• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

Yeah right.

I will try to be brief, I do not consider myself expert or anything, I just expose my humble opinion.

I currently own a pair of original two-way W60 with alnico magnet, and I also have a Rosedale pair (equivalent to a W70E).

First of all, it is worth saying that old alnico drivers have a superior manufacturing level and quality.

With regard to sound, the advantages of the W60 are very obvious:

- The first is the mid-high frequencies, the wna4 has a superior performance to the joint work of the mid-range and the purple tweeter, the sound reproduction is more accurate due to the absence of a cross at this frequency level, in addition wna4 tone is more natural. There are no offset problems nor do you need to mitigate gain differences through resistors or l-pad ... The Rosedale mid-range has a lower gain than the purple tweeter.

One thing I forgot to mention is I will be copying the design of the crossover on my W70Es and replacing the stock ones that came with the Rosedales.
- The second, if I compare the woofers of both speakers, although the Rosedale woofer is 15 inches, I consider that the 12-inch red alnico woofer of the W60 has a remarkable performance, the first thing I rescue in addition to the alnico magnet is that has cloth surround, the Rosedale woofer has rubber surround, this cone is much harder to move. If I compare the bass responses of both boxes, I can say that the W60 woofer is faster, sounds more detailed, the sound is cleaner ... and most importantly, the resonance is nonexistent. On the other hand, the Rosedale bass is slow, sounds muddy, with much less nuance and the resonance level of the box is overwhelming.

That with respect to sound, although the Rosedale is a larger and three-way box, in practice the sand filled box and the simplest crossover give the W60 a clear advantage.

To conclude, the W60 is an extraordinary speaker and far superior to the Rosedale. It is more efficient, has a more precise sound due to the simplest crossover, has a more detailed bass, and the best thing is that you have a box without resonance. And finally, the naturalness of the sound that is achieved with the w60 is amazing (I'm not exaggerating). Read Gang-Twanger's threads, he was absolutely right with what he talked about these boxes.
I think your observations are true with respect to the Rosedale you have. The crossover is badly designed and there's a lot of overlap between the woofer and mid range. I think this is why you perceive a lot of box resonance. The compliance of the rubber surround on mine is very soft and transients seem very fast. Wharfdale was known for constantly changing materials. The cloth surround does not allow the W60 speaker to be used in a sealed configuration. It was designed to be ported. That said, you have peaked my curiosity and I may have to pick up a pair of W60's. Lucky for me they are inexpensive and very common where I live.

Edit: forgot to mention that I will be copying the Crossovers that are on the W70Es and replacing the originals on the Rosedales.
 
I think your observations are true with respect to the Rosedale you have. The crossover is badly designed and there's a lot of overlap between the woofer and mid range. I think this is why you perceive a lot of box resonance. The compliance of the rubber surround on mine is very soft and transients seem very fast. Wharfdale was known for constantly changing materials. The cloth surround does not allow the W60 speaker to be used in a sealed configuration. It was designed to be ported. That said, you have peaked my curiosity and I may have to pick up a pair of W60's. Lucky for me they are inexpensive and very common where I live.

Edit: forgot to mention that I will be copying the Crossovers that are on the W70Es and replacing the originals on the Rosedales.


You are absolutely right when it comes to rubber surround, it should work better in sealed boxes.

I believe that the key to improving the Rosedale is by changing the crossover.

Regarding the W60, I recommend you buy a pair with a red alnico magnet. You will be impressed with bass without resonance and the naturalness of the sound.

Another thing, I have always changed the capacitors of the croossover, for example in the Rosedale I am using Jantzen Z-Superior and in the W60 I am using Jantzen Alumen. With good level capacitors you can take full advantage of the drivers.
 
The rubber surround suspension on the later models is not immune to hardening. I have see some of these where the surround had become brittle due to age. But in general, the diver quality was changed over the years because of manufacturing cost and design trends. This seems to happen to nearly any mass manufactured product.

As for the WNA4 / PST4 - it's my opinion that this is the weak point of the W60. While it's middle frequency response is good - it rolls off far too low to satisfy my ears. The W60 ends up sounding muddy and rolled off. I nearly sent mine down the road. But I took a chance and found some Super 3 Ceramics from a junked W70. The frames on these have elongated ears at the mounting holes, allowing them to fit the studs on the W60 baffles. There is a small gap around the perimeter if the Super 3 once mounted; but this is of no concern due to the sealed enclosure covering the tweeter assembly.

I used film caps by Dayton and 8 Ohm L-pads to replace the blow out original parts. The later Alnico Super 3 and the ceramic Super 3 were capable of 1k Hz to 20k Hz response. The original 12uF capacitor crosses the driver at just above 1,500 CPS

The performance is superb, and I will never part with these speakers now that they sound so wonderful.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20200103_142228525.jpg
    IMG_20200103_142228525.jpg
    69.4 KB · Views: 28
  • IMG_20200103_143012366.jpg
    IMG_20200103_143012366.jpg
    51.5 KB · Views: 32
  • IMG_20200103_142935636.jpg
    IMG_20200103_142935636.jpg
    71.9 KB · Views: 30
Last edited:
I just came across the British Audio forum and this thread so thought I would post in this thread vs. starting a new one. (I did a little background research and read through the first 40 (!) pages of this thread before this post, so I'm very generally aware of the issues but definitely not knowledgeable yet.)
I'm a new owner of W90Ds with a few pics and a few questions. I acquired these as part of a bundle of amps, equalizers and a preamp. Previous owner "threw these in", so now I have them and need to figure out what to do with them. I already have enough speakers so I'm not at all sure about keeping them but I would like to hear how they sound. The first check shows all drivers are working except the tweeters in one cabinet. A surprise, to me at least is the 32mfd capacitor and the 2 12mfds on the crossover. I will clean the pots and expect I need to put in new capacitors. Also expect I should rotate the woofers since they are 50 years old. Dates on the woofers are mostly 1969 and I think maybe of 1970 is there as well. These came without grill covers so I will need to either construct new or sell them as is, if I decide not to keep them.
The questions: Is there any recommended wire, presumably 18 ga., for extending the woofers after a rotation? Is there a way to successfully get Deoxit into the level control pots without disassembling? I don't see any holes in these which I would normally expect. Only the very narrow gap at the bottom.
(Numbers on the masking tape are the serial numbers for them, so that I could keep the backs straight.)
Thanks for any advice and I welcome any/all comments.
Bruce
DSCF1270.JPG DSCF1269.JPGDSCF1268.JPG DSCF1267.JPG DSCF1266.JPG
 
If the plots aren't scratchy don't use the deoxit. Do replace the caps with decent film caps or russian PIO's. I have an earlier pair myself. Two tweeters and two miids along the top. The woofers are in separate compartments. The pots in mine were covered in a thick layer of corrosion. There was a minor bit of scratchiness in one pot. I just rotated it back and forth about 30 times without deoxit and its good. I didn't know a thing about theses when I got them. I got them very cheap so I said what the heck and hauled them home. Take a good long listen to them once recapped. You may like them. I have mine connected to a 35wpc tube amp and I'm very happy with them. They are on the buge and heavey side though.
 
The surrounds are cloth and allow air to pass theough them on mine. Do yours have the cloth aurrounds?18 ga.wire should do. It's a bummer a tweeter is dead. I would pull it and test it first.
They do pop up on Ebay from time to time. Maybe someone knows if that tweeter was used in other models as well.
 
The rubber surround suspension on the later models is not immune to hardening. I have see some of these where the surround had become brittle due to
I would take issue with this. Butly #10 does not degrade in inert environments, and will remain stable at temperatures as high as 109 degrees C. None of the W series woofers I have (six in total) exhibit any degradation or stiffness on the surrounds.
 
The surrounds are cloth and allow air to pass theough them on mine. Do yours have the cloth aurrounds?18 ga.wire should do. It's a bummer a tweeter is dead. I would pull it and test it first.
They do pop up on Ebay from time to time. Maybe someone knows if that tweeter was used in other models as well.
LaVane, thanks for the feedback.
Yes, mine are cloth and intact but definitely see-through. I do plan to test the tweeters and have hope, at least for the time being. You mentioned that your woofers are in separate compartments, unlike mine. Are yours W90D?
Bruce
 
LaVane, thanks for the feedback.
Yes, mine are cloth and intact but definitely see-through. I do plan to test the tweeters and have hope, at least for the time being. You mentioned that your woofers are in separate compartments, unlike mine. Are yours W90D?
Bruce
I don't know. I've seen three different versions of the W90's so far. I'm thinking yours was the latest?
 
After a few days with the new-to-me W90D speakers, I'm thinking I should work on improving their appearance as well as the insides. I'm looking for anyone who has W90Ds and can take a couple of pics and provide dimensions for the removable cloth grill covers. Mine are the low boy version and have only velcro pads on the front baffles so I don't have a reference for the covers, other than the catalog cuts of the entire speaker that are in post #1221. Specifically looking for closeups of the grill cloth and dimensions of the grill cloth frame, including thickness and the dimensions for the cutouts for the woofer and mid/hi. (Post #1111, in this thread, provides a good lead for a source for the fabric.) A front photo of mine are in post #1344, above.
Any info will be helpful.
Thanks
Bruce
 
I would take issue with this. Butly #10 does not degrade in inert environments, and will remain stable at temperatures as high as 109 degrees C. None of the W series woofers I have (six in total) exhibit any degradation or stiffness on the surrounds.

Just because the 6 woofers you have seen are still good - doesn't mean they ALL are still good. back in the mid 80s I worked in a speaker shop doing recone services. In any repair business, you see all sorts of things that you couldn't ever imagine possible. But sure enough - people will bring in all sorts of insane failure scenarios - seeking help. I have indeed seen Wharefedale woofers with hardened rubber surrounds. Not many - but at least two to three examples.
 
Last edited:
Just because the 6 woofers you have seen are still good - doesn't mean they ALL are still good. back in the mid 80s I worked in a speaker shop doing recone services. In any repair business, you see all sorts of things that you couldn't ever imagine possible. But sure enough - people will bring in all sorts of insane failure scenarios - seeking help. I have indeed seen Wharefedale woofers with hardened rubber surrounds. Not many - but at least two to three examples.
These may have been quality control issues or some attempt by Wharfedale to try other types of less expensive materials. The statistic I quoted was from a military study of Butly rubber compound #10. Point is, if the rubber compound is still good today, it's not likely to change. BTW I also have a pair of Philips 10 inch woofers in the attic that are the same age that are also still good, and 12 NOS Peerless Alnico 5, 8 inch, 16 Ohm speakers that never found a home.
 
After a few days with the new-to-me W90D speakers, I'm thinking I should work on improving their appearance as well as the insides. I'm looking for anyone who has W90Ds and can take a couple of pics and provide dimensions for the removable cloth grill covers. Mine are the low boy version and have only velcro pads on the front baffles so I don't have a reference for the covers, other than the catalog cuts of the entire speaker that are in post #1221. Specifically looking for closeups of the grill cloth and dimensions of the grill cloth frame, including thickness and the dimensions for the cutouts for the woofer and mid/hi. (Post #1111, in this thread, provides a good lead for a source for the fabric.) A front photo of mine are in post #1344, above.
Any info will be helpful.
Thanks
Bruce
I just happened to get a pair of W90D's last week. Unfortunately they have some mismatched parts. I was pointed in this direction to see if proper replacements are possible.

The good news (for you at least) is mine have the grills intact. I can take pics and better measurements tomorrow.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3560.JPG
    IMG_3560.JPG
    116.4 KB · Views: 25
  • IMG_3561.JPG
    IMG_3561.JPG
    99.3 KB · Views: 26
I just happened to get a pair of W90D's last week. Unfortunately they have some mismatched parts. I was pointed in this direction to see if proper replacements are possible.

The good news (for you at least) is mine have the grills intact. I can take pics and better measurements tomorrow.
The jelly fish tweeters come up on flea bay quite regularly. The question is do you want to go with original or use a modern upgrade? These old purple tweeters are pretty easy to replace with new ones which are sonically superior
 
The jelly fish tweeters come up on flea bay quite regularly. The question is do you want to go with original or use a modern upgrade? These old purple tweeters are pretty easy to replace with new ones which are sonically superior

In truth, I'd like to do both. First, I'd like to be able get these guys back to original to see what they sound like.

I expect that is going to be either impossible or too expensive to be reasonable, but it's worth a try.

If I don't like the sound or I can't find the parts, then I will see about newer replacements.

That being said, are these supposed to have the jellyfish tweeters? I had really hoped that the speaker in pic 3560 was correct and I only had to worry about the non-blue mid and the left woofer in pic 3561.

Are these both mutts?
 
After a few days with the new-to-me W90D speakers, I'm thinking I should work on improving their appearance as well as the insides. I'm looking for anyone who has W90Ds and can take a couple of pics and provide dimensions for the removable cloth grill covers. Mine are the low boy version and have only velcro pads on the front baffles so I don't have a reference for the covers, other than the catalog cuts of the entire speaker that are in post #1221. Specifically looking for closeups of the grill cloth and dimensions of the grill cloth frame, including thickness and the dimensions for the cutouts for the woofer and mid/hi. (Post #1111, in this thread, provides a good lead for a source for the fabric.) A front photo of mine are in post #1344, above.
Any info will be helpful.
Thanks
Bruce

Bruce,

Let me know if you need any additional measurements or pics.

Simpleton

*Edited because I hate typing on a phone.*
 

Attachments

  • 8856B70B-2680-4D36-BB45-26365D6069F6.jpeg
    8856B70B-2680-4D36-BB45-26365D6069F6.jpeg
    104.3 KB · Views: 13
  • F5FDF3B7-C032-4EBD-AFC2-30BC3F22E322.jpeg
    F5FDF3B7-C032-4EBD-AFC2-30BC3F22E322.jpeg
    109.7 KB · Views: 11
  • C29D27BA-6E2D-42F0-A0CC-6A995053B57A.jpeg
    C29D27BA-6E2D-42F0-A0CC-6A995053B57A.jpeg
    105.3 KB · Views: 11
  • 905BF545-C481-4378-9957-17091E4A69CF.jpeg
    905BF545-C481-4378-9957-17091E4A69CF.jpeg
    105 KB · Views: 11
  • 551B3069-D1E2-415B-9EE5-5C0F39275AAB.jpeg
    551B3069-D1E2-415B-9EE5-5C0F39275AAB.jpeg
    108.5 KB · Views: 12
All of the tweeters have been replaced with units from some other application. The non blue mid is replaced ( you know this ) and the woofer has either been replaced or reconed. It appears to have a reverse rubber surround and a weighted dust cap.
 
In truth, I'd like to do both. First, I'd like to be able get these guys back to original to see what they sound like.

I expect that is going to be either impossible or too expensive to be reasonable, but it's worth a try.

If I don't like the sound or I can't find the parts, then I will see about newer replacements.

That being said, are these supposed to have the jellyfish tweeters? I had really hoped that the speaker in pic 3560 was correct and I only had to worry about the non-blue mid and the left woofer in pic 3561.

Are these both mutts?
There are two sets of purple "jellyfish" tweeters available on the flea bay UK site right now. Just sub the .uk for the .com and search for Wharfedale jellyfish tweeters. One set is 45 pounds (pricey) and the other is 29 pounds. That's under $100 US + shipping. Not terrible.
 
All of the tweeters have been replaced with units from some other application. The non blue mid is replaced ( you know this ) and the woofer has either been replaced or reconed. It appears to have a reverse rubber surround and a weighted dust cap.

Well, this explains why some of the soldering looks like it was done with someone with a palsy.

I ordered some Audyn Cap Q4 12uF 400V MKP Foil and Dayton Audio DMPC-30 30uF 250V Polypropylene capacitors from partsexpress before I had done much research.

I'm just going to put in the new caps and see what is sounds like. From there I guess I may have to part them out if I have to replace half the speakers.

I had really hoped I had found something when I bought these.
 
Well, this explains why some of the soldering looks like it was done with someone with a palsy.

I ordered some Audyn Cap Q4 12uF 400V MKP Foil and Dayton Audio DMPC-30 30uF 250V Polypropylene capacitors from partsexpress before I had done much research.

I'm just going to put in the new caps and see what is sounds like. From there I guess I may have to part them out if I have to replace half the speakers.

I had really hoped I had found something when I bought these.
Well, you did. There's a pair on flea bay listed at $800. I have a pair of W70E's and a pair of Rosedales (almost identical to the W70Es in concept). I haven't seen anyone selling the 15 inch woofer for these for a very long time.
 
Back
Top Bottom