• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

A single cap on the tweeter is not much of a crossover. It's really just a bass blocker.

Open back tweeters are rare. If you pad that highly sensitive compression driver down enough you might find it works well. There's always the option of firing the compression driver to the rear. Danny Rich favors that approach.
The plan at this point is to stick with a full range driver that is open back and plays high enough to not need a tweeter. The tang band 5in driver that I have in mind seems to fit the bill.
 
Still trying to decide how to lay out the drivers. Which way would you go and why?

It will be flat sheet of 3/4in plywood to begin.

These are the two ideas I am currently tossing around.

3717386F-EF62-4E10-A1B3-7FFE5FCA87EE.jpeg

966BE8FB-681E-4F97-A0CC-0E46D8751FBC.jpeg
 
I see this a lot and it does not make sense to me that the 2 drivers are so far apart. Isnt it ideal to keep the drivers center to center distance to a minimum?

The higher up the spectrum you go the better it is to have the drivers spaced as close as possible. But with a bass only unit it becomes much less localized and less important.
 
I'm sure this has been discussed before but what driver parameters should we be looking for in a driver that would work well in OB?
 
How about tall and skinny with wings and (from the top down) woofer/FR/woofer/woofer or FR/woofer/woofer/woofer
That would be cool, but way more of a project than I am willing to take on. This one s my first attempt at ob and until I decide that I like ob and want to have a permanent ob setup, it will be simple. Just a rectangle shaped baffle to start, that can be turned into a “u frame” down the road by adding hinged wings.
 
I'm sure this has been discussed before but what driver parameters should we be looking for in a driver that would work well in OB?
For low frequency drivers, high qts. Or, low qts with a graphic eq in the signal chain.

For high frequency drivers that are monopole/closed back, there are no parameters to consider for ob.

For open back drivers that are full range or HF, I have never heard of parameters that need to be within a specified range. From what I gather, it’s trial and error, and far less touchy than LF drivers.

The above is what I have learned by reading, not first hand experience.
 
JBL le14a (quantity 4)

Tang Band w5 (quantity 1)

So, low qts woofers, eq to shape the low frequencies to taste. No additional bass support.

You need high Qts woofers for OB. My favorite OB woofer is the Eminence Alpha 15a which has a Qts of 1.26 which is pretty high.

.7 is acceptable but higher is better. No EQ is needed for the Alpha.
 
If the TB is going to be OB also, the crossover would need to be higher than previously mentioned.
I

The previously mentioned crossover point for the tang band w5 wideband driver was 100hz.

Why would it need to be higher if ran ob and how much higher would the crossover point need to be?
 
The previously mentioned crossover point for the tang band w5 wideband driver was 100hz.

Why would it need to be higher if ran ob and how much higher would the crossover point need to be?

It is a 5" driver with a QTS of 0.38 and 2.5 mm x-max.
Try running a frequency sweep (mid to low) at a low volume (be careful) with the driver on a baffle (anything will work even cardboard) the width you are thinking of using, see where it loses output.
 
Even with that big of size, this will give you a chance to get a taste of OB. Good for you!!

I found a larger baffle size like that to have a bit too much of a room divider effect and I didn't really care for it. I've since not gone much about about 24" or so in width and made it taller. I like what that does better.

Not completely sure if you can get drivers that low of q to give you the right bass for OB. But again, it should give you a good idea of the sound of OB even if you can't get the deeper bass. You will have to eq those enough that power demand will go up and movement will be greater than a more proper driver. Every bit of greater cone movement is greater distortion. Though it may work ok...no real rules.

In TB 8" drivers for full range use, run in a stack of either 3 or 4, I found that they do ok down to about 75-125hz. I've played with crossover frequencies there and typically run about 80hz since I went to four. More drivers gets lower. You need cone area for lower frequencies and in OB for sure you do. That single 5" for the full range part I think I'd look for a crossover around 400 or so. With an electronic crossover, you could try 250 to about 500 and see how the 5" versus the woofs sounds.

And hopefully you're aware you'll probably want to wire the set of four drivers series/parallel so that you get a decent amp load. If they're 8 ohm, you'll get an amp load of 8 in series/parallel.

Make sure you play around with lots of space behind...more is better and hear what that does for the sound. And enjoy!

EV3
 
Even with that big of size, this will give you a chance to get a taste of OB. Good for you!!

I found a larger baffle size like that to have a bit too much of a room divider effect and I didn't really care for it. I've since not gone much about about 24" or so in width and made it taller. I like what that does better.

Not completely sure if you can get drivers that low of q to give you the right bass for OB. But again, it should give you a good idea of the sound of OB even if you can't get the deeper bass. You will have to eq those enough that power demand will go up and movement will be greater than a more proper driver. Every bit of greater cone movement is greater distortion. Though it may work ok...no real rules.

In TB 8" drivers for full range use, run in a stack of either 3 or 4, I found that they do ok down to about 75-125hz. I've played with crossover frequencies there and typically run about 80hz since I went to four. More drivers gets lower. You need cone area for lower frequencies and in OB for sure you do. That single 5" for the full range part I think I'd look for a crossover around 400 or so. With an electronic crossover, you could try 250 to about 500 and see how the 5" versus the woofs sounds.

And hopefully you're aware you'll probably want to wire the set of four drivers series/parallel so that you get a decent amp load. If they're 8 ohm, you'll get an amp load of 8 in series/parallel.

Make sure you play around with lots of space behind...more is better and hear what that does for the sound. And enjoy!

EV3

Yes, series parallel for an 8ohm load.

Some say bigger baffles minimize cancelations and that is good. Some say low q + eq is best because you get the bass AND good cone control. So, we’ll see. It’s an experiment for sure.

I am using an active, electronic crossover. Adjustable down to 100hz and up to 1000hz (I think). My concern is running the xover point high enough into directional territory to where there will be directional frequencies coming from too many sources. To counter this, I put the drivers very close together. I am not certain how close drivers need to be to counter the acoustic problems that can occur with a higher crossover point that is into directional frequencies. I understand closer is better, but what are the numbers?

I have 3.5ft measured at the back side of the baffle to the wall nearest the back of the baffle.
I can’t increase this dimension by much, so hopefully it will work.
 
Higher qts is considered correct for OB. My experimentation has me in the camp of not too high though. Boundary effect and just the room itself plays in so much that it's just a matter of trying. If you shelve off a little too fast then no harm, just will feel a bit light weight and may be correctable. And with OB it's not a quick fall off like a ported box. They go much lower than generally mentioned, just with a rolling slope.

OB works enough different than point source that I haven't been able to find issue with comb filtering even up higher in freq where it matters more. Measuring with a mic you can find it but not when at normal listening distance setting in the normal spot. Crossing over where you are, I don't think that will be an issue. It'll be much more how those particular drivers sound at those frequencies and how the directivity is at the crossover point.

The distance between is at a rule of thumb something like half the wavelength of the distance between. Again, I don't think that'll be an issue down lower. Having them closer wouldn't hurt but probably isn't to be heard either. I always really put drivers real close, like almost touching each other just because it's not too hard to do.

3 ft or more separation from the front wall for dipolar is the number thrown around most often. But I think more is more good. But the resulting frequency response from boundaries may matter a lot too so distance really tunes in a couple ways.

Look forward to your report on how things work! Consider it all a lowish cost experiment and for fun and see what can be learned for satisfy your tastes. I find the openness and lack of box coloration to be really, really hard to turn away from. Once used to it, you start hearing it in the conventional pretty readily.

EV3
 
I just ordered a pair of Lii Audio F-15 drivers ( currently on sale ) and will build my own rectangular baffles rather than copying this Caintuck barrel design. Lii Audio informed me that their US warehouse is out of stock but I can expect delivery within three to four weeks. They're also sending a pair of F-6 drivers to make up for the delay. Nice gesture on their part.

I'm anxious to see how the F15's compare to the Zenith Alnico wide band drivers.

ZF15M525.jpg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom