• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Speaking in general terms, when comparing an open baffle set up to a boxed set up, assuming both are of quality and deployed properly, what is the frequency range that the open baffle design affects the most?

I am guessing the “tweeter frequencies” sound no different, going back and forth from ob to boxed.

I am guessing that output below about 60-80hz will suffer with ob.

I am guessing ob really shines from 100hz to about 2000hz.

Am I on the right track?

Bass will sound different and load the room differently. A lot of those that have heard it done well say it is better.
If comparing equal size drivers, then OB may suffer, but it doesn't have to and OB bass can be very good to below 40 Hz (well below with some configurations).
 
I had decent bass down to 28Hz on a pair of OB Using the Lii W-15 on a 21: Square Baffle pulled off the wall 4 feet. Running Sine waves I was getting approx 3db down at 28 and 30 Hz things picked up a good bit beyond that
 
So this is kinda what I plan on...

Would it even make sense to do it this way? Or would the boxed subs render this project a fools errand? I am thinking that since the OB part of the system is carrying everything above 100hz, with a 24db per octave filter I will still get much of what the OB technology has to offer. OB subs are off the table, for the moment. This is as far as I can go for now. Still deciding if this project is viable.

OB DIAGRAM.png
 
So this is kinda what I plan on...

Would it even make sense to do it this way? Or would the boxed subs render this project a fools errand? I am thinking that since the OB part of the system is carrying everything above 100hz, with a 24db per octave filter I will still get much of what the OB technology has to offer. OB subs are off the table, for the moment. This is as far as I can go for now. Still deciding if this project is viable.

If you have most/all of the electronics to do it, why not? You can do the OB top cheaply just to try it out.
Remember open baffle needs some room to work well, most say at least 3 feet, I like 5 or 6.
 
If you have most/all of the electronics to do it, why not? You can do the OB top cheaply just to try it out.
Remember open baffle needs some room to work well, most say at least 3 feet, I like 5 or 6.
The speakers will be spaced, this was just a rough sketch.

So, they need several feet spacing to work well, but do they need to be playing below 100hz to work well too? Thats mostly what I am concerned with.
 
No your mids and highs dont Technically need to go below 100Hz. I have used Lowthers and others where I crossed them at 150 Hz with great success. Your subs will have to be very fast to keep pace I suspect
 
The speakers will be spaced, this was just a rough sketch.

So, they need several feet spacing to work well, but do they need to be playing below 100hz to work well too? Thats mostly what I am concerned with.

Sorry, I meant out from the front wall in case it wasn't clear.
What Joe said.
 
OK, first idea scrapped.


Moving along.


I have (8) JBL LE14A woofers in my possession and I would love to build an OB system around them. Four for left, four for right. Kinda like this...



PAP-Quintet15-Horn1-1a.jpg





But unfortunately, thats a little too much for me to build. So I was thinking something more like this.





OPEN BAFFLE.png



The HF driver in this scenario is a Tang Band w5 full range driver.



Does this seem viable? Looking around I don't see ANYONE else doing something like this. Just a flat sheet of 3/4in pine plywood, painted. Probably bolted to a steel frame. One for left, one for right.
 
I have (8) JBL LE14A woofers in my possession and I would love to build an OB system around them. Four for left, four for right. Kinda like this...

The HF driver in this scenario is a Tang Band w5 full range driver.

Does this seem viable? Looking around I don't see ANYONE else doing something like this. Just a flat sheet of 3/4in pine plywood, painted. Probably bolted to a steel frame.

The JBL's qts is too low unless you are going to eq them.
If the TB is going to be OB also, the crossover would need to be higher than previously mentioned.
If eq'ing the JBLs and using them, I would be inclined to place 2 below the wideband driver with a separate baffle for 2 more that can be placed as needed including slightly behind the full range baffle.
 
I would be inclined to place 2 below the wideband driver with a separate baffle for 2 more that can be placed as needed including slightly behind the full range baffle.

I follow everything you said but this ^^

Could you explain a little more?

I do plan on using the LE14A woofers and I can add eq if needed.
 
woofer-behind-woofer.webp
 
One woofer directly in front of another? Interesting...

So, one thing I am trying to wrap my head around at the moment is the different types of baffles used.

Looking around, I see the following commonly used. There are others, but these are the common ones.

1 -- H frame
2 -- U frame
3 -- Flat baffle with no frame or wrap-around

I am having difficulty understanding how to choose.

I was planning on #3 because that is what most people seem to use looking around on the net and it looks the simplest to DIY.
 
OK, first idea scrapped.


Moving along.


I have (8) JBL LE14A woofers in my possession and I would love to build an OB system around them. Four for left, four for right. Kinda like this...



View attachment 2423180





But unfortunately, thats a little too much for me to build. So I was thinking something more like this.





View attachment 2423183



The HF driver in this scenario is a Tang Band w5 full range driver.



Does this seem viable? Looking around I don't see ANYONE else doing something like this. Just a flat sheet of 3/4in pine plywood, painted. Probably bolted to a steel frame. One for left, one for right.

The PAP Treo and up are actually fairly easy to clone. You make 4 or 5 small panels which is MUCH easier to move around setup etc... the hardest part is figuring out the rear support. How will you be cutting the baffles ? router, Jig Saw or ?

If you are using a Router the rear supports are fairly easy as well have a look at the Spatial X2, I have cloned these 2 separate times. I found them MUCH better than the PAP

X2 rear.PNG
 
Another poster pointed/reminded me toward this thread, which I contributed to at some point in the past, but I'm back to ask for help for an OB Dummie (me).

Several years ago I build a pair of OBs in the Caintuck tombstone style, each with an Eminence Alpha 15a and a Wild Burro Betsy driver. To drive them requires bi-amping and I've kept it very simple by applying tone controls to the Eminence Alphas to send them bass while sending full range to the Betsy drivers. They sound decent but I know they'd sound better if they were properly crossed over and I can hear a midrange boost where the Betsy drivers and Alphas are both putting out the same frequencies. It can be simpler and better, but I don't know how to get there.

I also hate the multiple cables and having to split signals and run two amps just to make them operate. I really want to simplify.

But, I don't know what I'm doing in that realm and I'm interested in simplifying, so I'd like each side to run using one set of speaker cables and I don't want to play around with electronic crossovers or DSP boxes and the like.

Can someone please walk me through what I need to add to apply appropriate crossover for these things? I picture adding a small platform/base at the foot of each speaker that would include required bits and speakers jacks of some sort. I see places like PartsExpress offering passive speaker crossovers but don't know where to begin.

Thanks in advance for any help/advice you can provide!
 
Another poster pointed/reminded me toward this thread, which I contributed to at some point in the past, but I'm back to ask for help for an OB Dummie (me).

Several years ago I build a pair of OBs in the Caintuck tombstone style, each with an Eminence Alpha 15a and a Wild Burro Betsy driver. To drive them requires bi-amping and I've kept it very simple by applying tone controls to the Eminence Alphas to send them bass while sending full range to the Betsy drivers. They sound decent but I know they'd sound better if they were properly crossed over and I can hear a midrange boost where the Betsy drivers and Alphas are both putting out the same frequencies. It can be simpler and better, but I don't know how to get there.

I also hate the multiple cables and having to split signals and run two amps just to make them operate. I really want to simplify.

But, I don't know what I'm doing in that realm and I'm interested in simplifying, so I'd like each side to run using one set of speaker cables and I don't want to play around with electronic crossovers or DSP boxes and the like.

Can someone please walk me through what I need to add to apply appropriate crossover for these things? I picture adding a small platform/base at the foot of each speaker that would include required bits and speakers jacks of some sort. I see places like PartsExpress offering passive speaker crossovers but don't know where to begin.

Thanks in advance for any help/advice you can provide!

You would need a 2 way passive cutting the bass off at 150 - 200 Hz and sending the balance to the Burro. Most including me would run the Burro at full range and put a low pass filter on the bass driver cutting it off at the same 150 or 200 Hz. Call Parts Express or Madisound either one can help you with a unit ready to plug and play
 
Is there a way to pass full signal to the Betsy and low-pass the Eminence without requiring two sets of speaker cable coming from two amps though? My big thing right now is to create a more "conventional" set up, running these things from one amp, one set of speaker cable to each OB. I'm sick of the bi-amping stuff in this particular application.



You would need a 2 way passive cutting the bass off at 150 - 200 Hz and sending the balance to the Burro. Most including me would run the Burro at full range and put a low pass filter on the bass driver cutting it off at the same 150 or 200 Hz. Call Parts Express or Madisound either one can help you with a unit ready to plug and play
 
Is there a way to pass full signal to the Betsy and low-pass the Eminence without requiring two sets of speaker cable coming from two amps though? My big thing right now is to create a more "conventional" set up, running these things from one amp, one set of speaker cable to each OB. I'm sick of the bi-amping stuff in this particular application.

Honestly I just use a crown XLS1002 for my bass as it has the built in Low Pass filter. I am Positive that you can run a low pass filter only on the bass in parallel sort of like many folks will run a 1st order for a tweeter, with the Burro at full range. Not sure how that might affect the Burro SQ. I would still call and discuss with the pro's at Madisound / Parts Express

I see no reason you could not connect something like this to your bass driver (You would need one for each Bass driver) then split your speaker wire so that it run to the Burro and then to the Low Pass here. Your speaker wire would have to split in front of the Lowpass. I would personally run it parallel to start.
I would bet you could get something like this cheaper if you call them

https://www.parts-express.com/PRV-Audio-1DF180B-Low-Pass-Crossover-Board-180-Hz-294-2863

burro and bass diagram.png
 
Excellent and thanks! I frankly didn't know that it might be possible to split the speaker cables that way. Much appreciated and I'll look into low pass filters and implementations. I'll report back after some experimentation.
 
Back
Top Bottom