I understand and agree with much is being said here by JMelton. The scientific knowledge on the specific effects of various chemicals on phonographic records is extremely lacking. There was a past period where people cared and put energy towards this, but that time is long gone as there is no longer any financial support for research on such an obsolete technology, despite the fact that our technological abilities have expanded exponentially. It's a shame, but as Rich said, we can anticipate results based on what is known and, as Ripblade stated, what has been experienced. What we can do is not ignore the existing body of knowledge and instead use it in a quest to do the best that we can. Indeed, this is what this thread has been all about.
It is accepted that there are many ways to clean a record including those employing household products. It is also accepted, however, that there are those who strive for something specific, or something extraordinary. After all, this is an attribute of this hobby, where folks know that a common record player and cartridge will reproduce sound from a record just fine, but there are some who seek something more. Neither is wrong, and there are threads here for both and everything in between.
Face it, the hobby is filled with tweekers whether they be cartridge rotators, tube rollers, capacitor swappers, or record cleaners. For me, I seek to understand what the records are made of, what constitutes the contaminants they are susceptible to, and how best to separate them without negatively affecting the product in terms of sound reproduction, quality, and longevity.
I have performed many studies, in a laboratory setting, looking into this both as a self-funded hobbyist and as a paid consultant. Yet while I find I am shooting rather blind due to the general lack of scientific research, I feel there are still enough enthusiasts out there to do our own "crowd study", which is why I enjoy this thread. I feel less enthusiastic when I read threads about people spraying some grocery store product on their records and stating how great it worked without providing any basis behind the action, any measurement for the results, or any consideration for possible harm it may do. So I would encourage all to test various solutions, compare them, analyze results, and post them. Our ears and minds are open!