I certainly agree that Gilbert must have spent a great deal of time listening and voicing. The actual modding of designs to change the sound is beyond me technically. I mean, to actually decide what to change in the shape/stiffness/annular/coils size or what have you, constantly testing and re-testing in those very early days.
But I've thought about this a lot, and I'm starting to propose that a large bass driver with a short excursion will produce and more lifelike and faster kick than a smaller, long excursion bass driver. I remember in the 80's or 90's having a pair of missions (700's I think) and I used to love to watch those bass units pistoning, thumping out bass, I swear they moved a quarter-inch or more. But actually of course, most bass vibrations don't move that way in life, the soundboard of a string bass hardly moves at all, even a kick drum though it moves significantly, returns so quickly you can hardly see it move. Perhaps one of the secrets of the lifelike reproduction here is that short excursion large bass driver. That goes no way to explain the incredible wrap-around soundstage they produce. And this was mid to late 60's and the question I ask now is: Is the Dovedale the pinnacle of Briggs designs, or is there more to discover? And were the later models (3's and III's - what's the difference?) better than these W2's? I know he went on to the Airedales and others with onmi-directional designs, but I have read conflicting opinions on those. So: which were the best Wharfedales ever made?