• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, the solubility of X-100 (and other similar nonionic surfactants) generally decreases with increased temperature. I find that room temperature works best. I also find that gentle stirring works best. Shaking tends to create foam.

As hi*ball has stated, solubility appears to be enhanced by the addition of the isopropanol.
 
So here is my regime FWIW. I make a stock water alcohol mix in a gallon jug. I remove 8 oz's of water from the gallon and then add 8 oz's of 99% or whatever you can get alcohol. Boom stock water mix. I then make my concentrate 5ml of Triton then slowly add 50ml of the stock water/alcohol mix stirring all the time . The water/alcohol mix helps breakdown the Triton and when it's all mixed you have your concentrate.

I use a ketchup type plastic bottle which hold about 8 to 9 oz's I add the water/Alcohol mix to almost full then add about 3/4 teaspoon of the concentrate wa-la! I did have to buy some beakers which makes the measuring a little easier they were only like 8.00 and I feel like a chemist!
:beerchug:
 
Great advice posted above here Mike, you definitely don't want to use hot water with Triton. Time is your friend, as is alcohol. I've previously mentioned a "fast" method first dissolving in 50% IPA, then diluting up. If you want a super quick, lazy man's way, add a small drop of Triton to a couple ml of 70% IPA. It will dissolve immediately. Then dilute it up with water to about 25ml and apply it with a pad or whatever your regimen is. Not too scientific, but matches what people do with Dawn and it works in a time pinch. You can get a little more accurate using drops (if you use the same dropper device) and if you only need a small amount of solution: add one drop 100% Triton to a mix of 6 drops 99% IPA and 3 drops water to get instant dissolving resulting in a 10%Triton stock. Then dilute further (typically 20- to 50-fold) with distilled water to get the working concentration you want. I understand trying to get something quick and easy. For example, I've used this method on thrift shop finds just so I can get a quick look at the grooves and give an initial listen to determine whether they are worth saving.
 
Last edited:
I think my earlier question got lost in my winded post above. Zerostat guns, any good? Worth buying or waste of cash?
They are a waste. With a good cleaning system, and properly humidified space, you will never need one. People also use them improperly and typically IMPART an unbalanced charge onto the surface. They also use them while the record is on their table which can waste their cartridges as the guns produce a lot of voltage (Enough to light fires!). Read this article by John Cameron, one of the pioneers of this technology: http://amasci.com/emotor/zerostat.html and you'll forget about Zerostats. A Swiffer towel sprayed with Statisguard can be used much more effectively to wipe down equipment. Let the detergents to do the job on records.
 
They are a waste. With a good cleaning system, and properly humidified space, you will never need one. People also use them improperly and typically IMPART an unbalanced charge onto the surface. They also use them while the record is on their table which can waste their cartridges as the guns produce a lot of voltage (Enough to light fires!). Read this article by John Cameron, one of the pioneers of this technology: http://amasci.com/emotor/zerostat.html and you'll forget about Zerostats. A Swiffer towel sprayed with Statisguard can be used much more effectively to wipe down equipment. Let the detergents to do the job on records.
They are expensive, but I wouldn't call them a waste as they are handy to have when you need one and they do work when used properly. I agree they shouldn't be used while the record is on the platter as there seems to be little effect. Rather, they work best while the record is held in your hand before placing it on the platter, and to discharge and static remnants that might've built up during play as the record is being removed slowly from the platter.

The detergents do help quite a lot but my observation has been that the effect of static remediation is temporary, lasting only a few plays before static buildup returns. Maybe then is a good time to re-wash the record, but if the record is already stuck to the mat what do you do then?

They're also useful while re-sleeving and re-jacketing the record to restore it to a neutral charge condition for storage.
 
The RCM setup awaiting Triton X-100:

You can see a few floaties in the air - in the middle of some minor bathroom rennos (been keeping everything covered except this little sound break I needed ;-)
 
Many thanks Vince,

With your help and directions, I have cleaned a lot of my collection. I just wanted to point out that I work for the chemistry department, and so I just used a stir plate to get the Triton (in a beaker) to go into solution. Easy Peasey! Only took a few minutes in my office while I was doing other work. For the DI rinses I bought two 13" shallow pie-pans from some bakery supply company ($45) and just stick 'em in the kitchen sink. In less than 15 minutes I'll get 8 record cleaned.

What surprises me is even old (and I mean 1972) records play quietly. If there is any down side to any of this, the only thing I can think of is it lacks any immediacy. I mean you can't just go to the record cabinet and pull anything out and play it. And so it takes a little fore thought...what will I want to hear tomorrow night. Eventually I'll get them all cleaned, and then everything in the record cabinet will be ready to play at will.

Another thing I've noticed is even after cleaning an old record, some surface noise remained. But continued cleaning, helped greatly.

Gary
 
Just did a renewed search and actually found a source here in Canada for 500 ML size. Similar price to that above only Canadian Dollars ($11 CDN). Shipping is what gets us every time out west here especially with international rates and the CAN/US exchange rate these days. For the Canucks in the GTA out there, the company I ordered from is in Markham, Ontario so you can save $25 by going there directly I assume...

Here it is:
https://store.biobasic.com/product/tb0198-size-500ml/

Anyway, I am golden now with very much thanks and a shout out to a very gracious member of the AK group here - now just biding my time until it arrives with a great deal of anticipation ;-)
Cheers all and thank you for all the help.
TMF

PS: My "work in progress" project TT also thanks everyone as it is sounding better and better each day. Soon with clean/static free clean albums will be (hopefully) even more amazing:
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....rens-td-165-turntable-for-restoration.699495/
 
Last edited:
For those of you using paint pads how are you actual using them to clean records? Do you add something to the back of them to get a better hold of them while cleaning? The ones I thought have flat shinny plastic on the back, not sure how I would hold them/use them while cleaning.
 
For those of you using paint pads how are you actual using them to clean records? Do you add something to the back of them to get a better hold of them while cleaning? The ones I thought have flat shinny plastic on the back, not sure how I would hold them/use them while cleaning.
There is a "handle" that is made of plastic that is sold where the paint pads are sold.

They look like this:
PaintPad_zpshvdbdrmd.jpg
 
For those of you using paint pads how are you actual using them to clean records? Do you add something to the back of them to get a better hold of them while cleaning? The ones I thought have flat shinny plastic on the back, not sure how I would hold them/use them while cleaning.
If you go up to my RCM YouTube video post above you will see my pads which have handles built in. Got them from Home Depot I believe
 
If you go up to my RCM YouTube video post above you will see my pads which have handles built in. Got them from Home Depot I believe

I picked up the same RCM and have been amazed at how simple and easy it is to clean my records now. You can easily spin at whatever speed or direction you desire. He was great to work with and shipped it out quick all the way to Florida. Love it!
 
I'd like to keep this thread focused on cleaning fluids rather than methods. Maybe we need to start another thread?

Anyways, I was asked elsewhere about why a neutral pH was preferred in record cleaning solutions when household cleaners use acidic or basic conditions to clean more effectively. So I decided to provide a simplified chemical explanation of what is going on in the vinyl record: The most important thing to remember is that your record is made of PVC polymer. This polymer would be rigid and brittle if it were not for the plasticizers incorporated within the PVC matrix. These plasticizers are not covalently bound, they are trapped within the matrix, providing a lubricant to the PVC fibers so they can move against each other (flex). We have previously discussed choosing methods (like lowering or eliminating alcohol) that won't solvent extract these plasticizers out of the matrix. It may surprise some here that 25-40% of the record mass is plasticizer, not PVC. Most of this is phthalates, compounds that are a concern in the environment. These compound are not very soluble in water however, so they tend to stay in the record. That is, unless they are broken down through hydrolysis. At neutral pH, the phthalate esters are stable but acid or basic conditions lead quickly to hydrolysis. The products that are produced (an acid and an alcohol) are soluble in water and can be extracted. Furthermore, the amount remaining can now carry a charge (that can contribute to static). So we really want to keep a neutral pH in any solution that is in contact with our records. True, PVC is chemically resistant, but it is the other 25-40% of the record that is sensitive.
These plasticizers, incidentally, are also what contaminating microbes use as a carbon source, secreting enzymes to hydrolyze them.
 
Last edited:
Dr Vince
Been looking at your web page for cleaning (now a staple bookmark in my audio browser folder) at:
https://sites.google.com/site/vincesaudiofiles/

On the enzyme cleaning step you recommend the product Nexazyme (Bioprosper Labs). I gather this the stuff to which you refer?
http://www.amazon.com/Multi-enzyme-...ase-Hemicellulase-Galactosidase/dp/B00B9H46NK

As luck would have it I cannot order from Amazon.com as it is prohibited from shipping to Canada. I searched our sister site Amazon.ca (Canadian version of Amazon) and it doesn't have Nexazyme but it does list other digestive enzyme products like:

https://www.amazon.ca/Webber-Natura...=1457722698&sr=8-1&keywords=digestive+enzymes
or
https://www.amazon.ca/Jamieson-Dige...=1457722801&sr=8-3&keywords=digestive+enzymes
or
https://www.amazon.ca/Enzymes-Suppo...=1457722801&sr=8-2&keywords=digestive+enzymes
Would any of the above be any good as an alternative? The other day I was given (from a friend) a load of very old LPs with some in great condition and others in nasty shape which of course are hard to find favourtes mostly out of print that I want to try to resuscitate. Triton X-100 is on its way so now I am looking in the direction of the enzyme portion of your process to help with the embedded nasty's....
Thanks
TMF
 
Dr Vince
Been looking at your web page for cleaning (now a staple bookmark in my audio browser folder) at:
https://sites.google.com/site/vincesaudiofiles/

On the enzyme cleaning step you recommend the product Nexazyme (Bioprosper Labs). I gather this the stuff to which you refer?
http://www.amazon.com/Multi-enzyme-...ase-Hemicellulase-Galactosidase/dp/B00B9H46NK

As luck would have it I cannot order from Amazon.com as it is prohibited from shipping to Canada. I searched our sister site Amazon.ca (Canadian version of Amazon) and it doesn't have Nexazyme but it does list other digestive enzyme products like:

https://www.amazon.ca/Webber-Natura...=1457722698&sr=8-1&keywords=digestive+enzymes
or
https://www.amazon.ca/Jamieson-Dige...=1457722801&sr=8-3&keywords=digestive+enzymes
or
https://www.amazon.ca/Enzymes-Suppo...=1457722801&sr=8-2&keywords=digestive+enzymes
Would any of the above be any good as an alternative? The other day I was given (from a friend) a load of very old LPs with some in great condition and others in nasty shape which of course are hard to find favourtes mostly out of print that I want to try to resuscitate. Triton X-100 is on its way so now I am looking in the direction of the enzyme portion of your process to help with the embedded nasty's....
Thanks
TMF

You need to pay attention to the ingredients. The first you listed has betaine hydrochloride, which is a strong acid and not recommended. The second has a bunch of plant extracts included which are also not good. The third didn't list ingredients. You want as pure an enzyme mix as possible, with minimal fillers. Look for mixtures of Protease (e.g. Papain, Bromelain ), a Lipase, and Amylase (or Cellulase). Nothing else is needed (including salts and acids) though they will list gelatin or similar as the binder or capsule. To minimize this contaminant, make sure you open the capsule and only use the contents (toss those shells, they make sticky messes).
 
Last edited:
Roger that - thank you. Will stop off at a health (chemical soup) store and see what I can drum up using your advice above. The three I had listed were the only ones on Amazon.ca that I could find.
A shame that likely most of the ingredients I need are residing right here in my guts???? Maybe I can throw up and distill or fractionate out the bits I need LOL
I had already assumed the capsule shell was a throw away....
I am thinking that the Nexazyme might be one for my next trip to Seattle. I also make frequent trips to Friday Harbor and Port Angeles during the spring and summer in my boat so perhaps this is a good excuse to take it out of winter hibernation now that the weather is turning pretty nice. Can I pick it up at most US health food stores or is it a pretty rare product?
;-)
 
Last edited:
Great thread Vince...I've been using Triton X-100 in dH20 for several years now but without the IPA and have been generally very pleased with the results. I would now like to add some 99% IPA to my to mix to aid in the cleaning process and also to perhaps help shorten the drying time.

Since I mix one gallon of the final solution at a time, how many ml of 99% IPA should I add to the gallon mix?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom