• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

On over all design choices...let me add from my experience that the larger the baffles get, the more they intrude into the way they sound in the room. Kind of a divider almost between the front and back radiation pattern.

The reason for bigger, is to address how you're getting bass which also involves how low you're attempting to go with it. A choice depending on if the OB is it...or if you intend to add a separate subwoofer to augment. Too small to none-existent and it's probably going to need support way higher...or it's got a big way up woofer that rolls kind of soon even for it's size.

A number of ways to get bass and even at that, some just are happy with the really nice imaging and soundstage of mids and lack of resonances and don't worry about the lower freq's at all. All valid if it makes you happy and gives you reproduction that works. The point is that once you get rid of all the reflections of the box that when used to it, you'll not ever want to go back!

EV3

I did wonder about the effect of some of the largest open baffle baffles. I didn't think of the term "room divider," but that was what I was thinking. I even wondered if the next step would be mounting the speakers in a wall with their backsides in a different room of good size.

At first, the idea of open baffles might seem to be based on a kind of simplicity, but some of the designs don't go in that direction.
 
That's exactly what a baffle is, isn't it? :dunno:



So if the divider is too small, and the the two radiation patterns meet . . . . . ohhhhh, noooooo!

I hope it's not like matter and anti-matter meeting, but I'm guessing, if we saw a picture of it, we'd see eddies, like when the waters of two rivers converge (or at least criss-crossing ripples as when two rocks are tossed in a pond at the same time).

So, the speakers-on-upright-ironing-boards OB designers, don't care if they get those eddies. Those scamps!


.
 
That's exactly what a baffle is, isn't it? :dunno:

It the strictest since maybe so. But if you get like a 4 X 4 foot sheet on each side, then you really feel the size in the room and in the audio. I was trying to convey what words can't really do well...but you can hear.

With about 22-24" wide, up to about 4 foot tall, I never get the impression of the baffle being in the way like the bigger sizes I've tried. Like the Spatial Audio designs that are almost that wide but shorter. I'm simply taller as I wanted my line of four 8" drivers to be pretty close to centered on listening height. I do use a minimal amount of tilt back and do feel the image height is "proper" for what I like.

EV3
 
It the strictest since maybe so. But if you get like a 4 X 4 foot sheet on each side, then you really feel the size in the room and in the audio. I was trying to convey what words can't really do well...but you can hear.

With about 22-24" wide, up to about 4 foot tall, I never get the impression of the baffle being in the way like the bigger sizes I've tried. Like the Spatial Audio designs that are almost that wide but shorter. I'm simply taller as I wanted my line of four 8" drivers to be pretty close to centered on listening height. I do use a minimal amount of tilt back and do feel the image height is "proper" for what I like.

EV3

It's interesting that there are hyper-technical approaches to doing this, and then there is either an alternate approach (or a point of departure) when people, like you are doing it by feel.

22" x 48" makes me think of the first pair of Magnapan speakers I ever saw/heard. Though I believe they were somewhat taller. Not that I had any sense of where the drivers were in them or even if there were something that could be called drivers in them -- ha, ha.
 
That's exactly what a baffle is, isn't it? :dunno:
Why would one expect a woofer to do anything usefull in a non cabinet to to anything?

I would never bothered going to Led Zeppelin , Rolling Stone, Deep Purple concerts etc in the 70s if they used non baffle enclosures.
 
So if the divider is too small, and the the two radiation patterns meet . . . . . ohhhhh, noooooo!
I hope it's not like matter and anti-matter meeting...
It's exactly like matter and anti-matter meeting. The rear wave is out of phase with the forward wave and when the two meet they cancel out.
...but I'm guessing, if we saw a picture of it, we'd see eddies, like when the waters of two rivers converge (or at least criss-crossing ripples as when two rocks are tossed in a pond at the same time).
Yes, something like that. The edge of the baffle acts like a secondary source and produces an interference pattern with the sound coming directly from the driver.
jd_beugung2.gif
 
It's exactly like matter and anti-matter meeting. The rear wave is out of phase with the forward wave and when the two meet they cancel out.

Yes, something like that. The edge of the baffle acts like a secondary source and produces an interference pattern with the sound coming directly from the driver.
jd_beugung2.gif


When I was little and misbehaving a bit, Mom would say I was going through a phase. Of course, if I was misbehaving badly, she had other words and responses to it. After that, I felt rather out of phase.



.
 

Attachments

  • 6120B729-2D29-4015-9691-656DB7A683DF.jpeg
    6120B729-2D29-4015-9691-656DB7A683DF.jpeg
    83.5 KB · Views: 59
  • 03640943-76CD-4D7A-AFEE-DA7219435690.jpeg
    03640943-76CD-4D7A-AFEE-DA7219435690.jpeg
    102 KB · Views: 59
New Question for the group

I am trying some different things with the PAP Trio TB Clones. where are you crossing over your bass Drivers ? I know most Klipsch heritage cross over in the 4 to 600 range. The Eminence alphas specs say they are good for 46 up to 3500 HZ. One of the PAP claims is that there woofers are game changers in the mid bass adding to there improved sound etc...etc...etc...

I have been crossing over at 110 up to 160 trying to keep vocals off the Alphas, Now I a experimenting a bit with that Keeping the FR drivers at FR and crossing only the bass Right now I am trying 400HZ sound seems fuller but every once and a while I get some ODD harmonics (That could easily be room related). I am going to add more power to the FR drivers today and see what bumping the Bass cut off farther up the scale does. I did ask PAP what they crossed over at but did not get a response. I am stuck experimenting I guess. Also I dont think PAP will sell just there woofers any longer. I was on there site last night and it said something to the effect that only using in there designs now.

So where do you guys cross you bass drivers ? Anyone tried crossing at higher rates ? What were your impressions ?
 
in my OB setup (now put away for a move) i crossed the FR and the Eminence Alphas at about 100. i used a miniDSP with DIRAC as the crossover so could correct for room and adjust the slopes for each driver.
 
I downplay the idea of comb filtering TBH. I allow for a some decent overlap between my LF drivers and higher. Probably more than some would recommend. My low pass filter on my woofers is around 170hz? I think? But I am running 10" woofers as well. I'm not sure how it works with 15"/18" drivers when it comes to higher frequencies.
 
martin j king recommends against running the FR driver full range. he thinks the overlap with the helper woofer sounds unnatural.
 
martin j king recommends against running the FR driver full range. he thinks the overlap with the helper woofer sounds unnatural.

This has been my thinking / experience to now, but when I read about Pure Audio Projects Trio they get all gooey over the bass integration and stand proudly extolling just how much better there NEO eminence drivers are. I asked the very pinpoint ? to PAP about the Bass and just how much improvement someone could actually expect being that low in the Bass region. That email ended our conversation, They did not apparently feel the need to discuss further. My thinking has been since that they must cross higher to improve on midbass in order to get all these glowing reviews and people saying how amazing there bass is etc... Basically they peeked my interest just enough to experiment beyond what I have found over the past 20 years of running a 2 way system of either a full range in OB or a front loaded horn in 2 way
 
martin j king recommends against running the FR driver full range. he thinks the overlap with the helper woofer sounds unnatural.

He and I don't agree on that. In my systems some of the magic of the FR and SET amp combo is lost once a passive or active is inserted in the signal path. It's not as noticeable with solid state amps and that's all he uses. I was using the F.A.S.T. system before I knew it had a name.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom