• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Newbie. Has anyone considered using Tergazyme? From what I have read, it would seem safe, but I am definitely not the expert here.
 
Tergazyme contains the enzyme subtilisin which, as a protease, helps digest proteinaceous contaminants. However, the formula is about 30% sodium tripolyphosphate, an alkaline salt. This is awfully harsh to put on your delicate records when neutral, mild detergent solutions are available and are very effective. Having not tested the product, I am not saying it isn't safe, I just believe there are way better (broader spectrum) enzymatic treatments if a particular record should require it.
 
Given the small expense in making your own solutions, doesn’t it make sense to replace the cleaning fluid rather than filterIng it?

I've got about 600 records (and growing). So if I refresh the bath every 18 records (which, depending on the records might already be pretty filthy), that means ~33 tank refills. I'm not getting distilled water for $.39/gallon. For me, the closest grocery store has it at $1.09. Given about 1.5 gallons for 6L, that's around $50 in just distilled water. Which... cost of filter, housing and pump were right around that. So it's close to a push even before accounting for any of the IPA, Hepstat 256, or the Titron, Never mind the time cost or the pain-in-the-assedness of continually mixing up more solution. YMMY. Generally I'd rather consume less stuff in the process (which, to be honest I don't know the carbon footprint of my filter and housing) but I'm guessing I'm probably coming out ahead.
 
Whatever works for you, but I've washed thousands of records at a solution cost of about 5 pennies per record. Your water cost is high, but still only 8 cents per record (not including rinses). Since they typically only need deep cleaning once, this is still a bargain in my book. I don't use IPA in US tank cleaning, and the other reagents I have lifetime supplies of at the concentrations I use. Cost (to the pocketbook and environment) doesn't drive my process, but I understand this isn't always the case. The bigger cost for me is in decent sleeves. The issue with filtration is that it depletes detergent (it forms complexes with the contaminants and gets filtered out). Since I like to use a minimum amount of detergent, this is an issue for me. The filtrate also contains dissolved contaminants that pass through. I would hesitate to filter the water I use to clean my dishes or body and re-use it for the same reason, though the world might have to head in that direction. How much is a filter and how long do they last? If the water re-circulates during the US process, is cavitation efficiency affected (discussed previously)? How does one store a wet filter, pump, and tubing between wash sessions so they don't get moldy? Just some points to discuss.
 
If you are using a filtration system what filter are you using? Would a carbon filter actually remove the detergents from the water? How many microns are sufficient?
 
Tergazyme contains the enzyme subtilisin which, as a protease, helps digest proteinaceous contaminants. However, the formula is about 30% sodium tripolyphosphate, an alkaline salt. This is awfully harsh to put on your delicate records when neutral, mild detergent solutions are available and are very effective. Having not tested the product, I am not saying it isn't safe, I just believe there are way better (broader spectrum) enzymatic treatments if a particular record should require it.
THANK YOU.
 
Santa brought me a US Tank and a vinyl stack.
I'll get some time to using it on Monday. My question is, how long does the vinyl need to be in the water for it be clean?
I figured 5 minutes would be plenty so a rotation of 10 minutes should be enough to clean an entire record.
Any thoughts on this?

I have used the same ultrasonic cleaning system and I let it run for 10 minutes. I suppose 5 min. would be good enough, but it was set up in the garage and I got tired of going back and forth that quick. I rarely did more than 1 record on the Vinyl Stack. All of the records were pre cleaned on a VPI machine and then later on a hand made setup with a broken turntable and a small shop vac, so the US only had to get rid of debris the other method missed.
 
If you are using a filtration system what filter are you using? Would a carbon filter actually remove the detergents from the water? How many microns are sufficient?

There's another massive thread here:

https://www.diyaudio.com/forums/analogue-source/218276-version-ultrasonic-record-cleaner-201.html

There's lots of overlap in that thread with this one. That page linked above has the OP with some thoughts on a 1 micron v. a .35 micron filter. Also if you go to page 214 (currently the last page in the thread) there is a parts list for the filtration system he set up. The cheap pump he originally bought for $19 now runs close to $100, but there are numerous pumps in the $20 range on Amazon as well as other places.
 
I use 40C but I preheat my water and have gone over that many times. I don't know what is the most effective temp is I just know you won't damage the records at 43C

I still have the question of at what point does the temperature of the water create a damaging effect on the record? I've done some searches on this thread about this and somehow missed it if it was indeed discussed. Does anyone have any ideas? My US cleaner is still getting pretty warm after three VinylStacks at 15 minutes each. Would approach 45 degrees and maybe higher if I chose to do more records. Right now I'm limiting my cleaning sessions to 9 records because I am not sure that 45 degrees C. or maybe even higher if I try to run it for a 4th cycle would be harmful to the vinyl, as in create warps.....
 
There's another massive thread here:

https://www.diyaudio.com/forums/analogue-source/218276-version-ultrasonic-record-cleaner-201.html

There's lots of overlap in that thread with this one. That page linked above has the OP with some thoughts on a 1 micron v. a .35 micron filter. Also if you go to page 214 (currently the last page in the thread) there is a parts list for the filtration system he set up. The cheap pump he originally bought for $19 now runs close to $100, but there are numerous pumps in the $20 range on Amazon as well as other places.
to view the parts list you have to be a member.
 
I still have the question of at what point does the temperature of the water create a damaging effect on the record? I've done some searches on this thread about this and somehow missed it if it was indeed discussed. Does anyone have any ideas? My US cleaner is still getting pretty warm after three VinylStacks at 15 minutes each. Would approach 45 degrees and maybe higher if I chose to do more records. Right now I'm limiting my cleaning sessions to 9 records because I am not sure that 45 degrees C. or maybe even higher if I try to run it for a 4th cycle would be harmful to the vinyl, as in create warps.....

I’m wondering if the heat issue is record specific... I ran 2 records @ 43.2 with a rotation of 1 rotation every 3-4 seconds and I watched the albums disfigure enough that it scared me. I pulled them out and they straightened as they cooled. I put 2 different records in at the same parameters and saw nothing untoward at all. I was not using a stand-alone thermometer but I will be doing so going forward.
 
Well unfortunately my US tank is faulty. The heating side of it isn't working unless the US is active. Replacement due on Monday.
I was shocked to see how much debris was in the tank after cleaning 6 records.
So I decided that a filtration system will be easier than dumping the water every 6 records.
Of the 6 records I cleaned I would say I was happy with the results. I need to fine tune but all in all I'd say a great investment.
 
I’m wondering if the heat issue is record specific... I ran 2 records @ 43.2 with a rotation of 1 rotation every 3-4 seconds and I watched the albums disfigure enough that it scared me. I pulled them out and they straightened as they cooled. I put 2 different records in at the same parameters and saw nothing untoward at all. I was not using a stand-alone thermometer but I will be doing so going forward.


Thermostat reads 44, thermometer reads 41.8
 
I’m wondering if the heat issue is record specific... I ran 2 records @ 43.2 with a rotation of 1 rotation every 3-4 seconds and I watched the albums disfigure enough that it scared me. I pulled them out and they straightened as they cooled. I put 2 different records in at the same parameters and saw nothing untoward at all. I was not using a stand-alone thermometer but I will be doing so going forward.
Do you mean one rotation every 3-4 minutes? I have found 16 minutes at 2 revolutions to be ideal.
 
Holy crap. I never thought record cleaning could be so complex and technical. Makes me think there could be a service industry for this? Has anyone made a business of professional record cleaning for customers? Any businesses like this in the Portland area?
 
Do you mean one rotation every 3-4 minutes? I have found 16 minutes at 2 revolutions to be ideal.
No it truly was every 3-4 seconds...
I’ve purchased a new power brick with adjustable voltage and am now running closer to what you are... my spindle motor did not have a speed adjustment
 
Holy crap. I never thought record cleaning could be so complex and technical. Makes me think there could be a service industry for this? Has anyone made a business of professional record cleaning for customers? Any businesses like this in the Portland area?

a lot of record shops here in FL will clean records, but they charge like 3 to 5 bucks per album
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom