• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

It has been my experience that OB just sound good regardless of the drivers. So long as the drivers measure reasonably well for OB Use. I personally got closer to the music when I pulled them farther into the room
 
It has been my experience that OB just sound good regardless of the drivers. So long as the drivers measure reasonably well for OB Use. I personally got closer to the music when I pulled them farther into the room

That's normal for any dipolar radiator.
 
Y'all know I've been a fan of alnico driver's since my experience with the Zeniths and Corals in OB's. Here's an interesting quote I found.

"After many years of experimentation I’ve found myself using alnico magnets in both cartridges – Kiseki and Dynavector – and speakers – Feastrex. Not only does alnico provide a very flat, linear frequency response, but as Takeda San of Miyabi put it, it does not sound “nervous” – there is very little grain, spit, noise or break up with it. There is a good sonic reason why alnico was the audio magnet of choice for so many decades, and why it is still the permanent magnet of choice, especially in Japan and the far East. To my ears, for a steep price, only electromagnets can beat it."
 
Last edited:
Interesting quotes from Linkwitz regarding panels which don't apply to OB's.

"Large panels radiators suffer from severe lobing at high frequency."

"The low masses of the moving parts in an ESL, a planar magnetic, or a ribbon driver are necessary to generate useful sound pressure levels. The force generated by an electrostatic or planar magnetic motor is weak. Since SPL is proportional to air volume acceleration, and moving parts Acceleration is Force divided by Mass, the mass has to be lower if the force is too weak to generate sufficient acceleration. Furthermore, since excursion is limited with these drivers the radiating area has to be large to move a sufficient air volume.. These relationships seem to be difficult to grasp by audiophiles. Marketing departments and even some designers like to tout low mass as an inherent benefit giving greater "speed" or frequency response to their speaker, when it is only affecting sensitivity in SPL/W".
 
The main reason had to do with cost. Ceramics have been around since the 1960's.
I'm not quite following your argument. Are you saying that alnico was the audio magnet of choice because it was cheaper than ceramic? Or because it was more expensive? Either way, doesn't appear to be a decision based audio performance.
 
I'm saying that there are lots of elements to a loudspeaker that determine its performance, such as cone material, the surround, the spider, moving mass, voice coil, etc. etc. It's a complex mix and I don't buy the idea that the magnet material has a significant impact (if any) amongst all the other things. Sure, alnico was the magnetic material used for years, but since it was the only viable material available it wasn't a choice based on sonic superiority (in my opinion). If someone tries a loudspeaker with an alnico magnet and likes the sound, is that proof that the likeable sound is due to the magnet? Seems to me a bit like driving a red Ferrari and drawing the conclusion that red cars are fast. :no:
I'll admit that I haven't had a chance to compare an alnico speaker with a ceramic speaker where everything else is identical (same cone material, same magnetic field strength, same T/S parameters etc.), but who has? :dunno:
 
I'm saying that there are lots of elements to a loudspeaker that determine its performance, such as cone material, the surround, the spider, moving mass, voice coil, etc. etc. It's a complex mix and I don't buy the idea that the magnet material has a significant impact (if any) amongst all the other things. Sure, alnico was the magnetic material used for years, but since it was the only viable material available it wasn't a choice based on sonic superiority (in my opinion). If someone tries a loudspeaker with an alnico magnet and likes the sound, is that proof that the likeable sound is due to the magnet? Seems to me a bit like driving a red Ferrari and drawing the conclusion that red cars are fast. :no:
I'll admit that I haven't had a chance to compare an alnico speaker with a ceramic speaker where everything else is identical (same cone material, same magnetic field strength, same T/S parameters etc.), but who has? :dunno:

Lots of ceramic vs alnico guitar speaker comparisons on the net. Even one A/B on youtube using two identical speakers except for the magnet material. But I'm not going by any of that but just my personal experience. Alnico's can't take much power and they sound best with flea watt tube amps. That's what they were designed to be powered by back in the day.
 
I'm saying that there are lots of elements to a loudspeaker that determine its performance, such as cone material, the surround, the spider, moving mass, voice coil, etc. etc. It's a complex mix and I don't buy the idea that the magnet material has a significant impact (if any) amongst all the other things. Sure, alnico was the magnetic material used for years, but since it was the only viable material available it wasn't a choice based on sonic superiority (in my opinion). If someone tries a loudspeaker with an alnico magnet and likes the sound, is that proof that the likeable sound is due to the magnet? Seems to me a bit like driving a red Ferrari and drawing the conclusion that red cars are fast. :no:
I'll admit that I haven't had a chance to compare an alnico speaker with a ceramic speaker where everything else is identical (same cone material, same magnetic field strength, same T/S parameters etc.), but who has? :dunno:

What about the architecture of the speaker. Do you think that a magnet that surrounds the voice coil is inherently the same as a magnet that lies within the voice coil? Can you point to one speaker with a ceramic/ferrite magnet of significant size that is located within the voice coil like an AlNiCo speaker?

page03.jpg
 
I happen to have a pair of otherwise identical guitar cabs, one with ceramic speakers and one with alnico. They sound different. No surprise there as the magnet material isn't the only difference between the speakers.
 
I happen to have a pair of otherwise identical guitar cabs, one with ceramic speakers and one with alnico. They sound different. No surprise there as the magnet material isn't the only difference between the speakers.

If they're different speakers in those cabs what else would you expect?
 
That's my point exactly, and applies to anyone comparing for example a Coral holey basket and a different speaker with a ceramic magnet.

You're talking in circles. The fact remains that the same speakers identical in structure except for the fact that one is alnico and one is ceramic will not sound the same. Didn't you watch the video and hear the difference? This is such a silly argument I won't waste anymore time trying to convince you otherwise.
 
I am anxious to hear how they sound.
Well,
The Zeniths are playing. It will take a few days at least to see how they will begin to sound. So far, plenty of detail. Who knows how long they have been
cooling their heels, but even after only a couple minutes, I think they are improving. Sonic memory is so fleeting, at this point it is hard to recall my other
vintage speakers that are definitely alnico. Will post some photos and and try to better define how they progress. Definitely glad the parts are back together
in a semblance of togetherness and not strewn all over several rooms!
 
Well,
The Zeniths are playing. It will take a few days at least to see how they will begin to sound. So far, plenty of detail. Who knows how long they have been
cooling their heels, but even after only a couple minutes, I think they are improving. Sonic memory is so fleeting, at this point it is hard to recall my other
vintage speakers that are definitely alnico. Will post some photos and and try to better define how they progress. Definitely glad the parts are back together
in a semblance of togetherness and not strewn all over several rooms!

I recently had a PM from a member regarding disappointing results from a pair of Zeniths. It's always a gamble with a 60+ year old alnico driver that may have lost some of its charge. Hopefully that's not the case with yours.
 
They sure are sensitive. You can hear sound if you just look at the volume control, and I am hearing a lot of detail. They are speakers for finesse and not
for wall banging :)
 
Back
Top Bottom