• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

So I drove to this guys house, to collect a Thorens TD160MkII TT. As with all visits to pick up hi-fi stuff, it's always interesting to see their set-ups.....

The thing is, he had this wierd, truncated triangle contraption, completely open at the back! When I asked what it was, he replied; "It's an open-baffle" (Like I knew what that was?). Six months have passed - very happy with the new TT, and you now see me, knee high in cardboard & gaffer tape, trying to test-run my first OB's. Using 12" Philips AD12022 full range drivers.

Strangely captivating noise they produce.......

open baffle test.JPG
 
Don’t know if it’s been mentioned in this thread, but Accarion Systems- Alon’s & Nola are for the most part open baffle designs. My Alon IV’s are open baffle mid and tweets and sealed large box 12’s for the bass.
Open baffle mids/tweeters with box bass drivers makes a lot of sense, but Siegfried Linkwitz claimed that OB for the bass is essential for "proper" OB sound. I have to concede that he knew what he was talking about so I wouldn't argue with his opinion.
 
Last edited:
I don't know. Is there any supporting evidence that it works?
I actually thought that I heard a difference, but it may be a system dependent sort of thing. I don't have scientific data to prove or dis-prove,
but I shared in case someone wanted to try for themselves. It is not something that will cause harm, even if it seemed to have no effect:music:
 
Open baffle mids/tweeters with box bass drivers makes a lot of sense, but Siegfried Linkwitz claimed that OB for the bass is essential for "proper" OB sound. I have to concede that he new what he was talking about so I wouldn't argue with his opinion.
I don’t know... all subjective, I tried A&B comparisons to replace my Alon’s with magnapans, watt puppy’s and several others.. my sound stage has a taste of that magnapan 3d haunting seduction while still able to hit 19hrz @ 101db. Carl Marchisotto is no slouch either. Personally after spending a lot of time with Spacial audio turbo3S, I’ll keep a closed bass. (Take that measurement with a grain of salt, it was a YouTube video of 19hrz tone and an iPhone spl app)

https://www.psaudio.com/copper/article/talking-with-carl-marchisotto-of-nola-loudspeakers/
 
Last edited:
What's the copper ground deal? :dunno:
I as dimly understand the idea, it is basically a ground sink, or reservoir for your ground. The engineer fellow that mentioned it to me said that it
could add clarity to the sound if applied to your speakers. He said it made a difference on his speakers, so I got a copper bar off ebay, and added it to the
ground of my speakers, and I honestly thought that it opened up the sound when I tried it, so I have left it in place. It may be a system dependent sort of thing
but it cost me less than $20 to try it out, so I gave it a shot. My copper bar in each cabinet is roughly 3 1/4 by 1 1/4 inches and 3/16 inches thick, connected to the
ground of the speakers. I mounted mine inside the cabinet, but you could just attach it at the ground terminal outside your speaker if you wanted to give it a try.
It seemed to be worthwhile on my home brew speakers, so I just tossed it out for everyone. I have been told its ridiculous, and I can take that, but it is much
less expensive than some of the $$ ideas I have seen. All I can say is that it was worth while in my case:music:
 
I'm not a big fan of the way boxed bass pressurizes a room which to me is a bit unnatural. Linkwitz states that open baffle bass is more accurate and that's been my experience. If I needed visceral impact and room penetrating bass I would add a boxed subwoofer.

PA020015.jpeg
 
24" OB subwoofer by Stereo Integrity.
The King of OB subs.
5Wj0vrZ.jpg

HRC80MM.jpg

oA65nI5.jpg
 
Not really one for semantics, But I am having trouble seeing the 24" Stereo Integrity Sub pictured as true OB........................ Can you share some info on the design, web site etc...

Ill bet it thumps
 
Although "happy" with the way my initial experiments (with cardboard), are going, it's not yet, the real deal.
Using a H90cm x W80cm baffle (34" x 31"), will the final speaker be "chalk 'n' cheese" from where I am now.

Using a vintage 12" Philips full range 8Ω / 98db / 0,8w@96db powered by EL84/ECC82 tube amp

I'm not that good with wood, so I'm going to have to employ someone to make the baffles - OK, it's no rocket science for a half-decent carpenter, but it's still +€150.

Before this leap of faith, some reassurance that what I'm hearing from a cardboard mock-up, is only a fraction of what the end result will perform like.

Cheers as always.
 
Although "happy" with the way my initial experiments (with cardboard), are going, it's not yet, the real deal.
Using a H90cm x W80cm baffle (34" x 31"), will the final speaker be "chalk 'n' cheese" from where I am now.

Using a vintage 12" Philips full range 8Ω / 98db / 0,8w@96db powered by EL84/ECC82 tube amp

I'm not that good with wood, so I'm going to have to employ someone to make the baffles - OK, it's no rocket science for a half-decent carpenter, but it's still +€150.

Before this leap of faith, some reassurance that what I'm hearing from a cardboard mock-up, is only a fraction of what the end result will perform like.

Cheers as always.

Don't know what you're hearing or if the Phillips driver is a good OB candidate?
 
Not really one for semantics, But I am having trouble seeing the 24" Stereo Integrity Sub pictured as true OB........................ Can you share some info on the design, web site etc...

Ill bet it thumps

It is open baffle/dipole the same as an H or U frame, the design allows for a more compact subwoofer while providing greater path length before the front and rear waves cause cancellation.

https://www.linkwitzlab.com/woofer.htm
 
Don't know what you're hearing or if the Phillips driver is a good OB candidate?
You don't need to know what I'm hearing or how good a particular driver is...

All I need, is for someone who has gone through the process of mocking-up an OB with cardboard, to describe the difference between the sound of the mock-up, and the sound of the fully completed wooden unit.

Cheers.
 
You don't need to know what I'm hearing or how good a particular driver is...

All I need, is for someone who has gone through the process of mocking-up an OB with cardboard, to describe the difference between the sound of the mock-up, and the sound of the fully completed wooden unit.

Cheers.

If it sounds good in cardboard it will also sound good in wood but don't expect a night and day difference. Single full range drivers in OB's without a high Qts score will sound thin and no type or amount of baffle will make much of a difference. If you know the Qts rating it would help. A Qts of 1.0 and higher means the full range driver is a good candidate for OB's. A Qts of 0.7 is about as low as I'd consider without helper woofers.
 
I tried these full range Tang Band drivers ( Qts. 0.44 ) in the folding wing baffles and while the highs and mids were good there was no appreciable bass. In the same baffles the full range WBAL Betsy drivers ( Qts. .783 ) produced acceptable bass.

P2270031.jpeg
 
I took those same Tang Bands placed on flat baffles above H frame high Qts woofers and marveled at the sound. ( wife's sunroom and not my listening room ).

P9160028.jpeg
 
If it sounds good in cardboard it will also sound good in wood but don't expect a night and day difference. Single full range drivers in OB's without a high Qts score will sound thin and no type or amount of baffle will make much of a difference. If you know the Qts rating it would help. A Qts of 1.0 and higher means the full range driver is a good candidate for OB's. A Qts of 0.7 is about as low as I'd consider without helper woofers.

I can go online and calculate qts, but first I need other specs. The only thing I've managed to find is this data sheet from Philips. Is there enough data on this for the QTS to be calculated?
The AD12000/m8 dual-cone 12" with "whizzer" is the one I need, but as luck would have it, I have the P8 lying around in a box. The 'P' variant is said to be also suited to 'open' applications.

It's costing me nothing at the moment, just some fun. If I can get a QTS figure, as you suggest, then I'll progress. The sound is really quite nice, with still enough bass for my liking - especially whilst listening to jazz or female vocals.

Thanks for any guidance. And if the speakers get shot down in flames at this juncture, then so be it. Thanks
AD12202P8_p1.jpg
 
Is there enough data on this for the QTS to be calculated?
You don't need to calculate it - it's there on the data sheet. "Quality factor, loudspeaker mounted in recommended enclosure - 0.81"
Given Qms and Qes you can calculate Qts. 1/Qms + 1/Qes = 1/Qts
Qms is the Q of the mechanical system.
Qes is the Q of the electrical system.
Qts is the Q of the total system.
There's plenty of info online if you'd like to do some research. Here's one page for starters:
http://www.mh-audio.nl/Loudspeaker.html
 
Back
Top Bottom