• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

How do you guys with open baffle speakers, deal with the Dipole Peaking frequency??
I see no crossover that would actually deal with that.....so??

Set your low pass crossover frequency below the dipole hump and your high pass crossover frequency above the dipole hump, use second order filters. The hump will fill in the gap and produce a smooth transition between the two drivers. Passive or active this trick works great. You can model this in BASTA for your drivers and baffle design and dial in the crossover very accurately.

https://www.tolvan.com/index.php?page=/basta/basta.php
 
Does your active preamp do that too?

Wouldnt you need a passive pre to avoid this?

No as my preamp doesn't divide the frequencies. Much of the problem with crossovers ( active or passive ) comes from a less than ideal attempt at stitching two dissimilar drivers together. Have you experienced high quality full range single drivers running unabated?
 
Set your low pass crossover frequency below the dipole hump and your high pass crossover frequency above the dipole hump, use second order filters. The hump will fill in the gap and produce a smooth transition between the two drivers. Passive or active this trick works great. You can model this in BASTA for your drivers and baffle design and dial in the crossover very accurately.

https://www.tolvan.com/index.php?page=/basta/basta.php


Thank you!

I got the feeling many are simply not aware, or ignoring the Peaking frequency.
FYI not an expert here for sure, but DO find some nice benefits with this type of speaker, but also some negatives.

Some are works of art, but most I have heard were from the early days of audio!
 
Another way it is addressed is to always operate the drivers below the dipole hump where the baffle is rolling the response off at 6 dB/octave. Boost and EQ are used to bring the response back to flat. This requires each driver to operate over a very narrow band of frequencies and the system to be at least a 3 way, if not a 4 way, active system with each higher frequency driver in a progressively narrower baffle. No driver operates at or above the dipole hump. This is Linkwitz's method of OB design.

https://www.linkwitzlab.com/

Like everything in life there are lots of trade-offs and no one perfect solution. But I agree that there appear to be a lot of people winging it with their OB designs. Crossovers are tricky and can make or break the performance (ignoring or not using a crossover on each driver is a mistake IMO).
 
No as my preamp doesn't divide the frequencies. Much of the problem with crossovers ( active or passive ) comes from a less than ideal attempt at stitching two dissimilar drivers together. Have you experienced high quality full range single drivers running unabated?

This ;););)
 
Last edited:
Exactly my designs with same drivers, crossovers, and amps? Or an interpretation of the designs?

Yes I built the Lowther DX3 in MLTL exactly by your plans. They sound decent but the same drivers in open baffles ( see my avatar ) without crossovers or corrective circuits trounced them. The OB woofers use their own amp with a low pass. I know you use solid state amps while I use SET amps so that alone constitutes a difference.

I have used several different active crossovers in bi-amped OBs and each time they killed the magic of the SET amp. We've had this same conversation several other times and you know I'm not alone in my beliefs and experiences.
 
Last edited:
To quote Jacob George of Rethm speakers:

"Use the wide bander as a wide bander with no restrictions whatsoever and no filters. And just bring in the bass to fill in what the wide bander can not do."
 
The ML TL design is a single driver full range boxed speaker. Add a dedicated woofer making it a two way will improve performance. Also being a boxed speaker the low frequency motion of the full range driver cone is controlled by the box. It is what it is and performs as designed. An apples to oranges comparison to a two way OB design using the same/similar full range drivers.

Rethm speakers do not seem to be OB so the box again controls the low frequency motion of the full range driver cone and a sub seems to be contained inside the enclosure to help with the bass. another apples to oranges comparison to a two way OB speaker system.

I have run my two way OB speaker without any crossover on the full range driver. At first it sounded good but then I realized that having the woofers and the full range drivers overlapping for a broad range of frequencies centered around 100 Hz (the dipole hump region) was the reason (verified with measurements). It provided a pleasing over emphasized warm mid bass response, but after a while is just did not sound natural or accurate. Also, the full range driver was exposed to low frequencies which without support from a box may lead to excessive cone motion and distortion. Adding the crossover back cleaned up the sound of the full range driver and in my opinion produced a more accurate balanced presentation of the music. A full range driver, with a low Xmax, and crossover does what it is good at and is not asked to produce the low frequencies.

Tube amps struggle with the low frequency crossovers used in two way OB speakers, I don't know why. I have a tube amplifier and it produces an anemic bass performance with my various passive crossover OB speakers, it sounds good on full range driver boxed designs but not on the passive OB designs. Switching to a SS amp provided a much superior result with the two way OB speakers, I am not a fan of tube amps.

At this point I will duck out of the discussion, I have presented my thinking and posters can decide for themselves what makes technical sense in their own designs.
 
The ML TL design is a single driver full range boxed speaker. Add a dedicated woofer making it a two way will improve performance. Also being a boxed speaker the low frequency motion of the full range driver cone is controlled by the box. It is what it is and performs as designed. An apples to oranges comparison to a two way OB design using the same/similar full range drivers.

Rethm speakers do not seem to be OB so the box again controls the low frequency motion of the full range driver cone and a sub seems to be contained inside the enclosure to help with the bass. another apples to oranges comparison to a two way OB speaker system.

I have run my two way OB speaker without any crossover on the full range driver. At first it sounded good but then I realized that having the woofers and the full range drivers overlapping for a broad range of frequencies centered around 100 Hz (the dipole hump region) was the reason (verified with measurements). It provided a pleasing over emphasized warm mid bass response, but after a while is just did not sound natural or accurate. Also, the full range driver was exposed to low frequencies which without support from a box may lead to excessive cone motion and distortion. Adding the crossover back cleaned up the sound of the full range driver and in my opinion produced a more accurate balanced presentation of the music. A full range driver, with a low Xmax, and crossover does what it is good at and is not asked to produce the low frequencies.

Tube amps struggle with the low frequency crossovers used in two way OB speakers, I don't know why. I have a tube amplifier and it produces an anemic bass performance with my various passive crossover OB speakers, it sounds good on full range driver boxed designs but not on the passive OB designs. Switching to a SS amp provided a much superior result with the two way OB speakers, I am not a fan of tube amps.

At this point I will duck out of the discussion, I have presented my thinking and posters can decide for themselves what makes technical sense in their own designs.

The MLTL has good bass and when I blasted the empty cabinet with a leaf blower to remove the dust it sounded like a fog horn. But sadly the corrective circuit is like a shot of Novocain to the Lowthers. I would never use a single ended tube amp to drive bass woofers. You should always bi-amp OBs with the flea watt tube amp driving highly efficient wide bander with a powerful SS amp driving the bass woofers.
 
Last edited:
Thank you!

I got the feeling many are simply not aware, or ignoring the Peaking frequency.
FYI not an expert here for sure, but DO find some nice benefits with this type of speaker, but also some negatives.

Some are works of art, but most I have heard were from the early days of audio!

You and MJK must be referring to different things, he mentions "around 100hz" as the dipole hump region. :dunno:
With the higher frequencies you refer to the peak is minimized by a rectangular baffle.
 
No as my preamp doesn't divide the frequencies. Much of the problem with crossovers ( active or passive ) comes from a less than ideal attempt at stitching two dissimilar drivers together. Have you experienced high quality full range single drivers running unabated?
Any full range driver I have used up to this point has not been suited to playing below 100hz (sometimes I have needed a higher xover point). I have always felt that keeping the lows out helps them perform. Alleviating them, minimizing cone travel and lowering distortion.
 
Any full range driver I have used up to this point has not been suited to playing below 100hz (sometimes I have needed a higher xover point). I have always felt that keeping the lows out helps them perform. Alleviating them, minimizing cone travel and lowering distortion.
I agree. It makes a lot of sense, and my experience bears this out too.
 
Caintuck Audio offer all their OB bass woofers ( Alpha 15 and Lii W-15 ) powered by a plate amp while their full range OB speakers run full range without crossovers. Caintuck and Decware have a partnership. Randy even sells his Betsys on Steve's website. Here are the Betsy and Alpha on the same baffle which seems awfully crowded. No wonder they didn't sell. My point is there are other options than a passive or active crossover for open baffles.

http://www.caintuckaudio.com/Betsy_Buck.html
 
Last edited:
Here are the Lii Audio F-15 and W-15 bass woofers from Caintuck. I understand that Steve licensed the barrel shape baffle from Randy which allows Caintuck to advertise on the Decware site. Another example of OB's without crossovers as the plate amp brings in the W-15 bass woofer to fill in what the unfiltered full range F-15 drivers can't produce. My baffles for the F-15's ( currently on a slow boat from China ) are much larger than Randy's barrels but within the 2.2 rule.

Lii-15_08232021_medium.jpg
 
Any full range driver I have used up to this point has not been suited to playing below 100hz (sometimes I have needed a higher xover point). I have always felt that keeping the lows out helps them perform. Alleviating them, minimizing cone travel and lowering distortion.

It seems to me that if this was a real problem for everyone no one would run the wideband driver without a filter of some sort, and yet many do use them without any high pass. Including some with a lot of experience and good hearing.

Tradeoffs
How loud is the music?
Theory and real life experience don't always agree.
 
Last edited:
Any full range driver I have used up to this point has not been suited to playing below 100hz (sometimes I have needed a higher xover point). I have always felt that keeping the lows out helps them perform. Alleviating them, minimizing cone travel and lowering distortion.

What are the full range drivers that you are referring to? I don't recognize any of the drivers in your photos.
 
Here are the Lii Audio F-15 and W-15 bass woofers from Caintuck. I understand that Steve licensed the barrel shape baffle from Randy which allows Caintuck to advertise on the Decware site. Another example of OB's without crossovers as the plate amp brings in the W-15 bass woofer to fill in what the unfiltered full range F-15 drivers can't produce. My baffles for the F-15's ( currently on a slow boat from China ) are much larger than Randy's barrels but within the 2.2 rule.

Lii-15_08232021_medium.jpg

Most of us Decware forum members are not using any type of crossover.

What several of us do is use a Crown subwoofer amp to power our bass drivers. The Crown has volume and crossover control.

Several are using an up-firing super tweeter to add a little sparkle to the high end.

With this setup, I have never felt a need to try something different. However, I will say that I have never heard a similar setup incorporating a crossover.

YMMV.
 
Back
Top Bottom