• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not been having much luck with the US tanks I've gotten so far. The heater element has been faulty on both. Going to try a different brand.
Is it worth starting a thread solely to review and recommend US tanks?
I don't trust the reviews on Amazon as most are fake.
 
Not been having much luck with the US tanks I've gotten so far. The heater element has been faulty on both. Going to try a different brand.
Is it worth starting a thread solely to review and recommend US tanks?
I don't trust the reviews on Amazon as most are fake.
Such a thread might be a value to folks around here.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
Not been having much luck with the US tanks I've gotten so far. The heater element has been faulty on both. Going to try a different brand.
Is it worth starting a thread solely to review and recommend US tanks?
I don't trust the reviews on Amazon as most are fake.
If by 'faulty' you mean that as long as the US mechanism is running the temp just keeps going up, guess what? That's a feature. That was happening on my tank so I wrote the seller, thinking I had a bum unit. They said that was normal: that as long as the tank was running the bath temp would continue to rise, which makes no sense. Why even have an interface for temperature controls if you can't control the temp? It also limits the usefulness of these tanks if you have to stop your workflow so your bath doesn't warp the vinyl (and it might not; I haven't tested where mine actually maxes out temp wise).

Also, skeptical of having any luck with a different brand. In my experience a lot of these lower priced Chinese products are all literally the same product (from the same factory and everything) with slightly different labeling. I've seen this a fair amount with camera equipment. And skimming Amazon, the build of the various brands is near identical. Very much 'you get what you pay for'. Mine works pretty well but I can't run more than about 5 batched before I'm around 44C.
 
If by 'faulty' you mean that as long as the US mechanism is running the temp just keeps going up, guess what? That's a feature. That was happening on my tank so I wrote the seller, thinking I had a bum unit. They said that was normal: that as long as the tank was running the bath temp would continue to rise, which makes no sense. Why even have an interface for temperature controls if you can't control the temp? It also limits the usefulness of these tanks if you have to stop your workflow so your bath doesn't warp the vinyl (and it might not; I haven't tested where mine actually maxes out temp wise).

Also, skeptical of having any luck with a different brand. In my experience a lot of these lower priced Chinese products are all literally the same product (from the same factory and everything) with slightly different labeling. I've seen this a fair amount with camera equipment. And skimming Amazon, the build of the various brands is near identical. Very much 'you get what you pay for'. Mine works pretty well but I can't run more than about 5 batched before I'm around 44C.
The two I've previously tried would not heat unless the transducer was active. It would take 30 minutes to come to 35 degrees. It recommended no longer than 30 minutes of operation so I would then have to turn it off and wait 30 minutes and come back.
I at least want to be able to heat the water prior to the transducers being turned on.
I have a new model to try and I think I will stay a thread here in the coming days.
Everyone's experiences with these machines will be valuable.
 
So I did a very basic experiment (channeling an inner Richard Feynman) where I wiped half the record with the Swiffer and left the other half alone, then dipped the record in a bin of dust (a central vac canister), removed it, and blew off the free dust with air.

Oh, God, you're a Caltech chemist.

Well, apparently your wife has not made you quit your research job and teach high school. We all know where that path winds up.

-- Mark (Dabney '79)
 
Coming back for more here as I have made some new-ish discoveries and wanted to share them with you all. I am especially interested in Phantomrebel's thoughts about them.

Posting inquiries on another forum produced an interesting philosophy that suggests the most effective solution may be one that is just distilled water and a .1 - .5% concentration of Tergitol 15-S-9. Now that is very, very simple and for me, if indeed as effective as the 3 ingredient formula I'm now using (IPA, Hepastat, Triton X-100), simplicity is very appealing.

Here are some of the comments for your perusal:

"As a suggestion, substitute Tergitol 15-S-9 for the Triton X100. You can buy this at Talas, one pint is $21.75. The 15-S-9 is very similar to the 15-S-7 that the Smithsonian uses for shellac record cleaning, except it has a higher cloud point which would be better suited for the heated UT tank use. The Tergital is an Secondary Alcohol Ethoxylate NID and should be superior to Triton X100 which is a Octylphenol Ethoxylate NID. With the Tergitol 15-S-9 which has lower surface tension and better rinesability, you should not need the Isopopyl Alcohol (IPA)."

and....

"I would try with only a .1 to .5% concentration, leaving out the IPA and the Hepastat. This would be the absolutely safest chemistry to you and the vinyl. If you have some really grungy records, do a pre-clean step to remove the visible contamination - put a label protector on, and pre-clean with a soft brush and the .1% 15-S-9 solution, rinse under flowing fresh water (i.e., kitchen sink), or use a vacuum record cleaning machine and then put in the UT for the final clean. The DOW literature shows that a 1% concentration of 15-S-9 will reduce the water surface tension from 72 down to about 30, so the solution will wet the record nicely, and may drain off fast enough to avoid need for a separate rinse. After the UT clean step, if you can, a quick spin of the record(s) in air should leave the record(s) near dry. And, with the record heated to about 100-125 deg F from the UT process, it will dry completely very quickly.

and....

"There are a number of theads that talk to the 15-S-3 and 15-S-9 mixture, some referencing that this is what the Canadian Archivists use, and some saying that the mixture equals 15-S-7. Surfactants are classified by the HLB Scale: Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance. The 15-S-9 is rated 13.3 which classifies it as a detergent, and with its low surface tension, and not excessive foam height, and high cloud point should make it an excellent UT cleaning agent. 15-S-7 HLB is 12.1, and 15-S-3 is 8. When you blend 15-S-3 and 15-S-9, you get an emulsion with a HLB of 10.6, so this is not 15-S-7, so that rationale makes no sense. Otherwise, for the life of me, it makes no sense to clean a vinyl record with a blend of 15-S-3 and 15-S-9 that is an emulsion and can result in a cloudy solution, that decreases the effectiveness of the 15-S-9, and may inhibit rinsing. The only reason that you would add 15-S-3 to 15-S-9 would be as a defoaming agent. But UT cleaning should not cause a stable foam to develop, unlike if using a pumped parts washer. If you compare Triton X100 to 15-S-9, you will see similar HLB and surface tension 30 vs 33, but X100 can create a higher foam, and it is really intended for the metal cleaning industry where you are dealing with a lot of mineral based cutting oils and need the better oil emulsion properties, not some animal-fat based finger prints."

and....

"Hepastat 256 is a Bactericidal, used to disenfect surfaces. However, it has at 0.5 ounces per gallon, 886 ppm active quaternary ammonium compounds, and these salts are also used for antistatic in shampoos and fabric softeners. However, if you are going to add Hepastat why use distilled water, you are just adding salt to the distilled water; Hepastat its intended to be used in tap freshwater. Download the MSDS for Hepastat and look at the ingedients, its a spot cleaning agent complete with non-ionic surfactant and highly alkaline silicates.

If you want to keep a tank full of the DI water-Tergitol solution for weeks, keep covered, and once a week operate the tank (no records of course) at 165F for about 15-30 minutes, and any criters should be killed. PS, the recommendation discussed to store the Tergitol in a non-food refrigerator is based on preventing any accidental ingestion by a child, but at 33-41F, you may need to allow the Tergitol to warm up so can pour it out.

Otherwise, the wet cleaning process will remove any static charge from the record. Air dry or use an antistatic cloth to dry, such as Kinetronics Anti-Static Microfiber Cloth, 10x18-Inch Tiger Cloth (you can buy Amazon), and you should not cause a static charge to develop post cleaning."

So, lots to digest here and I'm hoping to hear back from you. Essentially, again, the simplest most effective formula (that's the goal for me) is what this quest is all about. Does the Hepastat help? Is it necessary? Is the IPA necessary? Can we get to where we want to be with just Tergitol 15-S-9? Would be nice, and by the way, much more environmentally friendly as well according to the information that was given:

"Tergitol 15-S-9 is a more environmentally friendly (and by DOW data should be more effective) alternative to Triton X100 which because of having components that can mimic estrogen, are toxic to fish, and there is 'some' associated human risk. DOW for now is continuing manufacture of Triton X100, but do not be suprised if they discontinue manufacture in the future as global environmental regulations increase. Conservationist (those conserving painting) use surfactants when cleaning/conserving paintings, and are very sensitive to using products that do no harm, or as little as possible. Some are using a non-ionic surfactant that appears very similar to the performance of Triton X100 and Tergitol 15-S-9: SURFONIC® JL-80X."

As a fishead, that part about "toxic to fish" makes my scales rattle!!!:(

Sorry for the length of this but wanted to include all I thought would be necessary to have a detailed conversation.


anovak
58 posts
 
Some good news. My latest US tank purchase seems to be working great. Takes about 25 minutes to heat the water. Cleaned 6 records yesterday and will say it was a marked improvement. I listened to the first track from each album I cleaned and took some notes on each. A lot of noise was removed and the sound was clearer. Like veil being lifted.
The tank is a Rovsun with analogue dials.
 
Fishead: thanks for posting and the PM. You asked for my thoughts: Firstly, I agree, Tergitols have advantages over Triton X's, and I recommend them in the Resource thread. I am partial to 15-S-7 for many reasons (risibility, effectiveness towards oily contaminants, foaming properties, etc).

I, too, am a proponent of minimizing ingredients, including alcohols, but it really depends on what is contaminating the particular record being cleaned. I am not in agreement that an alcohol or anti-stat is always unnecessary. The person you quote appears not to have experience using quats and is missing the point of the Hepastat recommendation (which I have repeatedly said is merely a suggestion of a quat source that is easy for the average user to obtain). Similarly, Triton X-100 has been recommended as a good non-ionic as it is widely available (one can buy on Amazon, for example) though it might not be the ultimate in terms of environmental impact or future availability. It works wonderfully in most instances and is far better than Dawn or other charged detergents people often use. We've discussed in this thread that there are thousands of different non-ionic detergents, each formulated for a specific application, yet realize we are only cleaning records here, not trying to isolate a specific membrane protein or disperse a particular drug so we have a lot of flexibility. I attempted to discuss some of the decisions that go into selecting a detergent, the properties of specific detergents, and possible substitutes in the Resource thread. In fact, when we formulate solutions for certain commercial entities, we use pure ingredients: a non-ionic detergent (hint it is neither Triton nor Tergitol), a quat surfactant (hint, they are not present in Hepastat), and purified water (hint, it is not distilled).

Point is there are many ways to go but the initial concept is the same: use a non-ionic detergent in purified water. If you have specific situations, there are additives that can help (quats for static issues, alcohols for solubilizing certain organics, flocculants for sequestering in tanks, chelators for minerals, etc.). There is no ONE solution for every record as they vary in types and levels of contamination. Records also vary in condition (new, old, previously treated, stored improperly, etc) and resin formulation. The only way to make a general cleaner is to include many additives. Just check out the vast ingredient list of Tide or similar consumer product: they are making a solution for a wide variety of materials, contaminants, machines, water qualities, temperatures, and storage conditions. The ultimate solution for grass stains on a white shirt is different than the one for oil on a pair of jeans, or ink on a wool sweater, so they need to cover many bases. You can apply a similar concept to records: cleaning dust is different than cleaning fingerprints, cigarette tar, fire ash, or fungal contamination. Furthermore, hand-washing is different than vacuum or ultrasonic cleaning. Hence, we need to understand what and how we are cleaning and be open to solutions that are best suited. This is why I attempt to provide useful ranges of ingredients and possible additives instead of one specific formulation. It isn't so simple and we all need to experiment to find what works best in our particular system. I think that is what this thread is all about: folks discussing what they are using, how they are using it, and what the results are.
 
Last edited:
Phantomrebel, thanks for taking the time to respond and the clarification. I think what you are saying makes a lot of sense. No doubt there are many contaminants to be found in the grooves of our records and the more of these we can remove, the better the sound should be.

Just yesterday I removed a record from the US tank after cleaning. My regimen includes a visual inspection during my final rinsing step and I found a very small nub of stuff that remained on the record. At first, I thought it was debris trapped in the vinyl as I so often see but it had a different feel to it. I finished vacuum drying the record and out came the lighter fluid. I rarely use this method and go very sparingly on the fluid, but a small amount on the end of a q-tip and the stuff dissolved quickly. Did another rinse and dry and what would surely have caused a skip in playback was trouble no more. This record had spent 15 minutes in the US, making 5 complete turns, the solution being the combination of Triton, Hepastat and IPA in distilled water and this bit of crud had survived it all! So the "shotgun" approach in terms of including a wide variety of ingredients to target what we most often find in the way of contaminants really does seem reasonable.

Thanks again for your insights.

PS - Is the lighter fluid (specifically Ronsonol) a no-no? Hope not, sometimes it's the only stuff that works.....

IMG_3981.JPG
 
Last edited:
Good point Fishead. Sometimes unusual measures are necessary to rescue a record. Whether it is, as in your case, a locally applied solution of Naptha* followed by a wash, or physically picking away a glob with a toothpick, there are somethings (like paint splatter, for example) that US treatment with detergents just can't remove. I'm always amazed at how much debris actually is removed however, so for the majority of records I really like US treatment. The solution can range from just plain dH2O to something very complicated. My method is very similar to yours, a US treatment with a detergent/quat solution followed by visual inspection and RCM rinses. Still, I have a large number of records that have burnt-in ash and sleeve plastic from a fire for which no treatment has been completely successful, and I've tried everything I can think of (including very strong solvents, high temperatures, and various glue masks). We can only save what we can. Perhaps we should put a list of unusual or extreme cleaning measures folks have successfully used in the Resource thread at some point.

*Naptha (or light petroleum distillates) and PVC are compatible so I don't think there is much harm in this.
 
Last edited:
Thanks amigo! I will breathe a little easier when applying the smelly stuff in the future. It only comes out of the cabinet when there is an exceptional circumstance which doesn't happen very often. 99% of the time, the US works extremely, and I mean extremely well, producing records that have, to my ears, never sounded as good.

I've a friend here in New Mexico with whom I regularly get together for listening sessions who has an impressive collection of LPs. He came over about a month ago and I showed him my new cleaning regimen, telling him he should bring over a few records that he knows very well and that don't sound so good. After showing him the tank, vinylstack, and explaining your solution we cleaned those records and he took them home to play.

I got a call the very next day.....he wanted links to everything, the tank, the vinylstack, the ingredients for the solution etc. Within a week he was up and cleaning and hasn't stopped since! I think he said he's already cleaned about 600 records to which I responded, "hey man, take some time to listen!" He laughed and said he had, and that the results were quite mind-blowing for him.

The moral of the story here is, and why I share it, that if you start cleaning via US system, and IF you have the right formula you will be astounded at the positive results! So, if you've been on the fence about it, tarry no more and take the plunge. My only regret is that I waited so long but I had all these questions.....which, by the way you are largely responsible for answering and I am very grateful.
 
Geespot, if you are referring to the mechanism that turns the records, it is a VinylStack 3 from the company of the same name. It comes with a power supply that has a selector for different voltages which in turn makes the unit turn faster or slower. I have mine set at 6 volts, which gives 1 complete turn every 3 minutes, so 5 turns in 15 minutes which is what I have made my standard time in the bath. Hope that's what you were asking.
 
I highly recommend the vinyl stack. Very well made.
Mine can clean 3 at a time although I'm not sure the middle and insides of the outer discs are getting as clean.
For new vinyl I'm cleaning 3 at a time as I think just a hot bath and a light scrub is all that's necessary. Older records I do 1 or 2 at a time depending on the level of dirt.
The results have been very positive.
I decided to purchase a filter and small pump and run this for 20 minutes.
 
Ollie, can you provide links to the pump and filter and anything else you need to set this up? Thanks.
 
Some good news. My latest US tank purchase seems to be working great. Takes about 25 minutes to heat the water. Cleaned 6 records yesterday and will say it was a marked improvement. I listened to the first track from each album I cleaned and took some notes on each. A lot of noise was removed and the sound was clearer. Like veil being lifted.
The tank is a Rovsun with analogue dials.
I usually preheat my water on the stove. Then I can just get down to cleaning right away.
 
On the filtering thing, I tend to overthink stuff sometimes but I'm wondering if running the pump/filter during the ultrasonic cleaning process might interfere with the cavitation? Anybody know? Maybe just run it in between stacks?
 
On the filtering thing, I tend to overthink stuff sometimes but I'm wondering if running the pump/filter during the ultrasonic cleaning process might interfere with the cavitation? Anybody know? Maybe just run it in between stacks?
I thought the same and just do it between cleaning
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom