• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

I'm still flirting with the Cain baffle F-15's but two members of another forum whose opinions I trust parted ways with theirs. It seems to come down to a matter of taste and listening space. One of the owners preferred his alnico Omegas over the F-15s.
 
I'm still flirting with the Cain baffle F-15's but two members of another forum whose opinions I trust parted ways with theirs. It seems to come down to a matter of taste and listening space. One of the owners preferred his alnico Omegas over the F-15s.
i heard similar from the Omega man but also that the space in the new listening area was the main concern, as well as the opportunity to turn a small profit on the build.

i'm also flirting w OB build but unclear direction. i have some 9/4 black walnut available, matching bell end 27" wide ;D thinking of just doing something basic to start, leaving the live edge on, w Altec 604 8G and Tannoy HPD 385.
 
I ran across a couple posts discussing the use of pro Neo woofers with high sensitivity and mid Qts. Everything I am reading says you get cleaner more linear bass though it does not dig as deep. Anyone here tried this ? Specifically I am reading about Lavoce WAN 153.00 15" and the FaitalPRO 15PR400 15" Neodymium

I should mention I would be using on a baffle powering them with a crownXLS1002, Low Pass crossing around 200 Hz

Thanks
 
So your profile pic got me wondering....

I am interested in getting into an open baffle set up.

Everything I read tells me that the baffle ought to be rather large to keep back waves of bass frequencies from canceling front waves.

And yet it looks like you have a dual-15 set up and a very small. narrow baffle seemingly incapable of effectively preventing cancelation from occuring.

What am I missing?
 
I cant speak for Pgeist, but I listen to twin 15" drivers on baffles as small as 20" Square for each driver. I dont know what cancellation sounds like but I do know this has been the best speaker I have owned. They have lasted longer in my setup than anything prior. I would put forth the suggestion that trial and error is the way to go. SEE WHAT SOUNDS BEST TO YOUR EARS. Not some random reviewer or builder. Measurements are a good start but listening is where you get to the meat of things
 
So your profile pic got me wondering....

I am interested in getting into an open baffle set up.

Everything I read tells me that the baffle ought to be rather large to keep back waves of bass frequencies from canceling front waves.

And yet it looks like you have a dual-15 set up and a very small. narrow baffle seemingly incapable of effectively preventing cancellation from occurring.

What am I missing?

Large high q drivers produce too much bass, the cancellation evens it out.
 
Made a 2nd set of top Baffles and been swapping out the F-15 with the Crystal 10's on top. I like what I hear from both setups and its easy to swap out. I put my Decware ZF15M Baffles in storage. I just cant get enough of that open Baffle Bass. The Emm Alpha 15a is an amazing driver for the price of admission. The Lii W-15 would dig deeper but you lose Bass texture compared to the Alpha, One of these days I want to try the Acoustic Elegance Dipole 15's

So many options, So little Time :crazy:
 
I cant speak for Pgeist, but I listen to twin 15" drivers on baffles as small as 20" Square for each driver. I dont know what cancellation sounds like but I do know this has been the best speaker I have owned. They have lasted longer in my setup than anything prior. I would put forth the suggestion that trial and error is the way to go. SEE WHAT SOUNDS BEST TO YOUR EARS. Not some random reviewer or builder. Measurements are a good start but listening is where you get to the meat of things

:thumbsup: I couldn't agree more.
 
So your profile pic got me wondering....

I am interested in getting into an open baffle set up.

Everything I read tells me that the baffle ought to be rather large to keep back waves of bass frequencies from canceling front waves.

And yet it looks like you have a dual-15 set up and a very small. narrow baffle seemingly incapable of effectively preventing cancelation from occuring.

What am I missing?

My flat baffles are approximately 48 inches tall and 20 inches wide ( same width that M. King modeled ). I've tried single Eminence Alpha 15's but dual 15's offer the best bass output. My experimental baffles of 3/4" MDF ended up being my final build. MDF is difficult to paint so I wall papered mine and trimmed the edges with quarter round molding. Every wide band driver I've used with the flat baffles sounded great. At the moment I'm using 8 inch Zenith Alnico's while the Lowthers occupy the MLTL cabinets. Bi-amping and avoiding a passive crossover gives the best results. Flea watt SET amp for the HF with no filters and a solid state amp low passed for the woofers.

P1010002.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Here's a quote I found regarding Alnico drivers. I wish I could give credit to the person who gave this explanation but I don't have it.

"The appeal lies in their "soft clipping" capability. As the magnetic field from the VC increases the alnico material begins to lose its magnetism. The loss is temporary and the magnet returns to full strength after the field from the VC subsides. This gives the drivers an almost tube like quality. Furthermore, a given amount of Alnico has greater magnetic density than an equal volume of ceramic or ferrite magnet. Alnico's can lose some of their charge if driven by a powerful amp. That was never a problem with vintage alnico which were always powered by flea watt tube amps."
 
I’m running narrow baffle zenith 852 w/alnico magnets over alpha 15 in h-frame. I don’t think I’m experiencing any back wave cancellation and like others have said it’s the best sounding speakers I’ve heard, at least in my setup. Sometimes I have them close to the wall to child proof and they still sound great and better yet 3 or so feet out. I think bigger baffles can help with bass but I don’t think narrow baffles suffer from back wave complications maybe because of the natural delay of the back wave arrival or possibly because how it’s dispersed off the back (*front) wall.
 
Last edited:
I’m running narrow baffle zenith 852 w/alnico magnets over alpha 15 in h-frame. I don’t think I’m experiencing any back way cancellation and like others have said it’s the best sounding speakers I’ve heard, at least in my setup. Sometimes I have them close to the wall to child proof and they still sound great and better yet 3 or so feet out. I think bigger baffles can help with bass but I don’t think narrow baffles suffer from back wave maybe because of the natural delay of the back wave arrival or possibly because how it’s dispersed off the back wall.

While the reflection off the front wall can add or subtract from desired results, the width of the baffle (or wings) has to do with the driver itself and the front and back wave being out of phase causing cancellation at each side. The wider the baffle, or added distance with wings, the lower the frequency where the cancellation begins.

There are many variables and options in design that the idea of wide baffles is now antiquated, but still works for some.
 
There are many variables and options in design that the idea of wide baffles is now antiquated, but still works for some.

Speaking in general terms, when comparing an open baffle set up to a boxed set up, assuming both are of quality and deployed properly, what is the frequency range that the open baffle design affects the most?

I am guessing the “tweeter frequencies” sound no different, going back and forth from ob to boxed.

I am guessing that output below about 60-80hz will suffer with ob.

I am guessing ob really shines from 100hz to about 2000hz.

Am I on the right track?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top Bottom