infullview
Super Member
I think your observations are true with respect to the Rosedale you have. The crossover is badly designed and there's a lot of overlap between the woofer and mid range. I think this is why you perceive a lot of box resonance. The compliance of the rubber surround on mine is very soft and transients seem very fast. Wharfdale was known for constantly changing materials. The cloth surround does not allow the W60 speaker to be used in a sealed configuration. It was designed to be ported. That said, you have peaked my curiosity and I may have to pick up a pair of W60's. Lucky for me they are inexpensive and very common where I live.Yeah right.
I will try to be brief, I do not consider myself expert or anything, I just expose my humble opinion.
I currently own a pair of original two-way W60 with alnico magnet, and I also have a Rosedale pair (equivalent to a W70E).
First of all, it is worth saying that old alnico drivers have a superior manufacturing level and quality.
With regard to sound, the advantages of the W60 are very obvious:
- The first is the mid-high frequencies, the wna4 has a superior performance to the joint work of the mid-range and the purple tweeter, the sound reproduction is more accurate due to the absence of a cross at this frequency level, in addition wna4 tone is more natural. There are no offset problems nor do you need to mitigate gain differences through resistors or l-pad ... The Rosedale mid-range has a lower gain than the purple tweeter.
One thing I forgot to mention is I will be copying the design of the crossover on my W70Es and replacing the stock ones that came with the Rosedales.
- The second, if I compare the woofers of both speakers, although the Rosedale woofer is 15 inches, I consider that the 12-inch red alnico woofer of the W60 has a remarkable performance, the first thing I rescue in addition to the alnico magnet is that has cloth surround, the Rosedale woofer has rubber surround, this cone is much harder to move. If I compare the bass responses of both boxes, I can say that the W60 woofer is faster, sounds more detailed, the sound is cleaner ... and most importantly, the resonance is nonexistent. On the other hand, the Rosedale bass is slow, sounds muddy, with much less nuance and the resonance level of the box is overwhelming.
That with respect to sound, although the Rosedale is a larger and three-way box, in practice the sand filled box and the simplest crossover give the W60 a clear advantage.
To conclude, the W60 is an extraordinary speaker and far superior to the Rosedale. It is more efficient, has a more precise sound due to the simplest crossover, has a more detailed bass, and the best thing is that you have a box without resonance. And finally, the naturalness of the sound that is achieved with the w60 is amazing (I'm not exaggerating). Read Gang-Twanger's threads, he was absolutely right with what he talked about these boxes.
Edit: forgot to mention that I will be copying the Crossovers that are on the W70Es and replacing the originals on the Rosedales.




