• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

So your Zenith 852's still rule :)
I still like my old what ever they are 12 inch Alnico's that came out of the GE Vacu-Magic console. Would love to know what the heck they are though.
Going to try a pair of Tang Band' W8-2145's somewhere, but not sure where yet. It is always fun to try new stuff! Thanks for sharing!
Den
 
The Zeniths rule at my house. Not the 852's which are slightly newer but identical versions of my 802's. I believe the 49CZ802 to be the original design based on it's lower model number and 1957 year of production. I was very fortunate to come by these Zeniths which are as mint as I've seen. It could be that some examples won't sound as good as alnico's can lose their charge over time and use.

P1010010 2.jpeg
 
PG, do you find that the rear facing tweeter is beneficial?

I sometimes find myself turning off the front facing one I've got, depending on what I'm listening to.

Do you know of any alternatives to the Radio Shack?

Thanks,
Frank
 
PG, do you find that the rear facing tweeter is beneficial?

I sometimes find myself turning off the front facing one I've got, depending on what I'm listening to.

Do you know of any alternatives to the Radio Shack?

Thanks,
Frank

The front firing Eminence ASD 1001 ( same tweeter used in the newer version of the Zu Omens ) is a little too hot for my tastes and I could never seem to pad it down enough. When I added the Realistic super tweeters firing to the rear wired out of phase as an experiment they perfectly balanced or perhaps reduced the output of the ASD's. If you are using the ASD's or another closed back tweeter I would try them firing to the rear. I remember Danny of GR Research once explaining to me that if using a single closed back tweeter in OB's it should be rear firing. If that doesn't work I think any tweeter with the same sensitivity as the Realistic would work in it's place. It's sensitivity is pretty high but I don't recall how high.

My inspiration to use the ASD tweeter came from this build.

https://speakerprojects.wordpress.com/2016/08/29/eminence-beta-12lta-on-open-baffle/
 
The Zeniths may not look special but alnico motors are expensive and uncommon in modern drivers. The frames are massive but the whole driver doesn't weigh much. In their original baffles they were rear mounted which wouldn't work with a heavy driver. The ridges cover about two thirds of the cone and there are no surrounds like you'd find on conventional drivers. The deep ridges extent all the way to the edge of the cone. The outer gasket which was necessary for rear mounting is an ugly beige color which looks much better painted flat black. I've tried a number of highly rated drivers atop the H-frames which didn't come close.

P1010013.jpeg
 
I hugged my OB's today! I tried a pair of the Tang Band's, but they cannot play in the same league as my unknown Alnico's. The best way I can describe them
in comparison to my Alnico's, with the Tang's you have sound and the taxidermy people did a good job stuffing the sound's carcass, but it is only a life like carcass.
With my Alnico's the sound is still breathing and ALIVE!!!
I am done buying new speakers!
 
ordinary, nothing-special drivers

Actually, I wasn't referring to the Zeniths, which, I agree, are pretty special.

I meant these. I wasn't clear in that last post.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20210423_2040250.jpg
    IMG_20210423_2040250.jpg
    61.3 KB · Views: 37
  • IMG_20210423_2040083.jpg
    IMG_20210423_2040083.jpg
    71.6 KB · Views: 35
Well I was kinda hard on the new Tang Band's the other day, so after some thinking, I re-organized them thusly.
I still don't think that they render detail as clearly as my Alnico's, so I dropped them down into my lower cabinet,
and put my Alnico's back in the top cabinet, so I listen to the Alnico's on axis, and the Tang's are off axis. I changed my tweeter
from a 3/4 inch cloth dome to a 1 inch Mylar dome Phillips tweeter, and crossed the tweeter over around 7K. The Mylar
is crisper sounding than the cloth dome. The Mylar I have had at least 40 years, but it still sings just fine having never
been abused. The Alnico's and Tang's run full range.
Off axis, the Tang's add a nice atmospheric presence, while my Alnico's supply the clear detail. For now, I can't see a better
use of the Tang's, and I really am not disappointed that I got them.
I use a modified Nelson Pass Amp Camp amp, around 8 watts a channel max, though I probably never use more than a watt.
It has plenty of power for me. My Pre is a modified Superphon CD Maxx , which is a basic Mosfet line stage from the mind of
Stan Warren of Superphon, and before that the "S" of PS Audio. Time to just do some listening................
 

Attachments

  • new arrangement.JPG
    new arrangement.JPG
    117.9 KB · Views: 31
Well I was kinda hard on the new Tang Band's the other day, so after some thinking, I re-organized them thusly.
I still don't think that they render detail as clearly as my Alnico's, so I dropped them down into my lower cabinet,
and put my Alnico's back in the top cabinet, so I listen to the Alnico's on axis, and the Tang's are off axis. I changed my tweeter
from a 3/4 inch cloth dome to a 1 inch Mylar dome Phillips tweeter, and crossed the tweeter over around 7K. The Mylar
is crisper sounding than the cloth dome. The Mylar I have had at least 40 years, but it still sings just fine having never
been abused. The Alnico's and Tang's run full range.
Off axis, the Tang's add a nice atmospheric presence, while my Alnico's supply the clear detail. For now, I can't see a better
use of the Tang's, and I really am not disappointed that I got them.
I use a modified Nelson Pass Amp Camp amp, around 8 watts a channel max, though I probably never use more than a watt.
It has plenty of power for me. My Pre is a modified Superphon CD Maxx , which is a basic Mosfet line stage from the mind of
Stan Warren of Superphon, and before that the "S" of PS Audio. Time to just do some listening................

If the TBs are new they'll definitely require break in.
 
Last edited:
I know I'm repeating myself but if by chance you come across one of these buy it. This Zenith record player from the 1950's contains two 12 inch 49CZ802 alnico's and two 8 inch alnico wide band drivers. There are also two alnico tweeters on board which I've never tried. The 8 inch alnico's are excellent but their identifying model numbers were blacked out on mine. They perform so well they deserve their own OB's which is what I use in the garage. I paid $35 for the console but at the time had no idea of what I had. Don't think they can be that expensive today as it's tube amp is mono and has this heavy tone arm Cobramatic changer. It's a record player only and has no radio.

file.php
 
The 8" Zeniths are way too good for garage speakers but I've run out of room in the house. I'm using an Ashly active crossover with them because the amps are class D.

P1010014.jpeg
 
The 8" Zeniths are way too good for garage speakers but I've run out of room in the house. I'm using an Ashly active crossover with them because the amps are class D.

View attachment 2220038
PG,
That console,what a find!!! I will keep my eyes peeled :) The people making the old Alnico's still knew the deep magic.
Sophistication is not the equal of wisdom.
The Tang's are mellowing, in fact the arrangement is sounding pretty good. Just need more time to sit and hear them
break in.
Den
 
It is kinda quiet, is everyone just listening:music:
revision.JPG
For the record, my speakers are a combo of an old Klipsch Heresy's and an additional bottom cabinet that I added. Previously I had
replaced the original cabinet backs with pegboard. We have a couple cats that live with us, and I needed a way to sort of be
open baffle, but also a way to keep out kitty paws. Recently I started wondering that if even though the pegboard is obviously filled with
holes, could it actually act as though it were being actually a ported enclosure? I went to the trouble of calculating the area of all of the holes,
approximately 1/4 of an inch sized for each hole for each cabinet back,
and coming up with the area of the combined holes, and using the depth of the cabinet, as the theoretical length of the
port X the area, and it came out to be roughly a ported enclosure tuned to about 33-35 Hz for both the larger and smaller bottom cabinet.

Now all of this may be out in the Ort Cloud, but in case it had any validity, I decided to replace the backs of the cabinet with metal lath, which is
way more porous than pegboard. I still need a barrier for kitties!
Aside from the lath screening being a bit hairy to work with, I believe that my speakers did benefit sound wise from the change. Sound is
more open, an improvement to my ears. I also added in the back, two 3 inch Alnico tweeters in each top cabinet, wired in opposite phase to my front 1 inch
Mylar dome tweeter. All the tweeters are crossed over around 6-7K with a capacitor. The tweeters are of the same 1960's vintage of my 12 Alnico
driver's in the top cabinet, and I have an 8 inch Tang Band in the bottom cabinet. I like the sound of the Tang better off axis, so that is why it is in the bottom.
Both the 12 inch and Tang run full range. So that is the state of the speaker here. Next project is building a new tube preamp to see if it can unseat my
current daily SS pre. If not, I can certainly live with my SS, but sometimes you just have to try :thumbsup:!

Oh, one more idea to toss out...An engineer acquaintance once shared this idea with me. Add a copper bar to your speaker ground. Mine
in each cabinet is 3 1/2 X 1 1/4 inch and 3/16th of an inch thick. Actual dimensions are not critical, but he had told me that it would improve
the sound of your speakers. I bought the bar off ebay for less than $20 as I recall, but for me, I could actually hear an improvement in clarity.
I mentioned it once to the fellow at Nirvana once, and he basically told me I was off the deep end, so take it all with a grain or two of salt.
Just thought I would throw it out for consumption. I promise I am not invested in copper:beerchug:

Den
 

Attachments

  • ground block2.JPG
    ground block2.JPG
    102.6 KB · Views: 31
The fun thing about open baffles is they allow for a lot of experimentation and imagination. And no matter what you come up with they can surprise you with good sound. As Linkwitz said, "it's difficult to screw up an open baffle speaker to where it sounds worse than a typical box speaker".
 
The fun thing about open baffles is they allow for a lot of experimentation and imagination. And no matter what you come up with they can surprise you with good sound. As Linkwitz said, "it's difficult to screw up an open baffle speaker to where it sounds worse than a typical box speaker".
Hi Poultry,
What do you think about the copper ground deal?
 
Don’t know if it’s been mentioned in this thread, but Accarion Systems- Alon’s & Nola are for the most part open baffle designs. My Alon IV’s are open baffle mid and tweets and sealed large box 12’s for the bass.
 
Back
Top Bottom