• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have had great success with, don't laugh, the Crosley wet cleaning system, very similar to the DiscWasher. I use 91% isopropal, distilled water, and a couple of drops of dishwash detergent to break surface tension. I also use a (dry, of course) carbon fiber brush before each spin. My point all along here is, does it really need to be much more laborious and complex than this? A
Actually I think it does. The dish washing detergent idea has been beat to death herein I think. Fact is that it is known to leave a static charge due to the ionic nature of all the crap they put into dishwashing detergents to make it smell nice etc - this thread has been primarily about getting out of ionic and into non-ionic large chain detergents to alleviate the problem - suggest you may want to read the thread from the very beginning...'
 
does it really need to be much more laborious and complex than this?

Literally, no, it doesn't NEED to be more, but I think what you're describing is more of a "wipe" than a deep clean. (And I've used a Discwasher since 1979). Better fluids and better technique yields better results in my experience. I don't find it to be laborious or complex, but if you're happy with your process, more power to you!
 
Literally, no, it doesn't NEED to be more, but I think what you're describing is more of a "wipe" than a deep clean. (And I've used a Discwasher since 1979). Better fluids and better technique yields better results in my experience. I don't find it to be laborious or complex, but if you're happy with your results, more power to you!
A wipe? Funny, I do hear and see "stuff" going into the grooves. And after using a carbon fiber brush, additional particles come up. When you are talking 50-60 year old records, there is always that rule of diminishing returns.
 
A wipe? Funny, I do hear and see "stuff" going into the grooves. And after using a carbon fiber brush, additional particles come up. When you are talking 50-60 year old records, there is always that rule of diminishing returns.

Yup - a wipe. I think of my discwasher like I think of my lint brush for clothes. Good for catching the random surface stuff and useful for what it is, but it's not the same as a deep cleaning. Back when most records were bought new, it wasn't that big a deal. These days? Different story.
 
You mean I can't keep putting them in the dish washer? They fit so nicely. Wondered why I have spent so much on vinyl over the years.
 
Despite what was said about glue I get consistently amazing results with it, very noisy records turn to brand new, and I haven't noticed any deterioration.
Maybe Titebond is not the right glue for it? I use Ryat Standard wood glue mixed with a bit of water, it is less hard/brittle when dry than Titebond. Excellent results, but you have to get the knack of it to do it properly
 
Despite what was said about glue I get consistently amazing results with it, very noisy records turn to brand new, and I haven't noticed any deterioration.
Maybe Titebond is not the right glue for it? I use Ryat Standard wood glue mixed with a bit of water, it is less hard/brittle when dry than Titebond. Excellent results, but you have to get the knack of it to do it properly
The wood glue record method was championed here at AK. You're preaching to the converted. This thread superceeds all that. Read it. Try it.
 
To be fair, this thread is only about changing one component, and the one used in minute amounts, namely the dishwashing liquid. Given we're taliking only one or two drops per litre, it is highly likely most would either never have, or never notice, a static problem afterwards, so realistically the need for change is minute.
 
To be equally fair, I have actually tried the formula that this thread is about, and have noticed a significant difference over dish liquid solutions. I challenge others to do the same before posting their unfounded opinions.
 
What was this difference? Perhaps you'd like to post some needle drops which demonstrate your findings? Remember, the change isn't going to affect cleaning ability one iota, but only static, so if you don't find any to begin with, there's no benefit to the change.

I'm not disputing the chemistry by the way, merely that, at the level of dilution, and we're talking at the ppm level for detergent, most would find little if any difference. It's also worth noting that static is caused my many things, including the action of removing a record from its sleeve and putting it on the platter, so static caused by washing wouldn't even make the top ten causes of it.
 
What was this difference? Perhaps you'd like to post some needle drops which demonstrate your findings? Remember, the change isn't going to affect cleaning ability one iota, but only static, so if you don't find any to begin with, there's no benefit to the change.

I'm not disputing the chemistry by the way, merely that, at the level of dilution, and we're talking at the ppm level for detergent, most would find little if any difference. It's also worth noting that static is caused my many things, including the action of removing a record from its sleeve and putting it on the platter, so static caused by washing wouldn't even make the top ten causes of it.
Sorry, I don't have the capability (nor the desire) to create needledrops. I am just encouraging you (and others) to try what is presented here before blindly dismissing it.
 
Make that 2 of us, mprince.

I've used dawn and a paint pad, and I found it didn't work exceptionally well. Static was still very much an issue.

Now, not so much. Remember, when I transfer, I want ZERO noise from dirt and grime. Pops from scratches and bad pressings are understandable. Switching from Dawn to Triton has made the glue method, which was indeed championed here on AK (thank you, theophile!) a very rare thing for me indeed.

I have a battered Ray Charles album that has defied me. I'm guessing that's the first one I'll glue in 3 months or so.

Using triton is superior to Dawn. There, I said it.
 
Whose dismissing it? No-one's arguing with the chemistry, merely saying that the change only affects one component, which is the detergent, and that the change in turn will affect only the static. In terms of how clean the record is, there won't be a difference. I don't think Vince ever claimed there would be.

It's also fair enough to point out that, at the vanishingly small levels of concentration used, you may not notice a difference at all, especially given that static can be caused by many things.
 
I regard this thread as an advanced diploma on the mechanics and effects of differing record cleaning methods. Fullstop. Not only are correct procedures described, the reason for the ingredients in the correct procedures are discussed, the reasons not to use the flawed methods are discussed. Not just "I use ********* and it's good" or "My records have never sounded better than they have since I started using #######". Reasons for doing it. Reasons for not doing it. Based on the chemistry of PVC.

I have read all of it. Every page. Every post. Not all of them are by Vince. Perhaps if one only wished to read Vince's input, one could search for the particular user in a search. That weeds out everyone else(including me). Vince's posts are the ones I'm happy to use as my reference here on his thread.

Here's is a search for Vince's postings on the turntable forum:

http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....g-&t=post&o=date&c[node]=28&c[user][0]=194533
 
Whose dismissing it? No-one's arguing with the chemistry, merely saying that the change only affects one component, which is the detergent, and that the change in turn will affect only the static. In terms of how clean the record is, there won't be a difference. I don't think Vince ever claimed there would be.

It's also fair enough to point out that, at the vanishingly small levels of concentration used, you may not notice a difference at all, especially given that static can be caused by many things.

Of course you're dismissing it, you say it won't make a difference. Do you have anything constructive to add? If not, then why are you posting here?

Just can't resist inserting your ego?

Jon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom