• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

He and I don't agree on that. In my systems some of the magic of the FR and SET amp combo is lost once a passive or active is inserted in the signal path. It's not as noticeable with solid state amps and that's all he uses. I was using the F.A.S.T. system before I knew it had a name.
Have you tried a line level passive xover? (AKA PLLXO) Same result?
 
Last edited:
I'll add a woofer and a tweeter, depending on the FR driver, but I'm currently keeping any sort of crossover away from the FR itself. I do a digital 24dB XO built into my Crown amp for the woofers, and a simple cap from the FR to the tweeters. I try not to mess with the FR sound.
 
Have you tried a line level passive xover? (AKA PLLXO) Same result?

Full range drivers are called full range drivers because they are designed to run full range and that's what they do best, Once you use a crossover to try and stitch them to a dissimilar driver they no longer run full range and become something else. Before I got into open baffles I was using full range single drivers in box speakers with filtered and separately powered bass assist. Nothing has changed except the box.
 
Full range drivers are called full range drivers because they are designed to run full range and that's what they do best, Once you use a crossover to try and stitch them to a dissimilar driver they no longer run full range and become something else. Before I got into open baffles I was using full range single drivers in box speakers with filtered and separately powered bass assist. Nothing has changed except the box.
I apologize, I was too short and unclear in my question. Since you said "In my systems some of the magic of the FR and SET amp combo is lost once a passive or active is inserted in the signal path," I was wondering if you were referring to speaker-level passive crossovers. If I understood correctly, I thought your experience was with active crossovers in the line-level signal path, and passive crossovers between the SET amp and FR driver. Since I have had success with adding a simple capacitor in the signal path between the preamp and amp, I thought I'd ask if you had the same loss of magic with that method. Of course, we're all able to do our own listening and make our own judgments! Take care and be well.
 
I apologize, I was too short and unclear in my question. Since you said "In my systems some of the magic of the FR and SET amp combo is lost once a passive or active is inserted in the signal path," I was wondering if you were referring to speaker-level passive crossovers. If I understood correctly, I thought your experience was with active crossovers in the line-level signal path, and passive crossovers between the SET amp and FR driver. Since I have had success with adding a simple capacitor in the signal path between the preamp and amp, I thought I'd ask if you had the same loss of magic with that method. Of course, we're all able to do our own listening and make our own judgments! Take care and be well.

No need to apologize. I've had success integrating a tweeter and larger full range driver powered by the same amp. In this picture a single 1.5uF cap on the tweeter positive filters out the LF. The Zeniths run full range powered by a SET amp while the H-frame Alphas are powered by their own plate amp which of course has a built in crossover. Bi-amping is the key. Another option I like is using an active crossover combined with a stereo amp to filter the HF but only on the woofers.

P1010005 2.jpeg
 
The Betsy is another full range driver that sounds it's best straight off the amp. Some folks even go so far as to solder the speaker cables directly to it's tabs. I tried F-mods to change the frequency upstream of it's amp as well as the down stream filter shown here. Couldn't tell much difference as to my ears the LF is not nearly as critical as the HF.

PB230008.jpeg
 
Hate to say if but I found the weak spot on the OB........................Clarity. The openness and holographic soundstage are wonderful but clarity has remained an issue for me. That nail was driven home last night. Listening to my Cardersound Madison V2 BLH (still single drivers) playing Willie Nelson Midnight Rider the wife and I were both struck by a level of clarity I had not experienced previous. We could both HEAR with absolute clarity the Texas accent in Willies voice. This is a song I have loved since childhood and never before had I heard it in quite the same way. It remains to be seen if this will be cause for me to make a permanent move. The difference is undeniable..............
 
Wondering why that might be? A design flaw maybe. I'll do some critical listening ASAP. Weekends here are a bit noisier than weekdays.

DSC_0001.JPG
 
Hate to say if but I found the weak spot on the OB........................Clarity. The openness and holographic soundstage are wonderful but clarity has remained an issue for me. That nail was driven home last night. Listening to my Cardersound Madison V2 BLH (still single drivers) playing Willie Nelson Midnight Rider the wife and I were both struck by a level of clarity I had not experienced previous. We could both HEAR with absolute clarity the Texas accent in Willies voice. This is a song I have loved since childhood and never before had I heard it in quite the same way. It remains to be seen if this will be cause for me to make a permanent move. The difference is undeniable..............
What do you think is behind that? Do you have a theory? The backwave muddies up the delivery? Can you try the same drivers in both configurations to compare?
 
What do you think is behind that? Do you have a theory? The backwave muddies up the delivery? Can you try the same drivers in both configurations to compare?

I have tried the same drivers in both OB and the BLH a pair of Fostex FE206 with Planet 10 mods. the drivers shine in the BLH and do well in the OB. I would have to guess it has something to do with the back wave........That is simply a guess though. I have smaller BLH (madisound BLH16, using the fostex sigma 168e) that are no where near as clean and clear as the Madisons this could have to do with break in. Fostex are notorious for the extended break in required
 
How far out from the front wall are the OBs?

I have experimented a LOT 6 or 8 different FR Drivers which included Lowther PM4a, Lowther PM6a, Voxativ 1.6, Tang Bang 1808 (current), Lii fast 8 coming in today, Zenith, Audio Nirvana, and more. Placement has been anywhere from 2 feet out to 4.5 feet from the front wall. This is not something stated lightly, I dare say Open Baffle has stuck around my system longer than 99 percent of the speakers I have owned (They remain today trading in and out with the Cardersound Madisons). I have tried several baffle sizes as well and several configurations with and without crossover using Full Range or 100 up HZ only to take stress off the FR and save cross over overlap. It is reality that NO SPEAKER on the planet is PERFECT they all fall short somewhere 10.00 to 200,000.00 they all have a weakness. That does not make them BAD. Im stating a FACT in my system YMMV

I still love the presentation of the OB, and in no way have decided to stray permanently. I found the clarity thing was informative and frankly wonder if anyone else has discovered the same........Perhaps I am just CRAZY :banana::dunno:
 
I have tried the same drivers in both OB and the BLH a pair of Fostex FE206 with Planet 10 mods. the drivers shine in the BLH and do well in the OB. I would have to guess it has something to do with the back wave........That is simply a guess though. I have smaller BLH (madisound BLH16, using the fostex sigma 168e) that are no where near as clean and clear as the Madisons this could have to do with break in. Fostex are notorious for the extended break in required
That's interesting. Love the openness of open baffle bass (first discovered with Magnepans 40 years ago), and the spaciousness of the mid and up, but it makes sense to me that there are tradeoffs, especially as described with the variations of distance to the wall, etc. Sometimes I am tempted to put some absorption behind dipole speakers - again tradeoffs. The original Quad 57 electrostatics have absorption of the back wave built in - it might make them more suitable to a variety of rooms and positioning. The experimenting never ends - enjoy!
 
When you run the signal through a passive crossover you can expect a loss of clarity and detail.

I personally have never used a passive crossover I have a Marchand active which was a revelation. I have gone back and forth with it as well using. and not, when not, I run the drivers Full Range and use a crown xls1002 for the bass cutting in typically between 100 and 250. I had been running minimalist no pre-amp direct from DAC to Amps I instead ran from DAc to Marschand then to amps the sound was much cleaner though not as clear as the BLH. It was like the FR drivers were opened up they were playing from 150 and up...............Taking the low end load off them in this instance did improve the SQ
 
No need to apologize. I've had success integrating a tweeter and larger full range driver powered by the same amp. In this picture a single 1.5uF cap on the tweeter positive filters out the LF. The Zeniths run full range powered by a SET amp while the H-frame Alphas are powered by their own plate amp which of course has a built in crossover. Bi-amping is the key. Another option I like is using an active crossover combined with a stereo amp to filter the HF but only on the woofers.

View attachment 1847234

Interestingly I'm running pretty much the same crossover point with a 1uf Duelund RS-Cu + 0.47uf Arizona Blue Cactus on my tweeters. I found this gave the best results for me and that cap choice is very natural. It forgoes the sparkle of Cornell Dubillier SF + Duelund JAM but blends seamlessly with the Lii Audio FAST-10S fullrange

Hate to say if but I found the weak spot on the OB........................Clarity. The openness and holographic soundstage are wonderful but clarity has remained an issue for me. That nail was driven home last night. Listening to my Cardersound Madison V2 BLH (still single drivers) playing Willie Nelson Midnight Rider the wife and I were both struck by a level of clarity I had not experienced previous. We could both HEAR with absolute clarity the Texas accent in Willies voice. This is a song I have loved since childhood and never before had I heard it in quite the same way. It remains to be seen if this will be cause for me to make a permanent move. The difference is undeniable..............

Hmmm, that is odd. I find the clarity and detail of my open backs surpass that of any box speakers I've heard.... The Lii Audio FAST-10S are augmented in treble and bass regions though with Lii Audio W15 woofers, and Aurum Cantus G3Si + Skar Audio VX1ST tweeters though I suspect I probably sacrifice a little of the openness due to the cabinet design of mine. Heck, ribbon placement likely sacrifices a little imaging precision also.

I believe the tweeters are most responsible for the added clarity. Nothing quite competes with a quality ribbon. ;)
 
Here's a quote from Jacob George designer of world class Rethm Speakers.

"Use the wide bander as a wide bander with no restrictions whatsoever. No filters and just bring in the bass to fill in what the wide bander cannot do".
 
Here's a quote from Jacob George designer of world class Rethm Speakers.

"Use the wide bander as a wide bander with no restrictions whatsoever. No filters and just bring in the bass to fill in what the wide bander cannot do".

I do that.... Though also fill in up top with super tweeters. Heck, my woofer doesn't even really need to be limited either. Ended up removing the coils I'd tried with them.
 
Back
Top Bottom