• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Another thing,

I am getting pretty decent bass out of this set up without EQ. Even though QTS is only 0.33. It’s odd though because it is as though it has to be a certain kind of bass to work well. Like, bass guitar on smooth, easy listening type of tracks. Very nice!

Hard hitting deep bass…..YUCK!

Add some EQ to boost the bass at 30 and 60 hz……DOUBLE YUCK!!!

So the graphic EQ is out now.

I am still familiarizing with this OB set up, but it has its strengths and weaknesses for sure.

I tried it with the full range up high, then in the middle. I like the middle much better, hence the block off plate up high.

Right now it is CDP -> 2way active xover -> amps -> speakers.

No preamp, no eq, no passive xover. The voice coils are wired directly to the amp output stages.

Strengths….jazz, blues, acoustic, piano, gospel, easy listening, classic rock from 60s + 70s.

Weakness….anything fast and hard hitting, deep bass.
 
Been playing with the crossover point. Historically, I have gotten best results with lowish crossover points. Not the case here.

Crossover point at 100hz…..YUCK!

Crossover point at 500hz….better.

Crossover point at 1000hz….boy do the JBL woofers love playing high!!! So smooth and musical!!! I did not expect this.

And no lobing or combing….?
 
Do you have anything solid (wood) to fill the gap between the baffle and floor?
Curious if it will make a difference.
Nothing readily available that will be a perfect fit.

What kind of difference would you be looking for?

Might be able to mock up some cardboard…
 
How are you liking the sound so far? They look impressive:)
Still getting familiar with it.

Some tracks have been VERY good sounding.

Some just don’t work at all.

That’s fine though and my other systems are the same way, with strengths and weaknesses.
 
Nothing readily available that will be a perfect fit.

What kind of difference would you be looking for?

Might be able to mock up some cardboard…

Doesn't have to be a perfect fit.
A little more bass, the waves will not be able to wrap around and cancel, the bottom of the baffle will in effect be infinite.
 
I've been looking forward to your report. Sounds like you're having some fun now. That's awesome!

Remember, the journey may be more fun than the destination.

Interesting, your report of 'yuck' bass. I'm wondering what kind of frequency response your actually getting. Any kind of even rough idea might tell you more about how it comes up lacking. Is there an app for a phone that will show something maybe? Some kind of sweep tone you could play and then have it show what the phone mic picks up?

While you've now heard at least how some upper bass can sound so good with the box out of the picture, normally it's just a matter of difficult to get the lowest bass. Not a report of sounding bad. Makes me wonder if the response is lumpy along with missing down low.

All drivers sound and play different. So feel free to play and look for other things that work. It's all part of the fun!

Good luck!

EV3

PS...a crack along the bottom at floor level isn't going to have any effect if that's what is being referred to.
 
I've been looking forward to your report. Sounds like you're having some fun now. That's awesome!

Remember, the journey may be more fun than the destination.

Interesting, your report of 'yuck' bass. I'm wondering what kind of frequency response your actually getting. Any kind of even rough idea might tell you more about how it comes up lacking. Is there an app for a phone that will show something maybe? Some kind of sweep tone you could play and then have it show what the phone mic picks up?

While you've now heard at least how some upper bass can sound so good with the box out of the picture, normally it's just a matter of difficult to get the lowest bass. Not a report of sounding bad. Makes me wonder if the response is lumpy along with missing down low.

All drivers sound and play different. So feel free to play and look for other things that work. It's all part of the fun!

Good luck!

EV3

PS...a crack along the bottom at floor level isn't going to have any effect if that's what is being referred to.
I’ll have to play with it some more.

For example, I played a track that really gets the subs going on another system of mine and the sound was not good on the OB system. At all. Sounded “wonky” as best as I can describe it. I played with the eq and it got worse. On all tracks I liked no eq best.

Other tracks sounded GREAT however…

Still figuring it out.
 
Is there an app for a phone that will show something maybe? Some kind of sweep tone you could play and then have it show what the phone mic picks up?.
I do have a sine wave generator. But I don’t have a real time analyzer / spectrum analyzer. I am unfamiliar with any app that gives my phone rta capabilities.
 
I understand. My meaning was why the extra attention to one side of the baffle if the same thing is occurring on another side? Just trying to follow.

It probably won't matter much with 4 large woofers, but it has to do with boundary reinforcement and the floor being the only part of the baffle that doesn't have front and rear wave cancellation.
If you pull a subwoofer out from the walls, will it have more bass placed on the floor or on a stand/table?
 
I could and may add a bottom to these flat baffles which would add unwanted extra weight but I'm thinking the floor will offer the same affect. Ordered the F-15's on 2/21 but still waiting.

P1010001 4.jpeg
 
So aside from Lii Audio, who else makes large diameter, full range drivers suited to OB? Not much out there it seems...
 
Back
Top Bottom