Coming back for more here as I have made some new-ish discoveries and wanted to share them with you all. I am especially interested in Phantomrebel's thoughts about them.
Posting inquiries on another forum produced an interesting philosophy that suggests the most effective solution may be one that is just distilled water and a .1 - .5% concentration of Tergitol 15-S-9. Now that is very, very simple and for me, if indeed as effective as the 3 ingredient formula I'm now using (IPA, Hepastat, Triton X-100), simplicity is very appealing.
Here are some of the comments for your perusal:
"As a suggestion, substitute Tergitol 15-S-9 for the Triton X100. You can buy this at Talas, one pint is $21.75. The 15-S-9 is very similar to the 15-S-7 that the Smithsonian uses for shellac record cleaning, except it has a higher cloud point which would be better suited for the heated UT tank use. The Tergital is an Secondary Alcohol Ethoxylate NID and should be superior to Triton X100 which is a Octylphenol Ethoxylate NID. With the Tergitol 15-S-9 which has lower surface tension and better rinesability, you
should not need the Isopopyl Alcohol (IPA)."
and....
"I would try with only a .1 to .5% concentration, leaving out the IPA and the Hepastat. This would be the absolutely safest chemistry to you and the vinyl. If you have some really grungy records, do a pre-clean step to remove the visible contamination - put a label protector on, and pre-clean with a soft brush and the .1% 15-S-9 solution, rinse under flowing fresh water (i.e., kitchen sink), or use a vacuum record cleaning machine and then put in the UT for the final clean. The DOW literature shows that a 1% concentration of 15-S-9 will reduce the water surface tension from 72 down to about 30, so the solution will wet the record nicely, and may drain off fast enough to avoid need for a separate rinse. After the UT clean step, if you can, a quick spin of the record(s) in air should leave the record(s) near dry. And, with the record heated to about 100-125 deg F from the UT process, it will dry completely very quickly.
and....
"There are a number of theads that talk to the 15-S-3 and 15-S-9 mixture, some referencing that this is what the Canadian Archivists use, and some saying that the mixture equals 15-S-7. Surfactants are classified by the HLB Scale:
Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance. The 15-S-9 is rated 13.3 which classifies it as a detergent, and with its low surface tension, and not excessive foam height, and high cloud point should make it an excellent UT cleaning agent. 15-S-7 HLB is 12.1, and 15-S-3 is 8. When you blend 15-S-3 and 15-S-9, you get an emulsion with a HLB of 10.6, so this is not 15-S-7, so that rationale makes no sense. Otherwise, for the life of me, it makes no sense to clean a vinyl record with a blend of 15-S-3 and 15-S-9 that is an emulsion and can result in a cloudy solution, that decreases the effectiveness of the 15-S-9, and may inhibit rinsing. The only reason that you would add 15-S-3 to 15-S-9 would be as a defoaming agent. But UT cleaning should not cause a stable foam to develop, unlike if using a pumped parts washer. If you compare Triton X100 to 15-S-9, you will see similar HLB and surface tension 30 vs 33, but X100 can create a higher foam, and it is really intended for the metal cleaning industry where you are dealing with a lot of mineral based cutting oils and need the better oil emulsion properties, not some animal-fat based finger prints."
and....
"Hepastat 256 is a Bactericidal, used to disenfect surfaces. However, it has at 0.5 ounces per gallon, 886 ppm active quaternary ammonium compounds, and these salts are also used for antistatic in shampoos and fabric softeners. However, if you are going to add Hepastat why use distilled water, you are just adding salt to the distilled water; Hepastat its intended to be used in tap freshwater. Download the MSDS for Hepastat and look at the ingedients, its a spot cleaning agent complete with non-ionic surfactant and highly alkaline silicates.
If you want to keep a tank full of the DI water-Tergitol solution for weeks, keep covered, and once a week operate the tank (no records of course) at 165F for about 15-30 minutes, and any criters should be killed. PS, the recommendation discussed to store the Tergitol in a non-food refrigerator is based on preventing any accidental ingestion by a child, but at 33-41F, you may need to allow the Tergitol to warm up so can pour it out.
Otherwise, the wet cleaning process will remove any static charge from the record. Air dry or use an antistatic cloth to dry, such as Kinetronics Anti-Static Microfiber Cloth, 10x18-Inch Tiger Cloth (you can buy Amazon), and you should not cause a static charge to develop post cleaning."
So, lots to digest here and I'm hoping to hear back from you. Essentially, again, the simplest most effective formula (that's the goal for me) is what this quest is all about. Does the Hepastat help? Is it necessary? Is the IPA necessary? Can we get to where we want to be with just Tergitol 15-S-9? Would be nice, and by the way, much more environmentally friendly as well according to the information that was given:
"Tergitol 15-S-9 is a more environmentally friendly (and by DOW data should be more effective) alternative to Triton X100 which because of having components that can mimic estrogen, are toxic to fish, and there is 'some' associated human risk. DOW for now is continuing manufacture of Triton X100, but do not be suprised if they discontinue manufacture in the future as global environmental regulations increase. Conservationist (those conserving painting) use surfactants when cleaning/conserving paintings, and are very sensitive to using products that do no harm, or as little as possible. Some are using a non-ionic surfactant that appears very similar to the performance of Triton X100 and Tergitol 15-S-9: SURFONIC® JL-80X."
As a fishead, that part about "toxic to fish" makes my scales rattle!!!
Sorry for the length of this but wanted to include all I thought would be necessary to have a detailed conversation.
anovak
58 posts