• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
For some ultrasonic formulas I've seen, it's more a matter of having something to reduce surface tension, than to use a detergent. And I've seen one where a small amount of IPA is used to break down greasy fingerprints.

Interesting how this all works!

This is why detergents are referred to as surfactants. This is how they work, significantly lowering surface tension of aqueous solutions. And they work best at solubilizing oily contaminants when they form aggregates like micelles. There is a lot of cool chemistry involved, including how they produce bubbles leading to foaming (as well as a lot of equations to try to explain the physics of how they work). IPA's main action on the oily prints is as a solvent, but the detergent is what sequesters the oils and keeps them from adhering back to the vinyl surface (they are happier to be in the detergent micelle). The micelles are polar on the outside so are easily washed away (with incorporated oils) in the water. Sometimes the oil contamination is severe, they can be combined with proteins or sugars, are tightly bound, and they need to be broken down in order to get them completely solubilized. This is why you can sometimes still see fingerprints after washing records. Dirty fingerprints really present a problem as they attract further contamination (both things that stick to the oils and things that feed on the organic contaminants). The older they are, the worse they get. Enzymatic treatment breaks these down to smaller components that can be more easily solubilized by the detergent or solvent. Much can be avoided simply by washing hands before handling records and sleeves but people are generally lazy in this regard, so we need to have tools to deal with it.
 
Last edited:
This is why detergents are referred to as surfactants. This is how they work, significantly lowering surface tension of aqueous solutions. And they work best at solubilizing oily contaminants when they form aggregates like micelles. There is a lot of cool chemistry involved, including how they produce bubbles leading to foaming (as well as a lot of equations to try to explain the physics of how they work). IPA's main action on the oily prints is as a solvent, but the detergent is what sequesters the oils and keeps them from adhering back to the vinyl surface (they are happier to be in the detergent micelle). The micelles are polar on the outside so are easily washed away (with incorporated oils) in the water.
It all makes sense, and yes I've read through most of the thread. :D It makes a lot more sense than some of the commercial cleaners that use their own hyperbole to sell it at an outrageous price. I had tried RRL fluid; they claimed it still pulled dirt out of the grooves despite it beading up on the surface, claiming surfactants were "impure" (if I recall), yet it didn't clean any better than anything else I had tried. And I've read so many home brew recipes over the past decade or so that amounted to "a squirt of this, a squirt of that, and duuude, it works for me"...you can guess why I'd gotten frustrated over the years.

I may rig up some kind of rinsing vat when I use an ultrasonic. I haven't decided which way I'm going to go about it, but I'll report back here in a couple of months once I move on it. I couldn't pass up a deal on a preamp this month, so I had to hold off...
 
Hey Vince, do you recommend leaving the triton mix on the record for a certain period of time? If so, how long? After I use the paint pad, I typically rinse the record with distilled water before sucking up the record dry. Should I wait for the mixture to dissolve the funk a bit before the distilled rinse?
You don't have to wait, you just need to scrub long enough to get everything hydrated, dislodged, and mixed well. The contaminants will partition into the lowest energy interface instantly. The biggest time factor is how long it takes to get the contaminant fully wet & dispersed and this depends on it's size and composition, something that varies with every record.
 
Last edited:
I'm not that thrilled with all the extra ingredients, but it should work. I did find pure behentrimonium chloride on Amazon ($6.90 for 4.4 oz of pellets - enough for years of batches). Keep in mind you need hot water to dissolve this stuff.In this case, a 10% stock is 10gms in 100ml of water. This can be kept at room temp without any microbial growth.
Just ordered some pellets - thanks for the tip!
 
Vince,

In reference to your enzyme cleaning formula, I'm having trouble locating a smaller amount <500 ml of TBE. Are there other types of buffers that can be used?

Thanks
 
Captain, the buffer is optional. It's purpose is to keep a neutral environment and to help stop the enzymatic reaction during the wash. The EDTA in the buffer binds Calcium, Iron, and Magnesium ions that are required for activity and often the main mineral components of tap water. I have used the protocol without buffer and it works just fine. If you want to use a buffer, HEPES/EDTA, Tris-acetate-EDTA (TAE) and MOPS-EDTA are all good substitutes, but stay away from any phosphate based buffers. If you were to buy one component, I would skip the buffer, buy some EDTA and include it with the Triton wash solution at a concentration anywhere from 1 to 10 mM (1 gm EDTA per Liter of wash solution is about 3.4 mM, which is a good starting point) . This will help with mineral deposit removal and also disrupt ionic interactions among bound contaminants. Though very useful, I did not include it in the Triton mixes described above as people wanted the simplest mix with the fewest ingredients. Including it makes your wash solution that much better. A "Tweak" if you will, much like adding a Quat. Hence, my "Ultimate Wash Solution" is:
Triton (0.5%), EDTA (5 mM), and Behentriammonium Chloride (0.05%) and, occasionally, 5% IPA.
 
Last edited:
This is why detergents are referred to as surfactants. This is how they work, significantly lowering surface tension of aqueous solutions. And they work best at solubilizing oily contaminants when they form aggregates like micelles. There is a lot of cool chemistry involved, including how they produce bubbles leading to foaming (as well as a lot of equations to try to explain the physics of how they work). IPA's main action on the oily prints is as a solvent, but the detergent is what sequesters the oils and keeps them from adhering back to the vinyl surface (they are happier to be in the detergent micelle). The micelles are polar on the outside so are easily washed away (with incorporated oils) in the water. Sometimes the oil contamination is severe, they can be combined with proteins or sugars, are tightly bound, and they need to be broken down in order to get them completely solubilized. This is why you can sometimes still see fingerprints after washing records. Dirty fingerprints really present a problem as they attract further contamination (both things that stick to the oils and things that feed on the organic contaminants). The older they are, the worse they get. Enzymatic treatment breaks these down to smaller components that can be more easily solubilized by the detergent or solvent. Much can be avoided simply by washing hands before handling records and sleeves but people are generally lazy in this regard, so we need to have tools to deal with it

Vince, thank you for this master class you are teaching! This is the first time I've heard it put this way, and it makes sense! My records have never sounded better....
 
Captain, the buffer is optional. It's purpose is to keep a neutral environment and to help stop the enzymatic reaction during the wash. The EDTA in the buffer binds Calcium, Iron, and Magnesium ions that are required for activity and often the main mineral components of tap water. I have used the protocol without buffer and it works just fine. If you want to use a buffer, HEPES/EDTA, Tris-acetate-EDTA (TAE) and MOPS-EDTA are all good substitutes, but stay away from any phosphate based buffers. If you were to buy one component, I would skip the buffer, buy some EDTA and include it with the Triton wash solution at a concentration anywhere from 1 to 10 mM (1 gm EDTA per Liter of wash solution is about 3.4 mM, which is a good starting point) . This will help with mineral deposit removal and also disrupt ionic interactions among bound contaminants. Though very useful, I did not include it in the Triton mixes described above as people wanted the simplest mix with the fewest ingredients. Including it makes your wash solution that much better. A "Tweak" if you will, much like adding a Quat. Hence, my "Ultimate Wash Solution" is:
Triton (0.5%), EDTA (5 mM), and Behentriammonium Chloride (0.05%) and, occasionally, 5% IPA.
Thanks again for the great insight. I would assume replacing Triton with a Tergitol would also be acceptable, although not your ultimate!
 
Thanks again for the great insight. I would assume replacing Triton with a Tergitol would also be acceptable, although not your ultimate!

Absolutely, they are interchangeable in our use. In fact, a mix of Tergitols might just be "super-ultimate", but people have a hard time finding them.
 
Absolutely, they are interchangeable in our use. In fact, a mix of Tergitols might just be "super-ultimate", but people have a hard time finding them.
I notice the Behentriammonium Chloride comes as a chunky powder, what's the best way to mix and measure for making a half gallon/ 2L using your formula. Sorry, not familiar with handling these materials.
 
I notice the Behentriammonium Chloride comes as a chunky powder, what's the best way to mix and measure for making a half gallon/ 2L using your formula. Sorry, not familiar with handling these materials.

I wish it were simple, but you really need to dissolve the Behen in HOT water. I make a 5% solution (five grams per 100ml of distilled water). Once cooled, this gets added in the ratio of 1:100 for the final detergent mix (e.g. 10 ml of 5% Behen into 1 Liter of 0.5% Triton mix). The final concentrations won't be exact, but close enough using this method (I'm trying to keep the recipe simple). The 5% Behen stock you can keep around for a long time and use whenever you need to make a fresh batch of Ultimate wash solution. As you can tell, the package sizes typically sold will last a long time, so keep the package of chunks in a ziplock.
 
Last edited:
[ iQUOTE="derekva, post: 9208360, member: 17427"]Please say there is a build thread somewhere for this.

-D[/QUOTE]
This is a very clever way to clean your records. Did you make the arm to the pad ?.
Is the other device a liquid dispenser ?.
Thanks, Jim
 
[ iQUOTE="derekva, post: 9208360, member: 17427"]Please say there is a build thread somewhere for this.

-D
This is a very clever way to clean your records. Did you make the arm to the pad ?.
Is the other device a liquid dispenser ?.
Thanks, Jim[/QUOTE]

The other opposite the paint pad arm is the vacuum tube.
 
It seems a lot of people are starting to incorporate quats and other goodies in their detergent mixes. Now it is going to get interesting! Don't be afraid to try different ingredients, ratios, and procedures. There is science, then there is art, and it would be great to see what people come up with that works best for them. Someone using an ultrasonic device may come up with a different mix than someone using an RCM for example. Hopefully everyone will share their findings.
 
Last edited:
Vince, shouldn't that be 5 grams per 95ml water?
Pretty close. In practice, you dissolve 5 gms in a partial amount of water, then bring the final volume to 100 ml with additional water. This goes for all the solutions I have mentioned (always add ingredients then dilute up to the final volume). The total amount of water to get to the 100ml final depends on the density, purity, and hydroscopy of the compound you're dissolving. I've never measured the exact amount required for Behentrimonium Chloride. Thanks for the clarification though, my statement should have been: (five grams per 100ml in distilled water). There is some error: we are assuming the solid form of this quat is 100% but we know it contains some ethanol according to the packaging.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps more succintly; 5 grams solute per 95 grams solvent (100% solute basis). Then volumetric considerations go away. Density can be such a bitch sometimes.
 
Last edited:
Let's not make it complicated. We're cleaning records here, not formulating pharmaceuticals. Every record varies in the amount of grime it holds and there is a huge range of effective detergent concentrations that will work. We are also using very small amounts, typically diluting these stocks 100-fold or more in working solutions and everybody is using different purity reagents. Recipes need to be easy if we are to convince people to change their routines. Whether you add 5 gms to 105 mls or to 90 mls won't make a difference in the record cleaning. This is why I have tried to give ranges of concentrations for ingredients. Just be consistent and do the same thing that works each time and your good. Kind of like cooking where 1 cup can be heaping and another a little short of rim, the cake still taste great! This is the Art. The Science is in the reagents we choose to use based on their properties, their synergy with each other, and their interactions with the vinyl record.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom