• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

With OB and no crossover of any sort, how do you decide between 1 larger full range driver per side like this…

C88A8E16-A71E-4E45-B808-E04D6C99599A.jpeg



…or multiple smaller identical drivers like this…


D15A50A5-E549-49F2-B270-C247167C2139.jpeg


The second pic looks like four 8in drivers per side, likely in series parallel for an 8ohm load.

The first, a single 8ohm Lii F15 per side.

What would be the advantages and disadvantages of each method?
 
Why not just go for the F-18? Looks like those are in stock.

The F-15 has better reviews and that's probably the reason they aren't in stock. Some would consider a 15" wide band single driver a stretch but with an 18" driver there's little doubt.
 
Last edited:
A single wide band driver is the epitome of coherency. There's no time alignment issues and no crossover/filters to muddy the sound or reduce the amp's output. The amp's signal is pure with nothing in the signal path between amp and speakers. This is extremely important when using highly resolving SET amps. Large wide band drivers are usually highly efficient allowing use of flea watt amps. They may not cover frequency extremes but what they do cover and how they cover it can be a game changer for many. They excel with less complex music played in near field but can't deliver deep bass. The latter is remedied with a sub or bi-amped woofers.
 
Last edited:
Bigger drivers used as they go up higher in frequency will 'beam' more and more. So the point angle of the driver gets to be more a problem, plus the overall energy into the room is also changing. How much this matters is debatable but the physics are there.

I like keeping the crossovers out of the way. With cone area in lower mids and upper bass needing more than in boxed speakers, you have to have enough cone area and baffle size to get lower in frequency so rolling in a supplemental woofer for lower frequencies can stay out of the way of the important voice range.

No one way to do things that's the perfect answer it seems.

EV3
 
Bigger drivers used as they go up higher in frequency will 'beam' more and more. So the point angle of the driver gets to be more a problem, plus the overall energy into the room is also changing. How much this matters is debatable but the physics are there.

I like keeping the crossovers out of the way. With cone area in lower mids and upper bass needing more than in boxed speakers, you have to have enough cone area and baffle size to get lower in frequency so rolling in a supplemental woofer for lower frequencies can stay out of the way of the important voice range.

No one way to do things that's the perfect answer it seems.

EV3
I have been thinking of it this way...

Comparing four 8s to a single 15 of equal build quality. No supplemental bass support in this hypothetical case.

The smaller cones will have stiffer, lighter cones, all things equal. Very difficult to have stiff and light 15in cones......advantage 8s.

Using four 8s divides the amp power evenly across 4 voice coils leading to more power handling.....advantage 8s.

Four drivers means multiple point sources for directional frequencies, the single 15 has one point source......advantage single 15.

A larger cone is typically higher in sensitivity.........advantage single 15.
 
Large wide band drivers are usually highly efficient allowing use of flea watt amps. They may not cover frequency extremes but what they do cover and how they cover it can be a game changer for many.

I am trying to get into the nitty-gritty of a single large wide band vs 4 smaller widebands....getting close to an even match in cone area between the two scenarios. Pros and cons with each method. No crossovers in either case, no additional bass support.
 
Four drivers means multiple point sources for directional frequencies, the single 15 has one point source......advantage single 15.

As long as the drivers are within the distances for the wavelengths involved, then acoustically they really are the same as a single driver. So in that case, it's a wash.

Seems to me like you really need more of an idea of what the output is level wise so you know what you need to do to achieve full range performance. Any audio guys around you have the OmniMic system? Or what about somebody with a receiver that includes any measurement systems with a mic based system that you could get the same type of info out of?

EV3
 
Many believe single 8" full range single drivers are optimal especially with bass support and I've owned quite a few. But my experience with the 12" Zeniths has been eye opening and that's the reason I'm intrigued with the Lii F-15 drivers. I can't say that I've ever experienced beaming and speaking of the F-15's the following is the email I received yesterday from Lii Audio.

Dear Paul,

We are very sorry for having you waited so long. By the time you placed the order, we had schedule to have the F-15s ready within 3 weeks. However, recently a breakout of covid cases in the city of our part suppliers has interrupted the planning.

As you might have known, China still applies very strict control policies, when one case occurs, a whole area get quarantined for at least a week and everyone tested, this affects greatly the supply chain when an outbreak take place in the factory area.

There is a good news that for these F-15s you are waiting for, we have upgraded the magnet with better quality and sound remakably improved. Currently the product has been produced and will be shipped to America by sea within next week.

We beg for your kind comprehension for the extra delay generated by situation out of our range of competence to control as a small business. But we will ensure that the sound quality of what you will receive will be better than before.

Best regards,
Weiyu ZHANG
Hangzhou Lii Song Electronics Co., Ltd.
 
I found this post regarding "beaming" and the F-15:

"From the first note, what I heard was not what I expected to hear.
I expected a 15" driver to beam like a banshee and draw attention to itself with no high frequency finesse and detail and a less than impressive soundstage.

"Man .... were my preconceptions off base .....
huh.gif

The soundstage floated above the baffles like it does with the Betsy drivers, both wide and deep and very well focused.
One of the amazing strengths of the Betsy drivers is what they do for human voice and surprisingly the F15s do very much the same.
Wonderful presence and palpability.
The high frequency harmonics of guitar and other instruments are easily heard and very natural sounding.
The lower midrange is a real treat ..... and instruments like cello have a weight and authority that is excellent from the top string to the bottom."
 
Whizzer cones ( as found on the F series drivers ) can reduce beaming while boosting dispersion but the jury seems somewhat divided. Some claim whizzers can be fatiguing over longer periods of listening but others favor them for added HF extension. In more recent models Lowther rolled the edges of their whizzers which tamed the dreaded Lowther "shout".
 
For a current and affordable wide band driver I like the Eminence Beta 12LTA. I removed the dust cap and added a phase plug which is a common mod with these. Just removing the dust cap also improves the sound.

View attachment 2533336
The 12LTA is still one of my favorites for OB. I have it paired with a Planar for air @ 10k where the Beta starts to roll off 102_0078.JPG and Alpha 15's for Bass.
 
As long as the drivers are within the distances for the wavelengths involved, then acoustically they really are the same as a single driver. So in that case, it's a wash.

Measuring distance from driver to driver, we are measuring center to center, right?
 
The 12 inch Zenith with alnico motors are really special but finding a pair in good condition is difficult due to their age. Mine were harvested from a 1957 Zenith tube console.

If I hadn't bought that $35 Zenith console and discovered their drivers I would have been happy with the 12LTA's.

12LTA OB build details

https://speakerprojects.wordpress.com/2016/08/29/eminence-beta-12lta-on-open-baffle/
Zenith alnico driver stand-alone vs 12LTA stand-alone?

As in one speaker per side, not 3ways.
 
Zenith but be prepared to pay unless you can find a tube console and the owner doesn't realize what he has.
 
Last edited:
For a first single driver OB project ( or maybe last for some ) I'd go with these folding wing baffles provided there's space for them. The Betsy drivers are good and affordable but if one's budget allows the Visaton B200 would be the ultimate choice. By expanding the center baffle and reducing the wings the Zeniths or other large drivers would be an option. These OBs are large but can be folded up and it's one way to get bass from smaller drivers.

When using a single driver without a helper woofer a driver with a Qts of 7 or higher is absolutely necessary to get any appreciable bass. That's why any old full range driver won't cut it in open baffles.


https://wildburroaudio.com/projects/
 
Back
Top Bottom