• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Could the US inducers themselves perhaps be heating the water? Any inducer will give off some heat when energized, but I don't know how much, and that's a lot of rise in a short time!
Inducers do produce heat and that is why they tell you to let them sit after 15 or 20 minutes but I don't think it is sufficient to raise the water temp.Not with my machine and it has 240 watts of cleaning and 300 watts of heating action.
 
I "liked" this for the inevitable debate, but I must admit I trust a biochemist/music lover with science on his side.

I have been reading this thinking about the scientific aspect. The main objection to a simple product like Dawn (or its much cheaper clones that can be had from Home Depot or as a generic dish soap) seems to be an a priori look at the molecules involved. Has any real *scientific* work been done on this? Now the scientists will know exactly what I'm asking but for the lay people I mean: What controlled experiments were done to see how much difference in static can be measured, how much that level of extra static charge affects dust accumulation or playback, and how persistent is that effect over time?

I clean vinyl very infrequently. So is the difference between supermarket-shelf dish detergent (maybe go for the one with no scent etc) and Triton X100 a very minor effect that lasts at most 1 week every 5 years (I probably wash records no more than once a decade, but being liberal here)? That low an effect means I just have no interest in taking the time and effort to buy a special product and dilute it precisely and store it in yet another container that I have to keep track of etc.

That said given all the "special sauce" recipes I'm reading I guess a lot of people do want to take the extra time and effort. So this is more a matter of asking not what's the best approach to spending any amount of time and effort to clean records, but instead asking what will I get by spending all this extra time and effort that today I perceive as of no real value?
 
I have been reading this thinking about the scientific aspect. The main objection to a simple product like Dawn (or its much cheaper clones that can be had from Home Depot or as a generic dish soap) seems to be an a priori look at the molecules involved. Has any real *scientific* work been done on this? Now the scientists will know exactly what I'm asking but for the lay people I mean: What controlled experiments were done to see how much difference in static can be measured, how much that level of extra static charge affects dust accumulation or playback, and how persistent is that effect over time?

I clean vinyl very infrequently. So is the difference between supermarket-shelf dish detergent (maybe go for the one with no scent etc) and Triton X100 a very minor effect that lasts at most 1 week every 5 years (I probably wash records no more than once a decade, but being liberal here)? That low an effect means I just have no interest in taking the time and effort to buy a special product and dilute it precisely and store it in yet another container that I have to keep track of etc.

That said given all the "special sauce" recipes I'm reading I guess a lot of people do want to take the extra time and effort. So this is more a matter of asking not what's the best approach to spending any amount of time and effort to clean records, but instead asking what will I get by spending all this extra time and effort that today I perceive as of no real value?
So: You are skeptical and would like for someone to prove to you the cost analysis of benefit before you want to trust what is said here?
 
General record cleaning has discussion threads all over the site. This thread, and its associated resource thread, is intended for those who want to squeeze the last drops out of the lemon.

As for "off the shelf" products, one serious problem is the lack of scientific studies to show that the various and sundry additives do not do harm, short or long term. Some effects are definitely known, or can be scientifically anticipated. The goal is to know what is in "it," so results can be scientifically anticipated, and avoided if desired.

Read this thread: Record Cleaning: A Comprehensive Resource for specifics relating to what we are doing in this thread. The thread is still developing, so there remain many concepts to be addressed.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
So: You are skeptical and would like for someone to prove to you the cost analysis of benefit before you want to trust what is said here?

What was I thinking?!

I guess the thing I'm asking before I accept that something is scientifically demonstrated is "what scientific work was done?" That's not too much to ask of a scientific conclusion surely? ;)
 
What was I thinking?!

I guess the thing I'm asking before I accept that something is scientifically demonstrated is "what scientific work was done?" That's not too much to ask of a scientific conclusion surely? ;)
I just wanted to clarify your request. Re-examine my question and you will see that there is zero judgement rendered nor aimed.
 
Of course, scientific thinker that you appear to be; You could examine the Material Data Safety sheets for each of the individual formulas. It would also be worthwhile to look up the scientific analysis that has already been documented about individual elements of the formulas.

Lots for you to research for yourself also.
 
I have been reading this thinking about the scientific aspect. The main objection to a simple product like Dawn (or its much cheaper clones that can be had from Home Depot or as a generic dish soap) seems to be an a priori look at the molecules involved. Has any real *scientific* work been done on this? Now the scientists will know exactly what I'm asking but for the lay people I mean: What controlled experiments were done to see how much difference in static can be measured, how much that level of extra static charge affects dust accumulation or playback, and how persistent is that effect over time?

I clean vinyl very infrequently. So is the difference between supermarket-shelf dish detergent (maybe go for the one with no scent etc) and Triton X100 a very minor effect that lasts at most 1 week every 5 years (I probably wash records no more than once a decade, but being liberal here)? That low an effect means I just have no interest in taking the time and effort to buy a special product and dilute it precisely and store it in yet another container that I have to keep track of etc.

That said given all the "special sauce" recipes I'm reading I guess a lot of people do want to take the extra time and effort. So this is more a matter of asking not what's the best approach to spending any amount of time and effort to clean records, but instead asking what will I get by spending all this extra time and effort that today I perceive as of no real value?
Speaking for myself, I've tried just about every recipe, method or internet fad out there, including a few I invented myself. The formula discussed herein is the most effective, sensible solution I've tried. Not a scientific examination... just an experiential observation.

For one who seldom cleans records, the effort needed to try this on their own is probably not worth it, nor is the quest for anything better than the basic sink wash with dish soap.
 
I understand and agree with much is being said here by JMelton. The scientific knowledge on the specific effects of various chemicals on phonographic records is extremely lacking. There was a past period where people cared and put energy towards this, but that time is long gone as there is no longer any financial support for research on such an obsolete technology, despite the fact that our technological abilities have expanded exponentially. It's a shame, but as Rich said, we can anticipate results based on what is known and, as Ripblade stated, what has been experienced. What we can do is not ignore the existing body of knowledge and instead use it in a quest to do the best that we can. Indeed, this is what this thread has been all about.

It is accepted that there are many ways to clean a record including those employing household products. It is also accepted, however, that there are those who strive for something specific, or something extraordinary. After all, this is an attribute of this hobby, where folks know that a common record player and cartridge will reproduce sound from a record just fine, but there are some who seek something more. Neither is wrong, and there are threads here for both and everything in between.

Face it, the hobby is filled with tweekers whether they be cartridge rotators, tube rollers, capacitor swappers, or record cleaners. For me, I seek to understand what the records are made of, what constitutes the contaminants they are susceptible to, and how best to separate them without negatively affecting the product in terms of sound reproduction, quality, and longevity.

I have performed many studies, in a laboratory setting, looking into this both as a self-funded hobbyist and as a paid consultant. Yet while I find I am shooting rather blind due to the general lack of scientific research, I feel there are still enough enthusiasts out there to do our own "crowd study", which is why I enjoy this thread. I feel less enthusiastic when I read threads about people spraying some grocery store product on their records and stating how great it worked without providing any basis behind the action, any measurement for the results, or any consideration for possible harm it may do. So I would encourage all to test various solutions, compare them, analyze results, and post them. Our ears and minds are open!
 
Last edited:
I would ask anyone who is requesting contributors to this thread provide scientific proof of their observations or findings:

Have you read and investigated every post on this thread before making that request? There is a mountain of references/links/information already provided on this thread that will answer quite a few lines of inquiry.
 
Theophile's insightful comment reminds me of another thread where there was discussion on how great a dry Swiffer pad was at cleaning a record. I did a little research and found the pads contain mineral oil. Knowing that this oil was included in the product to hold collected dust, I questioned its use as oil tends to transfer when wiped against another material. So I did a very basic experiment (channeling an inner Richard Feynman) where I wiped half the record with the Swiffer and left the other half alone, then dipped the record in a bin of dust (a central vac canister), removed it, and blew off the free dust with air. I presented the data in photos as a post in the thread, where dust was visibly stuck to the Swiffer treated side. While the implications were obvious and easily repeatable by anyone in this very simple experiment, there remained doubt by many. My point is that no matter the evidence, there are still those who will not accept any suggestion that goes against their habitual practice. To advance, it is essential that we resist this human trait and try to keep open minds.
 
Last edited:
I would ask anyone who is requesting contributors to this thread provide scientific proof of their observations or findings:

Have you read and investigated every post on this thread before making that request? There is a mountain of references/links/information already provided on this thread that will answer quite a few lines of inquiry.

There are 100+ pages of posts. I haven't read them all, but honestly I shouldn't have to.

The first claim made is that you need to switch from Dawn to Triton X 100 (or similar) because of the extra static you will get if you don't. Well, how much extra? Given that this is the first and principal claim, and I did read the first three pages following it and found nothing to support this claim except as I said the a priori look at molecules, I asked what is surely the most obvious question. "What was actually measured? How big is this static effect and how long does it persist? Can it be mitigated by 50% or 90% or 99.999% by using a humidifier? Basically: How important is this really?"

I stopped reading at the point of someone saying they would believe the scientist because well, he's a scientist. But I have to say "science" means something. It's not just a word to throw around casually IMO. And I say that after having spent 1000s of hours working on research for publishing that needed to pass scientific review.

It's just not good enough to say "I'm a scientist. Trust me."
 
There are 100+ pages of posts. I haven't read them all, but honestly I shouldn't have to.

The first claim made is that you need to switch from Dawn to Triton X 100 (or similar) because of the extra static you will get if you don't. Well, how much extra? Given that this is the first and principal claim, and I did read the first three pages following it and found nothing to support this claim except as I said the a priori look at molecules, I asked what is surely the most obvious question. "What was actually measured? How big is this static effect and how long does it persist? Can it be mitigated by 50% or 90% or 99.999% by using a humidifier? Basically: How important is this really?"
I stopped reading at the point of someone saying they would believe the scientist because well, he's a scientist. But I have to say "science" means something. It's not just a word to throw around casually IMO. And I say that after having spent 1000s of hours working on research for publishing that needed to pass scientific review.
It's just not good enough to say "I'm a scientist. Trust me."

Agree 100% with this. That said, in this instance there were subsequent posts where a summary of the results and the device used for measurements were described. As this is more of a hobbyist group rather than a peer-reviewed journal, tables of data would not play well. Instead, most (myself included) have taken the tactic of presenting basic result summaries and concepts, with a discussion of the logic behind them. This with the goal of hopefully presenting something new to try or incorporate into a cleaning regimen. As has been stated many times, we are merely cleaning records here, not seeking cures for cancer.

To answer your specific questions:
How is it measured? I measure static charge on records using a 3M 711 charge analyzer (shown in post #1586).
How big is the effect and how long does it persist? Not sure what you are asking to compare here, but a static free record has zero charge while a charged record exhibits a huge range (milli to mega Volts). It persists indefinitely, until discharged.
Can it be mitigted by humidity? Yes, this is explained in the resource sticky.
How important is this? Really important to some. The number one source of contamination is that which is attracted via electrostatic interaction. A record is not clean if it contains a static charge as it will accumulate dust from the environment and sound will be affected. It isn't important if pops and clicks aren't distracting to you so it is a personal determination.
Hope this helps, but there isn't a lot in the literature, believe me, though the relevant historical papers and patents have been linked and discussed throughout this thread if you look. Indeed, there are a lot of pages to sort through, which is why the resource thread was started.
 
Last edited:
Moderation Note:

The original title for this thread has pretty much always been rather unfortunate, serving as challenging and inflammatory. In keeping with the true purpose for this thread, I have changed the title to something a bit more appropriate.

Rich P
 
If I am using the Triton and Hepastat mix diluted in my 2 gallon ultrasonic cleaner, can I get by with one rinse per side after I remove the records from the US cleaner?
 
If I am using the Triton and Hepastat mix diluted in my 2 gallon ultrasonic cleaner, can I get by with one rinse per side after I remove the records from the US cleaner?
This is not in response to your question, but looking at what you are using in your mix, I wonder if a bit of flocculant would be beneficial in the ultrasonic cleaning formulae. If not, why not?

Let's ask. Paging @phantomrebel

I would like to request an installment in our resource thread addressing flocculants and chelating agents.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
In response to some of the points raised here recently, I decided to post a new installment on additives like chelators, flocculants, etc in the Resource sticky.

Also, thanks to the moderator for changing the title to this large thread to something less confrontational. :beerchug:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom