• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Poultrygeist what problems would I incur using two different drivers like a an 8 alnico and a mark audio 12p if the base isn't there I could run a sub out of my dbx 120x ....

They are both different sounding full range drivers so you should pick the one that sounds best to you. You don't want them competing with each other in the same system. To augment the bass you can use a separately powered OB bass woofer or sub.
 
You should get way more bass out of your Nirvana with the substantially higher Qts.
the nirvana only has 1.0mm on the Xmax, so it won't be able to handle equalization to boost bass, looks like you will need to depend on a separate
OB or sub for the low end as Poultry said, but with that addition, you could have a really nice setup. You are on the cusp of a great adventure!
 
PG Can you share the info on that inductor and what the cut off for the low end was using it. I would like to add a passive Inductor for my Emerald Physics bass at around 200 Hz cant seem to find the info

Did you try a search? There are a number of crossover calculators available online.
 
The reason I built these, was that I purchased a TT from a guy who had OB's & I'd never heard of them before, let alone see them!
I had a pair of 12" Vintage Philips full-range, and thought, for the cost of some wood, I'd give it a go.
And after you confirmed that they would indeed 'work' as OB's, I proceeded.

So then, the review:

Everything I've come to expect from my listening experience was present; imaging, soundstage, instrument seperation. The bass was suprisingly present.
The mids & highs were more pronounced than my main speakers, and overall, the experience was pleasant.


The one thing that I think sums up these is that, I will have to "choose" what to listen to. It will be have to be Jazz, female vocals, or some classical. The piano track I listened to was outstanding.

With my mains, I can put what ever I want on. With these OB's, I have to choose the music.

Perhaps this is common with members with more than one set of speakers? They choose the speakers that will best suit the music they want to listen to?

Anyway, for the cost, a worth-while experiment.

Cheers for the direction.
 
The reason I built these, was that I purchased a TT from a guy who had OB's & I'd never heard of them before, let alone see them!
I had a pair of 12" Vintage Philips full-range, and thought, for the cost of some wood, I'd give it a go.
And after you confirmed that they would indeed 'work' as OB's, I proceeded.

So then, the review:

Everything I've come to expect from my listening experience was present; imaging, soundstage, instrument seperation. The bass was suprisingly present.
The mids & highs were more pronounced than my main speakers, and overall, the experience was pleasant.


The one thing that I think sums up these is that, I will have to "choose" what to listen to. It will be have to be Jazz, female vocals, or some classical. The piano track I listened to was outstanding.

With my mains, I can put what ever I want on. With these OB's, I have to choose the music.

Perhaps this is common with members with more than one set of speakers? They choose the speakers that will best suit the music they want to listen to?

Anyway, for the cost, a worth-while experiment.

Cheers for the direction.

Single drivers limit one's choice of music. Once you add multiple drivers OB's become proficient at reproducing more complex music.
 
I have experimented a LOT 6 or 8 different FR Drivers which included Lowther PM4a, Lowther PM6a, Voxativ 1.6, Tang Bang 1808 (current), Lii fast 8 coming in today, Zenith, Audio Nirvana, and more. Placement has been anywhere from 2 feet out to 4.5 feet from the front wall. This is not something stated lightly, I dare say Open Baffle has stuck around my system longer than 99 percent of the speakers I have owned (They remain today trading in and out with the Cardersound Madisons). I have tried several baffle sizes as well and several configurations with and without crossover using Full Range or 100 up HZ only to take stress off the FR and save cross over overlap. It is reality that NO SPEAKER on the planet is PERFECT they all fall short somewhere 10.00 to 200,000.00 they all have a weakness. That does not make them BAD. Im stating a FACT in my system YMMV



joespride, May 9, 2020Report
#

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
OK Here we go, My VERY 1st post on ~~~AudioKharma~~~~ Very Very glad to be here, WOW a real LIVE audio chat forum, very active, very informative and everyone is cool.
Can't ask for more.

I just came off **another audio forum** which was pretty much a bore, hardly anyone, maybe 1 menber,,has no interest in Wide Band/Full Range/High Sensitivity speakers.
WOW here there is a longggg running topic on my ONLY fav speakers, ~The New High Tech Wide band~~
You can read all my dozens of recent posts over on *that other forum~~ I go under the name mozartfan.
Anyway.
Joespride and i , have alot in common, I too bought several ,,well cheap,, chinese,,**fulll* band speakers, Just for test purposes only, 2 pairs sold aftera few days testing, less than 1/2 price,,,Anyway, Long story short, ]
Today I just placed a order with Voxativ for their newest AC1A's.
Should be in end of next week and hopefully my tech and I can put some cabinet together, part Voxativ's plans and part my ideas.
I am a HUGE fan of Wide Band the new labs that is, which we also tag as *Full Range * and high(er) sensitivity speakers..
Just a few notes /comments/opinions/dogmas
having been around audio off/on past 40 years, I've finally realized Higher Sensitivity is THE ONLY speaker for my musical genre, all classical, chamber to full symphonic orchestra.
Having recently upgraded my Seas Thors with new Millennium tweeters after 20 trs use, light us and installing brand new Mundorf HIGH quality/expensive caps, , The reulst were a HUGE let down in the tweeter,,??? HUH, what happened...I thought I'd havea super high fidelity sound, = out of pocket some $1200+. The W18E001's I am still using, but the Millennium is gone, sold $300 pair brand new'/paid $700. Replaced witha DavidLouis 4 inch full range,, Much much better vs the Millennium. And also runninga KASUN double magnet paper cone 3.5 tweeter, not bad.
Anyway.
Long story short
The new high tech wide bands are The 21st C speaker
Wide bnad high(er) sensitivity offers a musical image which xover/traditional speakers can not compete.
Some of the previous wide band, Fostex/Loqwther had roll off issues in the highs/bass.
These roll offs have been addressed in these new (since 2010!!!!!!!!!!!!) are far superior vs the older models.
I could never go back to xovers. Now if I need extra basss, I have the Seas dual W18E001's with the Mundorf simple xover thats IF the Voxativ comes up short in the punch.
Its only a matter of time before these new wide band begin to make their name/reputation known among audiophile groups.
There still remains quite a large group completely totally committed to *The Old School* of xovers, And they have no intentions of accepting something they can not understand.

Glad to be here, Mostly I chat speaker/wide band.
As we all know speakers is the heart and soul of the voice of the sound.
And for me, Wide band are King of all designs,.
 
ingle drivers limit one's choice of music. Once you add multiple drivers OB's become proficient at reproducing more complex music.

Poultrygeist, Jun 14, 2021

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Yes note all the YT videos on SET/Wide Band/High Sensitivity speakers.
Mostly simply easy jaz, nothing complex,
Thing is most of my music is complex heavy full symphonic orchestra.
So I will putting the oxativ 's to the real test,
will test with 3 amps.
My Defy 7 with Mundorf SESGO caps/F&T caps.
The other 2 amps are of my tech geeks designs, His Dyanco Mark4 EL34 amp, and his SET250 amp.
After cabinets are built and all good to go, I will upload several YT vids showing how each performed with different genres of music.
But I sure as heck will never go back to xover designs in midrange/highs
In Bass fq's, I have no issues at all with the lower sens drivers/xover designs, Its in the 800hz-15khz that I will not accept xover designs/drivers.
I'm done with those dinasaurs.
 
The one thing that I think sums up these is that, I will have to "choose" what to listen to. It will be have to be Jazz, female vocals, or some classical. The piano track I listened to was outstanding.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Its for this reason i will not be usinga SET amp with the Voxativ, although as we know SET's work well with high sens speakers,
Yet when I read up on SET experiences/opinions,,, they are hush about its performance on complex heavy classical orchestra.
Most likely the EL34 lower watt amps would be the ideal amplifier for Wide band speakers.
I have too many upgrades in the Def7 and will keep it as main amp.
We will see how that match comes off.
Might work out acutally.
 
I am still using a Single Driver Full Range but they happen to be either the Lii Audio F-15 or the Lii Audio F-18 they are true full range ie....GOOD bass without Augmentation. That does not mean one can not Augment top or bottom. I still do some on bass with the F-15 as there is simply some music that "I WANT" the extra thump. I have not personally found a genre that I can not get great results. I have my Favorites which of course I will swear sound better but I am not complaining on anything I listen to except for a poor recording.

I do agree that 8" full range drivers benefit from augmentation mainly on Bass. I have experienced driver breakup on complex tracks using various 8" FR Drivers. Not so much now
 
Here is my system, The lil DavidLouis 4 inch is OK, only paid $170/pair.
Not worth any more than 170.
can't wait til the Voxativ arrives.

 
I am still using a Single Driver Full Range but they happen to be either the Lii Audio F-15 or the Lii Audio F-18 they are true full range ie....GOOD bass without Augmentation. That does not mean one can not Augment top or bottom. I still do some on bass with the F-15 as there is simply some music that "I WANT" the extra thump. I have not personally found a genre that I can not get great results. I have my Favorites which of course I will swear sound better but I am not complaining on anything I listen to except for a poor recording.

I do agree that 8" full range drivers benefit from augmentation mainly on Bass. I have experienced driver breakup on complex tracks using various 8" FR Drivers. Not so much now

joespride, Today at 5:24 P

Hey Joe
I can see you and I have alot ij common, tastes.
I can tell.
You have my sense of *lets see how we can make this all work out* DIYer of sorts, like myself.
I have no issues joining up a woofer witha wide band for that extra low end, Not at all.
I'm not expecting THE ULTIMATE from the Voxativ AC1A's,.
I have the Seas dual W18E001's from the Thor + The Mundorf high end caps which add a solid OUNCH to the bass. Rock Solid.

btw, I had the Fast8 LII, the old model, I hated it, sold it off next day 1/2 price. YUCKKK
I really don't like any chinese full range. davidLouis has some Voxativ clones, I'm sure at $500 they are **accceptable**, But I'd rather go the 2k's and get The Real Deal.

I see you have much experience in all things audio. far more than I.
All i do know is xovers/traditional speakers in the 800hz-15khz, range is not my cup of tea.
I see xover designs as Dinasaurs.
Exception to he rule are the s
Seas and Scan speak woofers for bass , IF needed with wide band.
Not sure, wait and see when they arrive.
Those high end woofers come at a price once you add in Mundorf high end caps.
 
Back
Top Bottom