• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Speaking of small baffles here's the Linkwitz Orion. Woofers in M-frames.

lx521_back.jpg
 
Last edited:
Still planning...

When mounting a LF driver and a wideband driver to the same baffle in an open baffle set-up, is it important that the wideband driver be spaced back some (into the baffle) to put the voice coils of the wideband and LF drivers in alignment with each other? I heard something about this keeping them in phase.

I also read that the drivers should not be centered on the baffle. Does this specifically apply to wideband drivers or does this also apply to LF drivers?
 
Still planning...

When mounting a LF driver and a wideband driver to the same baffle in an open baffle set-up, is it important that the wideband driver be spaced back some (into the baffle) to put the voice coils of the wideband and LF drivers in alignment with each other? I heard something about this keeping them in phase.

I also read that the drivers should not be centered on the baffle. Does this specifically apply to wideband drivers or does this also apply to LF drivers?

There are lots of "conventional" speaker manufacturers that do just that, stagger the drivers. But there are many that do not. Maybe a diminishing returns situation? Lots more cost due to added complexity of the cabinets and not enough payoff?

Using the "conventional" model again, you do see pairs of speakers that are mirror-imaged. It is usually done with the tweeters, they are offset to the left or right. It's sold as improving the image but I've never owned a pair like that to make any comparison. And like the staggered drivers example, many speakers are constructed with all the drivers aligned.
 
My understanding of having the voice coils in line deals with time alignment, Supposedly the resulting sound from each driver will exit the drivers and be more coherent. Personally in MANY DIY speakers both Open Baffle and Horns I have never found this to be a real issue in SOUND. I know it can be shown in measurements (I dont listen to those)

More or less the same issue with mounting the drivers off center this is supposed to be so the soundwave reaches the ends of thee baffle at different times improving detraction & ? Oddly enough I mount all my drivers in the center, If you look at a square with a circle in the center there are literally dozens of different measurements I could take from my driver to the edge of the baffle it all depends on where I want to place my tape measure.

I tried the off center mounting and could not hear any improvement with off center mounting. I am positive someone could take a measurement and explain why its better. I am not positive most people could actually hear the difference.

At some point you will need to simply try an OB speaker and decide for your self if it is worth the effort. I understand the research, None of that will actually tell you if you will enjoy it. I have seen people like Nelson Pass build and LOVE Open Baffles, SLOB's + others and I have seen his drivers mounted center and with his SLOB its is impossible to align the voice coils.
 
Last edited:
I've always done mirror image with the full range driver closer to one edge ( I use the location that MJK used in the link below ). Also when the driver is closer to one side it allows room for a tweeter should you need one.

http://www.quarter-wave.com/Project08/Jordan.pdf

The Jordon project would be a good one for anyone who wants to use a single amp ( no bi-amping required ). You could use a less complicated flat baffle instead of the H-frame.
 
My understanding of having the voice coils in line deals with time alignment, Supposedly the resulting sound from each driver will exit the drivers and be more coherent. Personally in MANY DIY speakers both Open Baffle and Horns I have never found this to be a real issue in SOUND. I know it can be shown in measurements (I dont listen to those)

More or less the same issue with mounting the drivers off center this is supposed to be so the soundwave reaches the ends of thee baffle at different times improving detraction & ? Oddly enough I mount all my drivers in the center, If you look at a square with a circle in the center there are literally dozens of different measurements I could take from my driver to the edge of the baffle it all depends on where I want to place my tape measure.

I tried the off center mounting and could not hear any improvement with off center mounting. I am positive someone could take a measurement and explain why its better. I am not positive most people could actually hear the difference.

At some point you will need to simply try an OB speaker and decide for your self if it is worth the effort. I understand the research, None of that will actually tell you if you will enjoy it. I have seen people like Nelson Pass build and LOVE Open Baffles, SLOB's + others and I have seen his drivers mounted center and with his SLOB its is impossible to align the voice coils.
My questions stem from watching this video.

I cant decide wether or not to take him seriously. On one hand he seems to know what he is talking about, but since he is a manufacturer making money off of his designs that tells me he has an agenda beyond educating the public. Good video either way though. What do you think?

 
My questions stem from watching this video.

I cant decide wether or not to take him seriously. On one hand he seems to know what he is talking about, but since he is a manufacturer making money off of his designs that tells me he has an agenda beyond educating the public. Good video either way though. What do you think?


I like Danny, I am sure he can show improved measurements. But think about that for a minute

You have a computer with a calibrated mic taking a measurement of X, Of course it will pick up things the Human EAR cannot, Further All Ears hear differently. Also consider the speaker you posted a pic of the PAP every driver they use is centered on their baffles and every driver is at a varying depth as the baffles are curved. I happen to know they do not use any DSP etc... correcting for time delay defraction etc... Now consider the hundreds of positive reviews from there owners. Think about Spatial, and Emerald Physics both center there drivers and neither use DSP in there passive crossovers All 3 have several audio awards with a LOT of positive reviews and even more satisfied owners. OB speakers are not for everyone some folks simply can not get past the BOX Thats fine, their perception of what they hear is what appeals to them.

The question is not can a measurement show improvement, The question is can YOU HEAR IT, will it make an actual perceived difference in what you are hearing.

You will not know if you LIKE OB till you actually try them, all the research and views of folks on the net including me means NOTHING. You simply must try them. That will answer all your questions and I dare say it will do that in mere minutes. It did for me

One day I want to build Danny's (GR Research) X-Static OB speakers, But currently I think my Spatial X-2 Clones are about the best speaker I have heard / owned. I have no real desire to stray, though I am always looking
 
View attachment 2429137


View attachment 2429138

I've never listened to any of his videos.

We have a pair of his Superminis also. When the wifes out for more than a day I move all that stuff between the speakers to another room.

Can you give more info on those top OB mids and tweeters ? I dont see anything like that on GR Research. I would love to try the Servo Bass as well. Where do you cross from the bass to the mids ? How high can the servo bass play ?

I like deep bass (as anyone in this hobby should) I also like detailed and articulate bass. Forced to choose between the 2 I choose decent lows with great articulation and detail. I have been so tempted to buy from Danny. A lot of his ideas really sound great. I like the idea of a narrow Baffle allowing the drivers to disappear more easily. due to the baffle creating a smaller wave, even my common sense tells me that is a great idea

Thanks for sharing, You may have just pushed me over the edge, Much to the wife and credit cards chagrin...........:eek:
 
When mounting a LF driver and a wideband driver to the same baffle in an open baffle set-up, is it important that the wideband driver be spaced back some (into the baffle) to put the voice coils of the wideband and LF drivers in alignment with each other?
It depends on the frequencies in question. At 5kHz the wavelength is about 2.6 inches, so an offset between drivers of about an inch is a significant proportion of the wavelength at 5kHz.
However, at 200Hz the wavelength is more like 67 inches, so a 1 inch offset between drivers is hardly anything at all and won't be of any benefit.
 
I like Danny, I am sure he can show improved measurements. But think about that for a minute

You have a computer with a calibrated mic taking a measurement of X, Of course it will pick up things the Human EAR cannot, Further All Ears hear differently. Also consider the speaker you posted a pic of the PAP every driver they use is centered on their baffles and every driver is at a varying depth as the baffles are curved. I happen to know they do not use any DSP etc... correcting for time delay defraction etc... Now consider the hundreds of positive reviews from there owners. Think about Spatial, and Emerald Physics both center there drivers and neither use DSP in there passive crossovers All 3 have several audio awards with a LOT of positive reviews and even more satisfied owners. OB speakers are not for everyone some folks simply can not get past the BOX Thats fine, their perception of what they hear is what appeals to them.

The question is not can a measurement show improvement, The question is can YOU HEAR IT, will it make an actual perceived difference in what you are hearing.

You will not know if you LIKE OB till you actually try them, all the research and views of folks on the net including me means NOTHING. You simply must try them. That will answer all your questions and I dare say it will do that in mere minutes. It did for me

One day I want to build Danny's (GR Research) X-Static OB speakers, But currently I think my Spatial X-2 Clones are about the best speaker I have heard / owned. I have no real desire to stray, though I am always looking
Would it be fair to say that there is nothing to loose and everything to gain by offsetting drivers?

Furthermore would it be fair to say that these things that can be measured but cant be heard are the things that separate a good system from a great system?
 
Would it be fair to say that there is nothing to loose and everything to gain by offsetting drivers?

Furthermore would it be fair to say that these things that can be measured but cant be heard are the things that separate a good system from a great system?

Any comment on what might be is shear speculation. According to those that take the measurements, I am sure they would consider it better. Build both and compare
 
Would it be fair to say that there is nothing to loose and everything to gain by offsetting drivers?

Furthermore would it be fair to say that these things that can be measured but cant be heard are the things that separate a good system from a great system?
No.
And no.
 
No.
And no.
Do tell.

Lets say I offset a full range driver on a 36in wide baffle all the way to one side leaving a couple inches of exposed baffle to one side of the driver and about 25in of baffle to the other side of the driver.

What would this do to the response?
 
It didn't do very much to ours when I was taking measurements. And in my case getting the H frames to integrate with the top-hats was music to my ears. I had lots of help.

Monday Super mini.jpg
 
Do tell.

Lets say I offset a full range driver on a 36in wide baffle all the way to one side leaving a couple inches of exposed baffle to one side of the driver and about 25in of baffle to the other side of the driver.

What would this do to the response?
Sorry, I misunderstood. I thought you were talking about setting one driver back from the other for "time alignment".
Yes, moving the driver off center is a good idea. There's a piece of software called The Edge which will model the response with different placements of the driver on an open baffle. Unfortunately I can't find it now.
 
Back
Top Bottom