Let me first confess that I have only read the first 19 pages of this thread so far. After several more days I hope to catch up to here. Meanwhile, a few observations and questions:
1) While the original poster began by experimenting with mounting speakers in various sized corrugated cardboard boxes with their backs open, and then some corrugated cardboard winged panel designs, there seems to be a vast number of ideas/designs used by people who are making, and sometimes, selling Open Baffle speaker systems, from arrangements not much wider than an ironing board stood on end, to others that look five or more feet wide, suggesting the configuration of the panel system the speaker (or speakers) are mounted through is real, real important. Then others have little more than the speaker(s) held up my some sort of framework/scaffolding/brackets, suggesting such a panel system is not important and maybe a hindrance. In the first 19 pages, I didn't gather a clear idea for how these seemingly contradictory ideas for Open Baffle designs have merit. It doesn't seem that both can be right.
2) I'm old enough to remember when radios, radio-phonograph units, and consoles including a turntable or record changers had open baffle speakers for one simple reason -- the company simply didn't put any sort of backing panel or the rear of the furniture. In fact, I grew up with an open baffle speaker, because the cabinet my dad built with a shelf to hold the kit tube amp he and my older brother built (and which they only built one channel of, leaving it a mono amp forever), had a big boxy space below the shelf for two speakers. And since, the amp was mono, only one dual cone 8" full-range Jensen speaker went in that big space, and the back of the space never got covered. We were mono, tube-amped, and open-baffle before it was cool. I wish I could hear that set-up again. Maybe I didn't know how good it was. My folks just just said "It has a good tone."
3) I wonder if anybody has just taken the back off of box speaker that had so-so sound, or some particular and frustrating deficiency, and found that it suddenly sounded much better. If people have done that, it might be interesting to know about such examples.
4) I also noticed that none of the open baffle designs I saw pictures on the first 19 pages of this thread, or pictured in linked pages I looked at, ever showed any kind of grilles or fabric over the fronts of the speakers. I get the impression having anything whatsoever in front of or directly behind a speaker is against the open baffle philosophy. I also get the impression that dedicated open baffle enthusiasts do not live with pets, children, or elderly persons of an age when they are getting clumsier and clumsier by the day, because in those circumstances (in my experience), if there is an unprotected speaker cone, it will get a hole poked in it, or get torn, or otherwise get damaged. So I am wondering, whether there exist any quasi- or heretical sort-of openish baffle speaker designs that provide the speakers with sufficient protection to survive in the hostile sorts of environments the rest of us live in?
.