• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
It was noted recently if you get the cost low enough per tank just dump it and start over
I'd have to agree.
 
On the filtering thing, I tend to overthink stuff sometimes but I'm wondering if running the pump/filter during the ultrasonic cleaning process might interfere with the cavitation? Anybody know? Maybe just run it in between stacks?
This was discussed here awhile back (post #1923) in response to this web page: http://www.zenith-ultrasonics.com/fluid_circulation.htm that suggests that circulation is detrimental to cavitation.
 
This was discussed here awhile back (post #1923) in response to this web page: http://www.zenith-ultrasonics.com/fluid_circulation.htm that suggests that circulation is detrimental to cavitation.

Aha, thanks PR, I thought my brain was resonating with something along those lines I had read here a time ago. I still think it is a reasonable approach but wonder how long the original combination of ingredients will be cogent enough to still do the job properly? It's not the cost, as most realize a tank will be a few dollars or less, but just the hassle of dumping the thing after 15-20 records when it starts to cloud up a bit. Any thoughts about that?
 
but just the hassle of dumping the thing after 15-20 records when it starts to cloud up a bit. Any thoughts about that?


All the time with filtering, degassing, and whatever else goes along with it is pretty much throwing a twenty dollar bill out to save one dime.

When I know I'm going to do a weekend regiment of cleaning, 400-600 records or more, I premake a fairly large 10% mix so I can batch make as my tank becomes full of junk.

With my 5 gallon bucket to catch the used fluid, and rinse water, it takes a matter of a couple minutes to drain, rinse, then pour the concentrate and distilled water into the tank to start the new batch degassing.

As far as I know, PR said that filtering also takes out a lot of the good stuff from the fluid. It seems very logical to me that would be the case, so I'm in the camp of buy large, build a lot of working concentrate, dump the scrappage when needed and just keep on keeping on. I don't want to spend half of my time cleaning cleaning fluid, I'd much rather spend my time cleaning records.

That and a whole lot less parts to buy.
 
So far I've cleaned 26 records. I filter after every 6 or so depending on how dirty the water looks. I can only run my US tank for 30 minutes at a time according to the manual. So that’s 2 sets of records cleaned before it needs a break. I run the filter for 20 minutes and it’s spotless. I’ve not noticed any difference in the ability of the solution to clean.
 
Hey Ollie, thanks for the PM and also your continued experience as you go forth. I think that's how we will put the pieces together and learn. Some of this stuff has, admittedly, gone right on over my head but as long as there are kind folks around on this forum, I believe a good solution will come about. And, it may not be the same for everyone but will likely share some basic ingredients. I know my records have NEVER sounded this good and I'm just floatin' along in audiokarma listening to some really good music as I type this!

As for the US tank you have, sounds a lot like the one I purchased. I know mine came with the same warnings about not running it over a certain time, mine said 1 hour but I have a friend who ordered the same stuff I did and he's run his for over several hours without untowards consequence so there's that. I think you have it down.....6 records, or two vinyl 3 stacks, is about my limit. I have also begun to institute a policy of getting ready for bed, and then going and cleaning 6 records and this seems very calming and relaxing stuff by which to get a great night's sleep!!! Doing it then leaves me free the next day when listening time rolls around to just enjoy the music......where have I heard that before :banana:Seriously!

The part about "not noticing any" difference.....I assume you are talking about listening tests?
 
My experience covers early days of sink wash, the SpinClean device, and an RCM with various fluids and of course distilled water rinses.

I played my first record that was cleaned on an ultra sonic this past weekend. It’s sounds quieter than most of my records. This is a used 1977 release. I am impressed with ultra sonic.
 
Bobins, things will only get better as you go from here....I did the RCM (diy but my vpi buddies routinely asked to clean their best records here) thing for almost 8 years and can only say, I'm so happy to have found US cleaning! Glad you are discovering the benefits as well....
 
C7-A21-B14-FAD9-4505-ABFC-600-A537-E7985.jpg

Pic of my filter set up. Still requires some tidying up but works well.
Those with the vinyl stack check the rotation times per voltage. I was using 6v that was actually taking 5:30 per rotation.
 
Paging @phantomrebel

My concern with filtering is some ingredient concentrations can change with filtering, resulting in unknown concentrations for subsequent operations. For example, when micelles have sequestered certain contaminates, does filtering break up the micelles, releasing the micellar components and filtering out only the contaminants? Similarly, what about ionic components and the contaminants bonded that way?

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
All I can tell you is that I've cleaned upwards of 40 records now and they are still coming out clean and sounding better than before.
From a scientific aspect this would be very interesting. Hopefully I don’t have to go back and clean them again if it turns out filtering odd a bad idea.
 
All the time with filtering, degassing, and whatever else goes along with it is pretty much throwing a twenty dollar bill out to save one dime.

When I know I'm going to do a weekend regiment of cleaning, 400-600 records or more, I premake a fairly large 10% mix so I can batch make as my tank becomes full of junk.

With my 5 gallon bucket to catch the used fluid, and rinse water, it takes a matter of a couple minutes to drain, rinse, then pour the concentrate and distilled water into the tank to start the new batch degassing.

As far as I know, PR said that filtering also takes out a lot of the good stuff from the fluid. It seems very logical to me that would be the case, so I'm in the camp of buy large, build a lot of working concentrate, dump the scrappage when needed and just keep on keeping on. I don't want to spend half of my time cleaning cleaning fluid, I'd much rather spend my time cleaning records.

That and a whole lot less parts to buy.

I've been using the US/ Vinyl Stack system for about 2 years now with the Triton/ IPA/ DW solution. After about 6 or 8 sets of three records, when the water starts to get dingy, I'll take a reusable #4 coffee filter screen and run the solution through it into a 5 gallon bucket. The filter has a very fine mesh screen that will filter out all of the debris from the records. It polishes the solution really good, almost like a silk screen does for polishing frying oil, like they do in restaurants. I'll rinse out the tank real good and pour the solution back in. I can usually do that several times per tank, and just add in a little more IPA or Triton as needed.
 
What is your criteria for "...as needed?"

Rich P

Good question! Normally for the IPA, which I think is 5% of the solution, Usually has a pretty strong odor to it when mixing a new batch and for several uses of the tank, but over time, the odor diminishes as the alcohol evaporates from the solution, and as more distilled water is added in as the the level gets low over time. This will dilute the solution anyway and I'll add in a few more drops of Triton after a couple of top-offs.
 
Where do you guys purchase your Tergitol? I can't seem to find it for a reasonable price online. The most reasonable was the Talas place mentioned a couple pages back, but they want close to $17 just for shipping.
 
Where do you guys purchase your Tergitol? I can't seem to find it for a reasonable price online. The most reasonable was the Talas place mentioned a couple pages back, but they want close to $17 just for shipping.

Excellent question that I would also appreciate some input on. I found the same thing as you, Davron94.
 
Paging @phantomrebel

My concern with filtering is some ingredient concentrations can change with filtering, resulting in unknown concentrations for subsequent operations. For example, when micelles have sequestered certain contaminates, does filtering break up the micelles, releasing the micellar components and filtering out only the contaminants? Similarly, what about ionic components and the contaminants bonded that way?

Enjoy,
Rich P


All the debris is surrounded by detergent molecules. Hence, removal of debris results in removal of detergent. Filtering doesn't break up micelles, it entraps them (a technique actually used by waste water treatment facilities). How much is removed depends on the filter type (pore size) and it appears folks here are using a huge variety. The concern is depletion of detergent below the CMC where it isn't as effective. One could add more detergent to compensate, but I think people are missing the point: particulate filters (like coffee filters) are only removing visible contaminants. The filtrate is still dirty and it is meant to be discarded even though some detergent remains. I ask my common sense: Would you filter your used dish water, re-apply it to another batch of dishes, and expect the second batch to come out spot-free? Cleanliness is even more critical in record cleaning so I am a proponent of using new fluid for every batch of records. Therefore, I am not the best person to advise on filter types and devices.
 
Last edited:
This is where it gets tricky. When do we change the fluid?
After every 3 records I clean on the vinyl stack? Every 12?
So far I've cleaned 61 records without changing the fluid, just filtered. I've added another 5ml of concentrate and another 150ml of alcohol.
The records are still coming out pristine and sound excellent.
I think I will change it out completely today. Maybe it's pushing my luck and it's not very expensive to do.
What ever your method the proof is in the pudding. US cleaning is the way to go.
 
Thanks, Rich. I'm a turtle about this, don't tend to make moves very quickly and all this information is making it more plausible to consider, reconsider, then think about it some more before making any decisive changes. I'm getting about 20-30 records cleaned in every tank before I change the solution.....I can see some detritus on the bottom, but the fluid still seems fairly clean to the naked eye. When I start seeing a lot of stuff on the records as they come out of the tank, that's when I decide to renew the fluid. Has worked so far given I rinse, rinse again and then vacuum. Anything that was on the record that was visible when it left the tank is gone as far as I can tell.....
 
Water is a rather unique solvent, exhibiting polar as well as non-polar characteristics. That and the cavitation in a US process will give significant results all by itself. Hence, the light concentrations of other elements are icing on the cake. However, icing is good on cake, and the light concentrations of solution elements are even better.

Remember why you are adding each other element (see the associated resource thread). Knowing that you are losing unknown amounts of your additional elements when you process, as well as when you filter, adding more of whatever to an unknown solution does not restore the solution to known concentrations. Concentrations are carefully chosen to maximize positive effects, and to limit any potential negative effects.

Knowledge is power. Our goal here is to develop the best processes, for the best results we can get, for the costs involved. For many of us, Good enough is not good enough. We want to know how to get the best we can, and how we got there and why. We won't all come to the same choices, but it is always best to be as informed as possible while we decide.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom