• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

Here's a look into my Hong Kong made Wharfdale W3's. I bought them a few years ago in Montana, I found them on Craigslist. A woman was selling some of her father's things out of a dusty garage. I saw them and just had to have them without knowing quite what they were. I brought them back to my fiancee's place. They got an audition and replaced the Utah HSC 3's in the evolving system I was putting together for her. Months passed and the Wharfdales were superseded by a pair of Advents. I mentioned that the Wharfdales could be slaughtered for their drivers, but Miss Jessica, despite her being tired of speakers filling up the house, wouldn't hear of it. So into the basement they went. it was the first time she ever registered and attachment to a set of speakers.

Last fall I picked up a Fisher X202B, this spring I recapped it and put some new tubes in as well. With the Fisher up and running it seemed like the perfect time to revisit the Wharfdales. Pictures follow.
 
They feature a 3" tweeter and 5" mid-range, both of which meter out to just over 8 ohms. The round oil filled cap measured 12.32 mfd, the square one to 1.98 mfd.

IMG_20200417_132119.jpg
 
Are we to presume that you have the FS (foam surround) models and that the speakers need new surrounds? If so you will have to cut new surrounds from a foam plastic sheet as original factory replacements are non-existant. The first version of the Linton fitted the speakers internally and to remove a faulty speaker required the rear panel to be cut out.

Yea, they are the FS model, but the foam is fine. The problem is that one of the mids is physically missing. This has all been rectified for the time being though...kinda. I’m going to sideline those big guys because I drove a total of eight hours today to buy a pair of W90D’s and I COULD NOT be happier with how these things sound! I finally feel like I have a pretty decent system and these speakers were the final touch. The tweeters have been replaced with modern ones, which I had read was the thing to do with these. Can anyone suggest period correct tweeters I could put in? Perhaps I should just leave them alone though....
I know the spacing and direction of the speakers may be a bit funky...but limited space and my wife’s opinion in the matter had to be considered!
 

Attachments

  • 6CA945B0-B6A6-4C8D-B7B0-DEB53E125C18.jpeg
    6CA945B0-B6A6-4C8D-B7B0-DEB53E125C18.jpeg
    142.1 KB · Views: 17
  • 82C16EDB-AD5B-4015-8F00-61F6EF253C23.jpeg
    82C16EDB-AD5B-4015-8F00-61F6EF253C23.jpeg
    145 KB · Views: 16
  • CC150C1B-5C6C-4616-B554-3312BCE0192F.jpeg
    CC150C1B-5C6C-4616-B554-3312BCE0192F.jpeg
    140.3 KB · Views: 19
Can anyone suggest period correct tweeters I could put in? Perhaps I should just leave them alone though....
Those are Visaton DT-94 tweeters which are the suggested replacements for the originals. I don't think you'll find anything better. The originals were Mylar, these are polycarbonate. They have about the same efficiency, DC resistance, and a flatter frequency response.
 
They feature a 3" tweeter and 5" mid-range, both of which meter out to just over 8 ohms. The round oil filled cap measured 12.32 mfd, the square one to 1.98 mfd.

View attachment 1836073
I don't get the placement of what looks like the tweeter. From the picture, it looks like it's bolted to a shelf in the box pointing directly up at a cut out in the top of the speaker which is several inches from where the tweeter is mounted. Looks to me like most of the sound would be lost inside of the box. Am I missing something?
 
I don't get the placement of what looks like the tweeter. From the picture, it looks like it's bolted to a shelf in the box pointing directly up at a cut out in the top of the speaker which is several inches from where the tweeter is mounted.

That's exactly the arrangement. It's why I'm a little concerned about room placement. I'm thinking that a foot off the ground in a fairly live room might be what's ideal.
 
That's exactly the arrangement. It's why I'm a little concerned about room placement. I'm thinking that a foot off the ground in a fairly live room might be what's ideal.
These may have originally been design for a mono system. Probably the thinking was at the time that a crystal cartridge was a little sharp around 8KHz and that would have muted the peak. Just a guess... OR, they were way out in front of Bose:) In any case, I'd be inclined to augment the high end with an outboard tweeter. Do you have any equipment to do spectrum analysis for the room EQ?
 
Howdy Y'all
I'm the proud new owner of some Wharfedale W90D's and have a few questions. They sound AMAZING; by far the best speakers I've owned. My other Wharfedales have some issues, but I'm sure they could sound at least as good as these once they are all sorted out. At any rate, I've read in numerous places that these are super efficient and you don't need a very powerful amp with something in the 20-50 watts being more than enough. Well, I have a Technics SU-8600, which has 73 wpc. These sound amazing if the music is clean a pretty distortion free but they lose their luster a bit if there's a ton of distortion (see, Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) by Neil Young). I then read this morning that "these aren't speakers you want to listen to hard rock, loud and with a ton of power." Based on what I heard, I concur but want to make sure of something...Is it that they wont sound ideal or is there any risk of damaging them with the 73wpc?? If its just that some music wont sound as good as other, I'm fine with that...it only gives me an excuse to set up a whole new system at some point! :banana: But, I don't want to risk damaging anything. Thoughts?? I've listened to smoother electric guitar on these, and they sound excellent for the most part. My other speakers, which are a custom boxes housing W15s, Super 8's and Super 3's, eat up as much distortion as you can throw at them. I was a slightly let down when I listened to Hey Hey, My My, which was a bummer, but oh well. I still love the warm sound of these!

I’ve attached some pics. I know the spacing and angle aren’t ideal, but it’s the best that happening in our 1000 ft2 apartment. Also, my wife’s opinion weighed heavily, haha. I’m going to have a woodworker buddy build some bases for me, to raise them up a bit. Also see attached picture of some rough plans I drew up.
 

Attachments

  • 210B80E9-6CA0-4B8E-AC1F-20243FA4E307.jpeg
    210B80E9-6CA0-4B8E-AC1F-20243FA4E307.jpeg
    140.3 KB · Views: 18
  • AD7DE391-466D-4C9B-BAE1-6B34E99FEECB.jpeg
    AD7DE391-466D-4C9B-BAE1-6B34E99FEECB.jpeg
    153.5 KB · Views: 16
  • 36AA9B23-39BB-49C7-ABD0-20D1A66064DB.jpeg
    36AA9B23-39BB-49C7-ABD0-20D1A66064DB.jpeg
    161.4 KB · Views: 18
  • 4AC6A2F7-C78D-49D9-AB47-5DFB0B3C525F.jpeg
    4AC6A2F7-C78D-49D9-AB47-5DFB0B3C525F.jpeg
    110.7 KB · Views: 19
Last edited:
Is it that they wont sound ideal or is there any risk of damaging them with the 73wpc??
If you overdrive the bass speakers long enough it will deform the voice coil and they will start to buzz. You can listen to hard rock at moderate volumes but you'll damage them if you listen to them at concert levels for a sustained amount of time. It should be safe to use an amp with 70 wpc as long as you don't run them over their rated power handling.
 
If you overdrive the bass speakers long enough it will deform the voice coil and they will start to buzz. You can listen to hard rock at moderate volumes but you'll damage them if you listen to them at concert levels for a sustained amount of time. It should be safe to use an amp with 70 wpc as long as you don't run them over their rated power handling.
Thanks for the response! I'm new to audio stuff, but I assume the "rated power handling" is going to be dictated by how much volume you try to push through them? Along those same lines, if I had an amp that was in the 20-40 wpc range, it'd be much hard or impossible to push them too hard??
 
Thanks for the response! I'm new to audio stuff, but I assume the "rated power handling" is going to be dictated by how much volume you try to push through them? Along those same lines, if I had an amp that was in the 20-40 wpc range, it'd be much hard or impossible to push them too hard??
I

I think most people here would say you are safer with an amp with more power than one with lower power rating - when used responsibly. A lower powered amp, pushed to the max, can clip and will risk damaging the tweeters. The earlier comment about too much power is also totally correct - speakers can of course be destroyed with too much power. If you are hearing notably higher distortion as the volume is pushed higher, you probably are at the higher end of the power the speaker can handle. Backing off a little is the best approach.

As the previous owner of your speakers, I'll offer a couple of other comments.
a. Your experience with the Neil Young track could be caused by several factors, either alone or in combination - your personal sensitivity to distortion, original recording wasn't the best (I don't have this track, so no direct experience), a weakness in any part of the signal chain (cartridge, amp, speaker), speaker placement (although less likely), speakers that are higher resolution than what you have been using. Many people, including me, are still surprised at the variation in sound quality for typical recordings. It can also vary significantly from one medium to another as well as from one copy of a vinyl recording to the next. As long as most of your music sounds the way you would expect it, I would take comfort in the realization you may be hearing more "into the recordings" than you may have previously.
b. The proper speaker placement can produce dramatically better resolution than if a person just places speakers in the most convenient places. There are many ways of proceeding with optimizing speaker placement, and there are people that will swear by each of them. I have found that moving speakers as little as 1/4" will notably improve the overall sound. Sounds OCD but my skeptical other half acknowledged this as true. Your mission is to experiment with height, distance, toe-in and angling speakers up slightly (from level) until you find what works best for your ears.
c. I did replace all of the capacitors with Dayton 5% polypropelene caps. The speakers are 50 years old and the original caps were way out of tolerance.
d. If you take the backs off for inspection, make sure you remember that the wires from the back panel to the interior are very short. I saw this warning in the Wharfedale owners thread before I started work and it was on target. You will be able to just get your flat hand in before you will need to reach in and disconnect the wires. Then you can fully remove the back.

I'm happy you like the speakers!
Bruce
 
I

I think most people here would say you are safer with an amp with more power than one with lower power rating - when used responsibly. A lower powered amp, pushed to the max, can clip and will risk damaging the tweeters. The earlier comment about too much power is also totally correct - speakers can of course be destroyed with too much power. If you are hearing notably higher distortion as the volume is pushed higher, you probably are at the higher end of the power the speaker can handle. Backing off a little is the best approach.

As the previous owner of your speakers, I'll offer a couple of other comments.
a. Your experience with the Neil Young track could be caused by several factors, either alone or in combination - your personal sensitivity to distortion, original recording wasn't the best (I don't have this track, so no direct experience), a weakness in any part of the signal chain (cartridge, amp, speaker), speaker placement (although less likely), speakers that are higher resolution than what you have been using. Many people, including me, are still surprised at the variation in sound quality for typical recordings. It can also vary significantly from one medium to another as well as from one copy of a vinyl recording to the next. As long as most of your music sounds the way you would expect it, I would take comfort in the realization you may be hearing more "into the recordings" than you may have previously.
b. The proper speaker placement can produce dramatically better resolution than if a person just places speakers in the most convenient places. There are many ways of proceeding with optimizing speaker placement, and there are people that will swear by each of them. I have found that moving speakers as little as 1/4" will notably improve the overall sound. Sounds OCD but my skeptical other half acknowledged this as true. Your mission is to experiment with height, distance, toe-in and angling speakers up slightly (from level) until you find what works best for your ears.
c. I did replace all of the capacitors with Dayton 5% polypropelene caps. The speakers are 50 years old and the original caps were way out of tolerance.
d. If you take the backs off for inspection, make sure you remember that the wires from the back panel to the interior are very short. I saw this warning in the Wharfedale owners thread before I started work and it was on target. You will be able to just get your flat hand in before you will need to reach in and disconnect the wires. Then you can fully remove the back.

I'm happy you like the speakers!
Bruce
Good to hear from you on here Bruce. Its funny that you brought up that "quality of the recording" aspect of it, because I considered that very thing this morning. In general, my wife and I try to find the nicest example of whatever record we're hunting for. This is usually a special edition or something like that, and generally sounds very good. This Neil Young with Crazy Horse record is a mass produced example. It did sound better on the other speakers, but I also had your speakers cranked up a bit, and that may have been part of the issue as well. We've probably listened to 20 different records since we got these home and this was the only one that sounded "off". All the others were at least as good as they've ever sounded. My Dad is a huge Neil Young fan & I grew up on his stuff, so I know how that track is supposed to sound. But, all the other records we played were likely higher quality, newer and nowhere near the distortion that N.Y. put into his guitar. His guitar REALLY growls on this particular track. Pink Floyd's - The Wall is the best I've ever heard it on these speakers and a lot of my wife's more contemporary "pop" music is very lively and full. After reading a bit about the wattage ratings and limits, I just wanted to make sure that I wasn't risking anything. At this point, I have a decent amount of money into all this stuff and can't do it all again in the short-term! It seems to me, from what a few of you have said, that the speakers will tell me if I pushing them too hard and to just dial things back a bit.
I buy into the positioning aspect of this 100%, as I can walked just a half foot or so and the sound from these speakers changes notably. Also, as we have discussed, getting them higher up is going to be a must. I may have him leave the back lip of the top off, so that I have the option of tilting them back a bit as well.
Thanks for the heads up on the wires. Unfortunately, I have a mind that desires tinkering and the taking apart of a perfectly working item, so I may jump into them at some point to check things out. As of now, I'm going to let them be and enjoy them. Long term goals are to pair them with a Fisher 800C and and undecided similar vintage TT. My Technics amp and TT will then likely get paired with some Pioneer HP-100's.
 
Thanks for the response! I'm new to audio stuff, but I assume the "rated power handling" is going to be dictated by how much volume you try to push through them? Along those same lines, if I had an amp that was in the 20-40 wpc range, it'd be much hard or impossible to push them too hard??
You can still damage them if you try hard:), but I think it would be safer. I have the W70E's and use an amp that's 40 watts
 
Back
Top Bottom