• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

In general I also hate about every audio product I have had or heard from China. "BUT" the F-15 and the F-18 are different. It took me a while to get over the made in China sticker. Eventually the SQ just won me over. I have discussed the drivers with a few others in Audio and every single one of them that have used the F-15 are in agreement about there qualities. They have a full SQ to them that said if you have younger ears and like Trebel above 16Khz then a tweet would be in order. I personally can not hear that high up anymore. Vocals are scary real when paired with the right gear.

Currently my system is PC running J-River 27, to SingXer SU-1, using 12s output into 12s input on my Audio GD Master 7 DAC that goes directly to my Marchand XM9 active Crossover The XM9 goes out to my SET Tube amps which powers the F-15 from 250Hz and up the Low out on the XM9 runs to a crown XLS1002 which powers my Lii W-15 woofers. I am waiting on my Trumpet MC to arrive for my Vinyl rig. I fully expect to be done with upgrades. My SQ is nearly perfect for my desired sound

That is until I find a pair of Oris 200 / 250 horns again. Then I will be building The Oris using some 8" full rangers in the horns on top of a pair of H-Frame Bass baffles. this way I can scratch all my itches (My wife is very accommodating with my audio hobby, She probably prefers it to Harley's :))
 
n general I also hate about every audio product I have had or heard from China. "BUT" the F-15 and the F-18 are different. It took me a while to get over the made in China sticker. Eventually the SQ just won me over. I have discussed the drivers with a few others in Audio and every single one of them that have used the F-15 are in agreement about there qualities. They have a full SQ to them that said if you have younger ears and like Trebel above 16Khz then a tweet would be in order. I personally can not hear that high up anymore. Vocals are scary real when paired with the right gear.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Help me out here,
SQ = ??
Are you speaking of the Lii older 15 inch woofers?? Or newer model?
 
SQ = Sound quality = high fidelity,
Reference to Lii??
I found the fast 8 old model just aweful. A guy on audiogon lives in my area, wrote he LOVES the Lii Fast 8, was cheap, so i bought a pair
Hated the sound, just aweful.
 
What's the high frequency hash/noise??? It is especially notable after 11:00 min.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Just listened at 11 - 11:30, Not sure, have no idea what you are hearing, as i say, Its my **Frankenstein** But far far far superior to Seas Millennium's 87 db tweeter.
The next big event /discovery in all audio will be The New High Tech Wide Band/FR/high sensitivity speakers,
Front and Center.
Most audiophiles have no clue they exist, how they work/sound, etc.
Will take 10 yrs to catch on.
 
I wish @opa1 would give us more information on his and why he sold them.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Its possible these 15's sound superior to their fast 8, But IMHO
All Lii havea ~~~characteristic voicing~~
Thats is to say, they all pretty much sound close.
No thanks.
Lii is hype.
And I was also looking fora good sub/bas with high sens on the budget side, so I looked at davidLouis DIATONE 10 and 12.. But then I got to thinking, His Diatone 6.5 was lousey, huge roll offs on bass and highs = trash.
So why would I expect deep bass out his 10, 12 to help out with the Voxativ in bass fqs???
My guess is the Vox bass will destroy my dual Seas W18E001's in that dept.
Sure the W18's will have more punch, thing is sens is 87, Vox is 91db+.
Higher sens always wins the shootout.
The newest and best thing is all audio are the new high tech high sens speakers/single drivers.
Speakers are the crown jewel of our system. High sens are the superior speaker for voicing high fidelity.
Xover designs are ~~ Dinasaurs~~
 
SQ = Sound quality = high fidelity,
Reference to Lii??
I found the fast 8 old model just aweful. A guy on audiogon lives in my area, wrote he LOVES the Lii Fast 8, was cheap, so i bought a pair
Hated the sound, just aweful.

I think I may have already shared these positive comments regarding the F-15 on OBs. They were evidently good enough to put his favorite Zenith alnico's in storage. That speaks volumes. I'm not close to replacing my 49CZ802s yet but it certainly gives me pause.

http://glowinthedarkaudio.com/lii-audio-f15.html

I wish @opa1 would give us more information on his and why he sold them.

https://hifihaven.org/index.php?search/104080/&q=F-15&c[title_only]=1&o=relevance

Out of curiosity, it would be interesting to know why he sold the F-15's. I have never heard the 15's, but I tried the F-12's, and I was very disappointed. I sent them back for a refund.
I preferred my unknown 12 inch Alnico hands down. To me, the F-12's sounded hollow, and sterile. Detailed, but they didn't
have the heart beat and life of my Alnico's. I have been listening to my 8 inch Tang Bands, and though they are not bad,
I think that I am going back to my old Alnico's, and will probably sell the Tangs instead of just adding to the clutter of unused stuff laying around.
Guess I just had to try something new, but the grass turns out to be greener, and softer where I already was before jumping the fence :)
 
Out of curiosity, it would be interesting to know why he sold the F-15's. I have never heard the 15's, but I tried the F-12's, and I was very disappointed. I sent them back for a refund.
I preferred my unknown 12 inch Alnico hands down. To me, the F-12's sounded hollow, and sterile. Detailed, but they didn't
have the heart beat and life of my Alnico's. I have been listening to my 8 inch Tang Bands, and though they are not bad,
I think that I am going back to my old Alnico's, and will probably sell the Tangs instead of just adding to the clutter of unused stuff laying around.
Guess I just had to try something new, but the grass turns out to be greener, and softer where I already was before jumping the fence :)

I've said many times that vintage alnico wide band drivers pulled from flea watt tube consoles can be quite special. If you're fortunate enough to find a pair in good condition that doesn't need a re-charge you've got some keepers.
 
I enjoyed these Tang Bands W8-1808 for awhile and found them nicely refined but too polite and laid back. Gorgeous drivers but sold them after picking up the Lowther DX3. The DX3 in OBs have that in-your-face jump factor and are anything but polite.

P7040015.jpeg
 
I enjoyed these Tang Bands W8-1808 for awhile and found them nicely refined but too polite and laid back. Gorgeous drivers but sold them after picking up the Lowther DX3. The DX3 in OBs have that in-your-face jump factor and are anything but polite.

View attachment 2277209
Poultry,
Are your Zenith's more forward and alive sounding in the mid-range than the Tang's were, and how do your Zenith's differ in sound to the Lowther DX3?
For me, the Tang's seemed to loose energy as you went up the frequency spectrum. They sounded polite, maybe even close to shy.
I now have my old Alnico's back on line, but I wonder what my mystery Alnico's would sound like compared to the Zenith's. It is a mystery what
the heck they are, and who made them. I guess it is the wander lust pulling on my coat tails!
On the other site, it was interesting to see the posted data on the Zenith's. They have a pair of 873's on ebay presently, though not at bargain prices.
 
Yes, the twelve inch 49CZ802 Zenith alnico's are just so much more engaging from top to bottom and with enough bass to stand on their own. Their tonality is breathtaking and I can listen to them all day. The TB's were pleasant and very smooth but laid back compared to the in-your-face Lowthers and not as detailed. The Lowthers are excessively detailed on OB's without correction and I couldn't listen for more than an hour or so without fatigue setting in. Now in MLTL cabinets with correction I can listen all day but with some loss of detail. It's all a trade off but I could see myself using the Lowthers in OB's again. I am fortunate to find my pair of mint Zeniths which sat in an elderly lady's living room console for 64 years and was rarely played. The Zenith console cost $35 and Lowther DX3 drivers go for $1300 and it's no contest to which I'd part with first.
 
I wish @opa1 would give us more information on his and why he sold them.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Its possible these 15's sound superior to their fast 8, But IMHO
All Lii havea ~~~characteristic voicing~~
Thats is to say, they all pretty much sound close.
No thanks.
Lii is hype.
And I was also looking fora good sub/bas with high sens on the budget side, so I looked at davidLouis DIATONE 10 and 12.. But then I got to thinking, His Diatone 6.5 was lousey, huge roll offs on bass and highs = trash.
So why would I expect deep bass out his 10, 12 to help out with the Voxativ in bass fqs???
My guess is the Vox bass will destroy my dual Seas W18E001's in that dept.
Sure the W18's will have more punch, thing is sens is 87, Vox is 91db+.
Higher sens always wins the shootout.
The newest and best thing is all audio are the new high tech high sens speakers/single drivers.
Speakers are the crown jewel of our system. High sens are the superior speaker for voicing high fidelity.
Xover designs are ~~ Dinasaurs~~[/QUOTE

You are "WRONG", I had the Fast 8, the Crystal 10 and still have the F-15 and the F-18, There drivers do "NOT" all sound alike. Try the drivers with an open mind and it will be very evident they each have there own sound character. A Blanket statement condemning any manufacturer's products, "without hearing them" is unfair / ill informed at best. Its like the old Lowther are schrill argument, Its BS Hyperbole.

The Fast 8 was the worst of the Lii Drivers I had / heard but it was easily on par with most of the Fostex I have heard. When I want a "Full Range" driver I take that as implying FULL RANGE................Simply put in an OB design an 8" driver can not produce bass down into the 30Hz region both the F-15 and the F-18 can do that and they can do that on a reasonable size baffle. I personally prefer the F-15 to the F-18 but that might have more to do with familiarity. It has a very nice full sound that brings vocals to lifelike in the room sound quality, while offering a nice balance from top to bottom with enough high end air for my hearing.

I am past the "Hi-Fi" Sound looking for every ounce of nuance, detail, resolution etc... My word for that sound is analytical = to lifeless, fatiguing & Dry

You are "WRONG", I had the Fast 8, the Crystal 10 and still have the F-15 and the F-18, There drivers do "NOT" all sound alike. Try the drivers with an open mind and it will be very evident they each have there own sound character. A Blanket statement condemning any manufacturer's products, "without hearing them" is unfair / ill informed at best. Its like the old Lowther are schrill argument, Its BS Hyperbole.

The Fast 8 was the worst of the Lii Drivers I had / heard but it was easily on par with most of the Fostex I have heard. When I want a "Full Range" driver I take that as implying FULL RANGE................Simply put in an OB design an 8" driver can not produce bass down into the 30Hz region both the F-15 and the F-18 can do that and they can do that on a reasonable size baffle. I personally prefer the F-15 to the F-18 but that might have more to do with familiarity. It has a very nice full sound that brings vocals to lifelike in the room sound quality, while offering a nice balance from top to bottom with enough high end air for my hearing.

I am past the "Hi-Fi" Sound looking for every ounce of nuance, detail, resolution etc... My word for that sound is analytical = to lifeless, fatiguing & Dry
 
Out of curiosity, it would be interesting to know why he sold the F-15's. I have never heard the 15's, but I tried the F-12's, and I was very disappointed. I sent them back for a refund.
I preferred my unknown 12 inch Alnico hands down. To me, the F-12's sounded hollow, and sterile. Detailed, but they didn't
have the heart beat and life of my Alnico's. I have been listening to my 8 inch Tang Bands, and though they are not bad,
I think that I am going back to my old Alnico's, and will probably sell the Tangs instead of just adding to the clutter of unused stuff laying around.
Guess I just had to try something new, but the grass turns out to be greener, and softer where I already was before jumping the fence :)

Kevin at Glow in The Dark still has his F-15's He prefers the F-18's I speak with Kevin often we compare notes on the Lii Drivers and the amps we often trade sell back and forth. Kevin has his impressions of both the F-15 and the F-18 up as well as MANY other drivers

F-18...http://www.glowinthedarkaudio.com/lii-audio-f18.html

F-15....http://www.glowinthedarkaudio.com/lii-audio-f18.html

Personally I agree with pretty much everything Kevin has to say about both drivers though as stated I prefer my 15 over my 18 and Kevin is opposite on that
 
Yes, the twelve inch 49CZ802 Zenith alnico's are just so much more engaging from top to bottom and with enough bass to stand on their own. Their tonality is breathtaking and I can listen to them all day. The TB's were pleasant and very smooth but laid back compared to the in-your-face Lowthers and not as detailed. The Lowthers are excessively detailed on OB's without correction and I couldn't listen for more than an hour or so without fatigue setting in. Now in MLTL cabinets with correction I can listen all day but with some loss of detail. It's all a trade off but I could see myself using the Lowthers in OB's again. I am fortunate to find my pair of mint Zeniths which sat in an elderly lady's living room console for 64 years and was rarely played. The Zenith console cost $35 and Lowther DX3 drivers go for $1300 and it's no contest to which I'd part with first.
Poultry,
I celebrate your fortunate find :)
If I ever become a Zenith owner, I will most likely have to part with more $$ than $35, but they will probably be worth it!
Thanks for the info on how the different speakers sound. I wish I could wrap up a viable sample of my unknowns for you to hear. I have not yet found anything to better them yet,
but I can't promise to not keep looking!
 
You are "WRONG", I had the Fast 8, the Crystal 10 and still have the F-15 and the F-18, There drivers do "NOT" all sound alike. Try the drivers with an open mind and it will be very evident they each have there own sound character. A Blanket statement condemning any manufacturer's products, "without hearing them" is unfair / ill informed at best. Its like the old Lowther are schrill argument, Its BS Hyperbole.

The Fast 8 was the worst of the Lii Drivers I had / heard but it was easily on par with most of the Fostex I have heard. When I want a "Full Range" driver I take that as implying FULL RANGE................Simply put in an OB design an 8" driver can not produce bass down into the 30Hz region both the F-15 and the F-18 can do that and they can do that on a reasonable size baffle. I personally prefer the F-15 to the F-18 but that might have more to do with familiarity. It has a very nice full sound that brings vocals to lifelike in the room sound quality, while offering a nice balance from top to bottom with enough high end air for my hearing.

I am past the "Hi-Fi" Sound looking for every ounce of nuance, detail, resolution etc... My word for that sound is analytical = to lifeless, fatiguing & Dry


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
fair
I stand corrected and take my opinion back. I am glad you gave us more info intom the F15 .
If my Voxativ for some reason does not work out, i will consider buying the F15.
Here is my newest tweak, a Tshirt thrown over the DavidLouis 4 inch.
I explain all in this 30 minute video.
My speaker is zero fatigue, zero coloration, Lets see Vandersteen and Thiel match that!

Could I live with this *The Frankenstein* You bet,
But lets see what the Voxativ AC1A's can do.
Bloody shootout just ahead.
The Frankies cost near $2G's. The Voxativ
's near $2G's.

 
Now if I decide to go back to a small full range driver it will be the Coral Holey Basket Alnico. Just from listening you'd never know it's only 3.5 inches. These are labeled Sony as they came from a TOTL Sony tube reel to reel.

P1010021.jpeg
 
Last edited:
The next big event /discovery in all audio will be The New High Tech Wide Band/FR/high sensitivity speakers,
Front and Center.
Most audiophiles have no clue they exist, how they work/sound, etc.
Will take 10 yrs to catch on.
The newest and best thing is all audio are the new high tech high sens speakers/single drivers.
Xover designs are ~~ Dinasaurs~~
There's nothing new about "full range" (or wide range) drivers. The earliest speakers used single drivers which attempted to cover the full range of audio, and in applications where high fidelity wasn't the primary objective (such as TV's and portable radios) wide range drivers were employed long after two-way and three-way hi-fi speakers became the norm. Even now, single wide range drivers are very common.
Whether or not the "new" designs are a significant improvement on what was available previously would be a matter of debate or opinion. It seems to me that the OB/full-range afficionados are usually searching for drivers from yesteryear.
 
Probably some of the most expensive wide band drivers used in open baffles today would be the Feastrex. Some of these go for over $40,000 a pair. I know of one AK member who has a pair used in BIB enclosures.

ZwyO0PPWD5VTBdDuOGLUM8ctV1odZZXjrGQYO0TL_3DF6J9JIV8VvSeoTgEWVK4XBH_iWettNzcAnRXP5eXPMlDQ4_DCHIYrEpg
 
Back
Top Bottom