• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

The 6" Diatone P610 clone destroys the 8" Dayton PS220-8 and sounds an awful lot like an alnico driver despite being ferrite magnet.
What does an alnico magnet sound like?
Cones can be light or heavy, thick or thin, rigid or pliable, etc. etc. Surrounds can pleated paper, cloth, rolled rubber, foam etc. etc. Spiders can be stiff or loose. The Qms can be high or low, the Qes can be high or low, the Vas can be high or low etc. etc. and these parameters can be used to predict the performance of a driver, at low frequencies at least. But what effect does alnico rather than ceramic have? :dunno:
 
What does an alnico magnet sound like?
Cones can be light or heavy, thick or thin, rigid or pliable, etc. etc. Surrounds can pleated paper, cloth, rolled rubber, foam etc. etc. Spiders can be stiff or loose. The Qms can be high or low, the Qes can be high or low, the Vas can be high or low etc. etc. and these parameters can be used to predict the performance of a driver, at low frequencies at least. But what effect does alnico rather than ceramic have? :dunno:

True. Just saying these are very similar to the Zenith in sound though a little richer and better detailed. Very happy I got them for the bedroom system. I think the larger ones (10" H10 or 12" P1210) would be fantastic candidates for open baffles.... Heck, the 6" and 6.5" are probably good candidates too. Lovely sounding drivers.

Not that I'll be trying them. The Zenith are there to stay in my open backs. ;)
 
Damn, It's just occurred to me that there was another way I could have done an actual open baffle and child proofed with high WAF....

I could have done full H frame for both top and bottom though applied speaker material to both the front and back to make it look like a normal speaker. I don't know why this never occurred to me until now :(

A bit late for me though might be a useful concept for someone else.... Hmmm, maybe I could do OB bookshelf speakers for the bedroom with Diatone P610 drivers ;)
 
What does an alnico magnet sound like?
Cones can be light or heavy, thick or thin, rigid or pliable, etc. etc. Surrounds can pleated paper, cloth, rolled rubber, foam etc. etc. Spiders can be stiff or loose. The Qms can be high or low, the Qes can be high or low, the Vas can be high or low etc. etc. and these parameters can be used to predict the performance of a driver, at low frequencies at least. But what effect does alnico rather than ceramic have? :dunno:

Alnico has the special pixie dust applied for extra magic. :P

Seriously though, I have no idea, how/why/if the material should affect how a speaker sounds. I know the "best" sounding guitar pickups I've owned have alnico magnets and at least in that application alnico vs ceramic usually seems to have a 'sound'. I think in a guitar pickup a magnet would/should have more effect than in a speaker, where there's more parameters that affect sound, but even in guitar pickups I guess it's hard to say what's exactly because of magnet and what is coil wire or something else. I certainly haven't done an alnico vs ceramic comparison where all else was equal. Can all else even be equal, since different magnets would mean different coil windings to get the same output? In guitar pickups, I think alnico ones generally sound more open and shimmery, with a very beautiful midrange, but with possibly looser bottom end than ceramics - generally more "open" but also more pleasing somehow. But is it because of magnets or because they were wound to sound that way to fit how people think they should sound? If a good pickup designer set out to make 3 identical sounding pickups, all using different type of magnets, could they do it? Same goes for speakers, though there are more parameters and moving parts involved. I certainly don't know. What I do know is guitar people are even more conservative and prone to superstition than hifi people, which is saying something :)
 
I know the "best" sounding guitar pickups I've owned have alnico magnets and at least in that application alnico vs ceramic usually seems to have a 'sound'.
One possible explanation as far as guitar pickups are concerned is that the magnetic material in a guitar pickup acts like the core of an inductor, so different materials give a different inductance for the same number of turns of wire. Changing the inductance changes the the resonant peak in the spectrum, hence a different sound.
 
One possible explanation as far as guitar pickups are concerned is that the magnetic material in a guitar pickup acts like the core of an inductor, so different materials give a different inductance for the same number of turns of wire. Changing the inductance changes the the resonant peak in the spectrum, hence a different sound.

Yeah exactly, it becomes impossible to compare the 'sound' of the magnet types in isolation. If you change the coil to account for the change of magnet, then are you really hearing the magnet type or the coil wire or what? Except of course if both pickups sound the same after balancing everything out, which frankly would be a bit boring and at least personally I hope there would be some unaccountable difference in sound, which some people would claim to be obvious, while others would say they sound the same and everyone who thinks otherwise is fooling themselves and couldn't distinguish them in a blindtest anyway :P
 
But what effect does alnico rather than ceramic have? :dunno:

Different saturation. Consider the difference between an air core inductor as an iron core inductor of the same properties.

Also, induction. I have never tried this with an AlNiCo magnet but have done it with neodymium magnets. Take a coil of wire and put an induction meter on it. Now put a slug of iron in the center and watch the induction rise on the meter. Pull the iron out and put a neodynium magnet in the center and the induction remains the same as if there were no magnet in the center.

Try this for yourselves. You can simply use a screwdriver to simulate an iron magnet and tape the neodymium magnet to a wooden stick to move it through the coil.
 
Last edited:
Also, induction. I have never tried this with an AlNiCo magnet but have done it with neodymium magnets. Take a coil of wire and put an induction meter on it. Now put a slug of iron in the center and watch the induction rise on the meter. Pull the iron out and put a neodynium magnet in the center and the induction remains the same as if there were no magnet in the center.
Which is what I said about guitar pickups in my previous post. I still don't see it as being the major factor in a speaker's performance given all the other variables.
 
I'll quote someone here:

"Changing the inductance changes the the resonant peak in the spectrum, hence a different sound."
That applies to guitar pickups and is very easy to demonstrate.
Can you show me the frequency response of any loudspeaker and point to the resonant peak due to inductance? Even the impedance curve, which does show inductance (at least for crossover-less single drivers) doesn't demonstrate an "alnico sound", just rising impedance at high frequencies much like that of a ceramic magnet speaker. Given so many other variables I would be amazed if anyone could identify from listening to a speaker what the magnet material is.
 
Damn, It's just occurred to me that there was another way I could have done an actual open baffle and child proofed with high WAF....

I could have done full H frame for both top and bottom though applied speaker material to both the front and back to make it look like a normal speaker. I don't know why this never occurred to me until now :(

A bit late for me though might be a useful concept for someone else.... Hmmm, maybe I could do OB bookshelf speakers for the bedroom with Diatone P610 drivers ;)

I suggested a partition between the two drivers which would make it a U frame over a U frame. That option is still available to you. Have no idea how they would sound but I've learned a lot more by trial and error than through pontification.
 
For WAF these Visaton OB's usually have speaker cloth covering their entire backs. The ones I've seen looked like conventional speakers.

Fig2a-OB-back.jpg
 
For WAF these Visaton OB's usually have speaker cloth covering their entire backs. The ones I've seen looked like conventional speakers.

Fig2a-OB-back.jpg

Very nice. In hindsight I'd like to have gone this route.

I suggested a partition between the two drivers which would make it a U frame over a U frame. That option is still available to you. Have no idea how they would sound but I've learned a lot more by trial and error than through pontification.

I may try at some point with temporary fixtures.... Double sided tape maybe....

I'm also curious what the affect of a panel behind the bass driver would be with absorption foam, leaving it open to the drivers above. That way less bass notes would be cancelled out.....

For now I'm more concerned with getting the matching amplification right though. That's my current weakest link.
 
Last edited:
That applies to guitar pickups and is very easy to demonstrate.
Can you show me the frequency response of any loudspeaker and point to the resonant peak due to inductance? Even the impedance curve, which does show inductance (at least for crossover-less single drivers) doesn't demonstrate an "alnico sound", just rising impedance at high frequencies much like that of a ceramic magnet speaker. Given so many other variables I would be amazed if anyone could identify from listening to a speaker what the magnet material is.

People claim to hear differences in wire, caps, even what some would consider very trivial things like elevating the wire 2", etc., so why should this be any different?

https://www.premierguitar.com/articles/24984-speaker-geeks-alnico-or-ceramicwhat-gives
 
People claim to hear differences in wire, caps, even what some would consider very trivial things like elevating the wire 2", etc., so why should this be any different?

https://www.premierguitar.com/articles/24984-speaker-geeks-alnico-or-ceramicwhat-gives

I don't see why not with different wire, I can with speakers and interconnects. A guitar is a small signal into an amp and wire that is potentially quite coloured and unsuited for stereo use could be just right the ticket for guitar. They're chasing tone after all.... Elevating the wire sounds like BS though.
 
Has anyone else noticed the weird ability of open backs to simultaneously expose the flaws of a digital recording like over processed, compressed or simply too low bitrate while also adding depth and naturalness to its playback which makes it more enjoyable despite those aforementioned issues?

I'm also enjoying artists I've never previously liked the sound of, like Bob Dylan.

Kind of like it's simultaneously more revealing and insightful though also forgiving and musical. Not things that typically go hand in hand in HiFi.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom