Many of those reviewers may be those new to vinyl who may be buying their first (entry level) table and don't know any better.
I think you mean you are looking for a semi-automatic. I've never heard of a table that just shuts off without returning the tonearm to its rest. There are few brand new tables out there that are auto or semi-auto, but they are not highly regarded.
I would either upgrade the cart on your present table if you think that will help, or buy another vintage semi-auto table. Your present table is a P-mount which might limit your cart choices. The used Technics direct drive S-arm tables are solid and highly regarded. Many are auto or semi-auto. I recently picked up a SL-D2 semi-auto table on the local CL and I like it a lot. My previous experience with turntables goes back over 40 years, but I've been mostly a straight arm belt drive or idler drive owner. The only other direct drive I have also has a straight arm.
Actually, my vintage Garrard DD75 does this (or supposed to do this). Often it will shut off (stop spinning) at the end of the record. Once in awhile the tone arm will lift off of the record. It doesn't return the arm to rest, but it stops the platter from spinning and it cues the arm off of the record. It is a nice feature for a manual turntable.