• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Back when flea watt tubes ruled large high efficiency wide band speakers were the norm. All those speakers listed above were manufactured and used interchangably in guitar amps, organs and home consoles. It reminds me of the vacuum tube era when companies made other companies' tubes and just relabeled them. CTS stands for Chicago Telephone Suppy and was bought out by Eminence which is now the world's largest speaker manufacturer. The Zenith console where I harvested my 49CZ802's contained a no name 10" alnico. I'd bet it's not a Zenith ( no ribbed cone and name blacked out ) and I'm not sure that all Zeniths weren't farmed out to other speaker manufactures?
 
toddy,

Take a look at the Alnico speaker in this Leslie. It looks like the CTS above. The Jenson P12 Alnico was also used in the Leslie.

86b7cf873661941c74eb97d555673269--leslie-speaker-hammond-organ.jpg

Yes, but that is not a Leslie 122 or 147 most commonly used with the B3.
 
Back when flea watt tubes ruled large high efficiency wide band speakers were the norm. All those speakers listed above were manufactured and used interchangably in guitar amps, organs and home consoles. It reminds me of the vacuum tube era when companies made other companies' tubes and just relabeled them. CTS stands for Chicago Telephone Suppy and was bought out by Eminence which is now the world's largest speaker manufacturer. The Zenith console where I harvested my 49CZ802's contained a no name 10" alnico. I'd bet it's not a Zenith ( no ribbed cone and name blacked out ) and I'm not sure that all Zeniths weren't farmed out to other speaker manufactures?
Even tube manufactures would buy from others and put their name on the product when they couldn't keep up with the supply/demand aspect.
 
Aha.... I turned off adaptive volume in JRIVER. I previously had that on with my darTZeel / Aurum Cantus combo as it was so dynamic my wife would constantly yell at me to turn it down. While it did degrade sound a bit it was never the difference I get with the FU32 / OB combo. Seems they're extremely sensitive when it comes to compression.

Not as sharp as the previous setup though this is clearly the best sounding audio I've ever achieved (in this room anyway). Got to say I really like the little amp. Once modded it's more like a solid state amp though with the 3D characteristics of tubes. Best of both worlds for me. Plenty of bass and flat with a little treble roll off. Perfect for me :)

Previously the only speakers I've experienced so critical of everything in the chain before it were the Dayton PS220-8. The Zenith are definitely better though. I can say that now for sure.

Once I've NOS power tubes I feel I can try recording this now. Time to start thinking about how to jerry rig my Rode S1 stage mic up to my phone to do a video.

IMG_20190810_113128.jpg
 
At the moment I'm driving the Alpha H-frames with this bizarre amp. It's a class D double chip TPA3116 mounted on it's linear power supply. The frequency is controlled by an Ashly XR-1001 active crossover. Variety is the spice of life. :)

P7190039.jpg
 
Ok, I've ordered a phantom power supply and 3.5mm jack to XLR cable. I should be able to do decent recordings with that. The S1 is a live vocal condenser mic so hopefully the dynamic range is enough. It's the best I have on hand anyway.
 
Ok, I've ordered a phantom power supply and 3.5mm jack to XLR cable. I should be able to do decent recordings with that. The S1 is a live vocal condenser mic so hopefully the dynamic range is enough. It's the best I have on hand anyway.

I'm anxious to hear how it sounds. :thumbsup:
 
You mentioned the Zeniths screech at you at 8kHz...
By 8kHz, most the sound is coming from the center of the driver with an aggressive ragged response...
Or cut-off the 10" driver with a passive network at 6kHz or so, and then cut-in the tweeter. So the aggressive upper response of the 10" is cut-off, and then the tweeter is lashed-in.
Yes, this is the standard approach to fidelity. Cone speakers usually work in a linear fashion at low frequencies but the cone starts to break up at higher frequencies and can produce quite a horrible sound. The vast majority of the 6/8/10 inch drivers in the world's hi-fi speakers are rolled off at the top end and crossed over to a tweeter, and for good reason (in my opinion).
I think there's a danger that this thread is giving the distinct impression that "open baffle" is somehow synonymous with "full range driver", but really they're two separate concepts. There's no reason why open baffle speakers can't be two way, or three or more, and no reason why they can't have fully developed passive or active crossovers. One of the most famous advocates of open baffle speakers, the late Siegfried Linkwitz, made his designs multi-way with very complex crossovers.
The full-range driver approach has an elegant simplicity about it which is very attractive, but you need the right drivers to do it, and even then you'll be getting wide range rather than full range.
 
As far as I'm concerned full range speakers ( aka wide band drivers ) are synonymous with open baffles. Most companies that sell OB's use full range drivers from Fostex, Tang Band, Voxativ, Eminence, Misco, Lowther, Visaton, Dayton etc. I think Linkwitz and GR Research are exceptions. It's much harder to stitch two dissimilar drivers together than it is to augment the bass of a full range driver.
 
It's much harder to stitch two dissimilar drivers together than it is to augment the bass of a full range driver.
That may or may not be true, but it applies to all types of speaker, not just open baffle.
To me, open baffle means simply that - a flat baffle board which is open at the back, regardless of whether or not the drivers used are full range or woofer/mid/tweeter. The big advantage of open baffles is there's no box, therefore no boxiness to the sound.
 
That may or may not be true, but it applies to all types of speaker, not just open baffle.
To me, open baffle means simply that - a flat baffle board which is open at the back, regardless of whether or not the drivers used are full range or woofer/mid/tweeter. The big advantage of open baffles is there's no box, therefore no boxiness to the sound.

Sometime you should try open baffles.
 
I was surprised that I appear to be getting more deep bass with mine than with my previous box speakers which reached down to 35Hz.

I suspect that the bass accuracy means that I can actually hear heretofore unheard bass detail and so it gives the impression of deeper bass even if it's not actually reaching that low
 
Crikey, these just keep getting better and better. Hearing so many details I've never heard in music before and presented a completely smooth, refined manner. I don't think I'll ever own another pair of speakers, and when it's time to downsize in another 30 years or so they'll make the move with me.

On top of that my original assessment of the sound stage was incorrect. I thought it to have less pin point accuracy than my Aurum Cantus speakers however that's just not true. The sound stage is wide and natural in a manner I've never before experienced. Things are still where they should be just a little more less clearly defined as they would be in real life. The richness of instruments is such as I've never heard before adding to the sense of realness more than detail alone could ever do. Then there's a sense of depth behind darn near everything.

That said I've come to recognize what I originally thought was deep bass is really not as deep as I thought. It's more better articulation of what bass is present. End result is I've a RSL Speedwoofer 10S on order with the wireless option. I'll situate it behind my listening position where there's free space.

Another thing that shocks me is how well this performs at low volume. I was unable to sleep last night so tested out how low I could go without compromising treble, bass, midrange, dynamics, tonality etc. Turns out the second position on my LTA MZ3, with an average SPL of 35db. That's a full 10db lower than ambient room levels during the daylight hours. Means I'll get in trouble with my wife less often ;)

I can't get over how this system is getting better every single day I listen to it. That said it's getting a good 14 hours non-stop use every day right now and will continue to do so until I'm back at work at the end of this month :)
 
Last edited:
It was recommended that I try adding some tweeters, but I don't know if masking the problem with more speakers is the answer.

If they don't sound good by themselves which they should, tweeters or woofers will not improve things.

My recommendation to try adding a tweeter was based on the premise that the speaker by itself might not go all the way up to 20k. If the freq response falls off rapidly somewhere between 10k - 15k or so, at least for me that kind of frequency response creates an impression of a screetchy and shouty treble, that's really fatiguing to listen to. I can even simulate this, applying a lowpass filter to a music file and listening to it. Now in the case of full range drivers, many of them can be a bit forward in the upper mids / lower treble to begin with, and this is highlighted by any beaming. When you combine the lack of high frequency extension with the forward lower treble/mids, I find the end result really uncomfortable to listen to. Even with a well behaved speaker, cutting out the highs produces uncomfortable results for me, it just might not happen instantly, but the listening fatigue will kick in sooner or later, usually rather sooner.

So at least for me, adding a tweeter to provide full frequency extension up to my hearing limit, is not at all about masking a problem, it's about psychoacoustically making a speaker listenable for me, as I find any speaker, no matter what buttery smoothness it displays between 200-10k or whatever, will sound fatiguing over time if it doesn't go up as far as I can hear, or at least very close to it.

I'm not saying what I describe above is going to be a problem for everyone. I do know many people seem very happy listening to "full range" drivers that go up to 12-13k only, so I'm sure this is not an issue for all people, but I'm sure I'm not the only one who experiences this, and for people like me, I want them to know that they can still enjoy the coherency of a good full-range (or rather wide band) driver, but they need to provide their ears the full frequency spectrum up to 20k or whatever is their personal limit, to be able to enjoy that and should only judge a driver after they have heard it in that context - just like you don't judge a midrange of a 3-way speker by listening to the midrange driver alone.
 
Back
Top Bottom