn't hold together through a fade-out, at some point you lose the soundstage and everything else that makes a piece of music sound belieavable. Open baffle speakers I think really help with this as well, even if in some ways that back wave might be coloring in a space that perhaps didn't exist in the original recording up to that extent - but no room is perfect, and overall (at least for now...) I find the open baffle presentation more believable and realistic."

You're probably right. Just when I think I'm done there's something new to try that piques my curiosity. I've tried high powered amplification, medium level tube and fleawatt now. I like something different about each of them. I can't justify keeping 3x high performance systems though.

With respect to the cartridge, I've found that myself. The Audio Technica ART9 is an incredible cartridge for the price point. I still prefer running SUT to the MC stage (higher gain settings) in my Valab LCR-1 phono too. Far better sound staging ;)

I'm finding that this current setup really amplifies the differences in the source. Vinyl sounds far better than digital content through my Gieseler GroB DAC which is really quite incredible seeing as it's a $2,300 DAC. Seems my previous setup either wasn't up to showing the difference or just as likely my current amplification and speakers just suit that format better. I suspect if I moved the modded Muji Studio DAC II from my second system the difference would disappear though;)

Common sense tells me fatigue is caused from what we hear and not from what we don't hear.

Not quite, hearing only part of a sound (kind of like clipping) can definitely cause fatigue.... Though I get where you're coming from:)
 
You're probably right. Just when I think I'm done there's something new to try that piques my curiosity. I've tried high powered amplification, medium level tube and fleawatt now. I like something different about each of them. I can't justify keeping 3x high performance systems though.

With respect to the cartridge, I've found that myself. The Audio Technica ART9 is an incredible cartridge for the price point. I still prefer running SUT to the MC stage (higher gain settings) in my Valab LCR-1 phono too. Far better sound staging ;)

I'm finding that this current setup really amplifies the differences in the source. Vinyl sounds far better than digital content through my Gieseler GroB DAC which is really quite incredible seeing as it's a $2,300 DAC. Seems my previous setup either wasn't up to showing the difference or just as likely my current amplification and speakers just suit that format better. I suspect if I moved the modded Muji Studio DAC II from my second system the difference would disappear though;)



Not quite, hearing only part of a sound (kind of like clipping) can definitely cause fatigue.... Though I get where you're coming from:)
You're misunderstanding the concept of hearing fatigue. Poultrygeist has it right.
 
You're misunderstanding the concept of hearing fatigue. Poultrygeist has it right.
I think it's more of a mental fatigue. Having lived with real instruments most of my life I know when the sizzle of a cymbal, shimmer of an acoustic guitar etc is missing.
So you kind of stress to hear it when it's not there. I find the same with bass. Without the proper harmonic content it's just a bunch of low end noise to me.

On a slightly different note, if you happen to be one of those people that use simple equalization (bass and treble) you might find yourself
trying to boost the upper end when all you're doing is boosting the harsh frequencies and not adding the clarity and air that you might be looking for.
 
I don't get your post. Are you saying missing highs ( from lack of a tweeter ) can sound fatiguing?

Yes, doesn't matter what's the cause. Lowpass filter does it just the same. The lack of highs makes the lower treble and high mids stick out in bad way and get fatiguing. Maybe I'm more special in that than I thought.
 
Yes, doesn't matter what's the cause. Lowpass filter does it just the same. The lack of highs makes the lower treble and high mids stick out in bad way and get fatiguing. Maybe I'm more special in that than I thought.

Take for example the Zenith wide band drivers which are the current topic of discussion. I've listened to them for hours with and without tweeters and found them extremely smooth, satisfying and not fatiguing in the least. I will admit that the tweeters definitely added some nice cymbal shimmer. But before adding the tweeters I certainly did not miss the shimmer. Point being you don't miss what you don't hear and to think that missing that shimmer causes listener fatigue is just silly. The blogger ( Mr. GITD ) who helped make these drivers so popular has this to say on the matter:

"In the past few months I've stopped using tweeters and feel that it's an improvement. These old Zeniths might not make it to 20khz but I can't hear that anyway. FM radio is cut off at 15khz and no one seems to mind. At any rate these Zeniths are very special drivers with a quality of sound that I've certainly found addictive".
 
Yes, doesn't matter what's the cause. Lowpass filter does it just the same. The lack of highs makes the lower treble and high mids stick out in bad way and get fatiguing. Maybe I'm more special in that than I thought.
No sorry you're not more special, not in my view anyway. :)
I'll have to agree with you on this one 100%
Actually it's common sense.With a lack of some frequencies the others seem louder.
It's all a matter of balance.
 
No sorry you're not more special, not in my view anyway. :)
I'll have to agree with you on this one 100%
Actually it's common sense.With a lack of some frequencies the others seem louder.
It's all a matter of balance.
The present frequencies are not "louder" because there are missing frequencies. This is not "common sense," it's a fact.

The only thing that can be truly said about common sense is that it is in fact, not common and not inherently correct.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom