• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Good luck with your project. I have no specific advice regarding OB speakers but when I see pictures like those in that blog post I'm stunned that anyone would would want to listen to music in a room with such unfriendly acoustics. It looks appalling to me.

OB's are much less room dependent than conventional box speakers.
 
OB's are much less room dependent than conventional box speakers.
They radiate a lot less to the sides but do radiate to the back and the forward radiation is pretty much the same as other speakers, so I wouldn't say the room acoustics are irrelevant when using OBs. A room with the acoustics of a gymnasium or the local swimming baths won't do your music any favours whatever speakers you use, in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
They radiate a lot less to the sides but do radiate to the back and the forward radiation is pretty much the same as other speakers, so I wouldn't say the room acoustics are irrelevant when using OBs. A room with the acoustics of a gymnasium or the local swimming baths won't do you music any favours whatever speakers you use, in my opinion.

I did not say that room acoustics were irrelevant but if you're really interested in OB's why not build a pair? You'll learn so much and put any speculation to rest.

You can read Linkwitz conclusions. He forgot more about OB's than we will ever know.

https://www.linkwitzlab.com/conclusions.htm
 
Last edited:
The metal frames are a good choice if you intend to play open baffles really loud or if you plan to experiment with different drivers. Without the frames and at normal listening levels you won't hear any resonance from 3/4" plywood or MDF in flat "I" baffles.

The modular nature of the setup is appealing to me. I like to tinker and swap out pieces (probably more than I should). My main rationale was also that I could add a second A15 if I felt it was necessary without rebuilding the entire frame.

I've read those gorgeous Daytons require a corrective circuit to sound their best. The Betsy's OTOH were designed for OB's and don't require any correction. I really like the B&G Neo 3's and they would probably work well with the Betsy's.

Ranking my favorite OB full range drivers bi-amped and paired with the work horse Alpha 15a woofers:

1 - Lowther DX3 and Zenith 49CZ802 ( a tie but very different drivers - hyper detail and in your face Lowthers vs the golden toned Zeniths )

2- Coral Holey Baskets ( amazing clarity and detail - sounds like a much larger driver )

3- Zenith 8" ( alnico motors and a smooth cone but no model number )

4- Radio Shack 40-12860 ( real sleepers and I need to do more experimenting with them )

5- WBAL Betsy ( excellent choice with high Qts and other than the big Zeniths they're one of the few that could get by without helper woofers )

6- Tang Band W8-1808 ( very smooth and refined full ranger but too laid back for my tastes )

7- Fostex Fe126En ( a detail freak but perform best in a BL horn )

This is GREAT info. The price point of the betsy is appealing to me. I could probably swing getting a pair of those and a pair of B&G Neo 3's to fill in up top... Like I said I plan to experiment and ideally run everything with an active crossover. So even if I did go with the Daytons I'd attempt to EQ out any misbehavior from them.

Being totally new to the open baffle world my biggest concern was low-end bass, not that I'm a crazy bass head or anything.
 
The modular nature of the setup is appealing to me. I like to tinker and swap out pieces (probably more than I should). My main rationale was also that I could add a second A15 if I felt it was necessary without rebuilding the entire frame.



This is GREAT info. The price point of the betsy is appealing to me. I could probably swing getting a pair of those and a pair of B&G Neo 3's to fill in up top... Like I said I plan to experiment and ideally run everything with an active crossover. So even if I did go with the Daytons I'd attempt to EQ out any misbehavior from them.

Being totally new to the open baffle world my biggest concern was low-end bass, not that I'm a crazy bass head or anything.

In terms of bass output two Alpha 15A's per side on flat baffles is comparable to one Alpha 15A H-frame per side. I enjoy the accuracy of OB woofers which don't have the slam of box subs but sound more accurate. The H-frames covers down to 40hz which is usually enough for one but adding a small fast sub to the mix like the Dayton 8" reference kit below is an ideal augmentation.

P7300001.jpg
 
anybody knows (I think) Irel Genova 12" fullranges?
26639827_d0fd7130997dd94f6219d0b573065ade_l.jpg

26639825_ea20b27418ebc1e1c6b48b03d16bcc17_l.jpg

26639823_edd8a0146c076c7d9f69bf33b0da6066_l.jpg
 
Finally got around to swapping the center baffle, now have the TB 1808 and the Lowther pm6a in between the alpha 15 twins per side. No apparent loss of fidelity and they still image like crazy. Much easier to switch between drivers. Now if I could only set it up to switch between amps this easy I would be all set.

ob trio twin.PNG
 
Finally got around to swapping the center baffle, now have the TB 1808 and the Lowther pm6a in between the alpha 15 twins per side. No apparent loss of fidelity and they still image like crazy. Much easier to switch between drivers. Now if I could only set it up to switch between amps this easy I would be all set.

View attachment 1785869

Excellent!

How novel ( and space efficient ) to have two main drivers on the same baffle to switch between. So which driver do you spend more time listening to?
 
Has not been together long enough to say in definite terms but over the last 3-4 days its been lowthers more, I really like the musicality of the TB but the PM6a is the best lowther I have heard to date. Its the latest version with the rolled edge wizzer
 
I'm building some MLTL's for the DX3 Lowthers based on MJK's plans. I decided to test the baffle step correction circuit for the MLTL's while the Lowthers are still in their open baffles and I'm amazed how the Lowther's sound is changed. It's very good but it's very different. It no longer has that in your face jump factor but it's now more refined. The circuit doesn't seem to reduce the sensitivity much which is important with flea watt SET amps.

P1010006 2.jpeg
 
Since I like the sound of the baffle step circuit with the Lowthers I think I'll mount them externally on the MLTL's. That way I can get to them for any future uses.

No sense burying $100+ of parts inside monkey coffins never to see the light of day. The openness ( accessibility ) of open baffles has spoiled me.

Hey PG can you post a link to MLTL's and the baffle step correction info ? Appreciate it
 
Back
Top Bottom