• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

A new saga begins: The social media marketplace yielded a little gem for me yesterday, when I found these:

W3's (1962 I think)

What's good: Well the cabinets are in good condition (though the lacquer is in need of a refinish. The bass drivers are original.

The bad news: someone has clearly had a go at replacing the mid and high drivers, in fact they have put two tweeters in series! They are not properly mounted and are just random units, mounted (or not as the case may be) in a random way.


The speakers sound, well, odd! Quite undefined, and a little bland, not at all like wharfedales. The caps are original, one paper in oil and one metallised foil, no idea yet how they are performing but I think it's safe to say they will need replacing. I will try to find replacement original drivers for the top end. I'm not sure what they would have been, but I found an image on the net which might help:
977974632_tp.jpg


can anyone identify them from that?

The fabric is also stained and damaged in places, not horrendous but replacing it would transform these. Should I?
Interestingly, someone helpfully left a schematic inside:
 
It is all about having spare parts. Extra speakers, crossovers, etc. the 1st model W70 was built around 58 years ago. I goes without saying that the drivers are long out of production. A parts stash is very nice to have. I just picked up another pair of W35 crossovers. I had no need for them as I already have a set. But the W35 is such a rare model that you pick up parts when they appear, and these crossover did not sell on their first listing. Another thing except for the value of one inductor and the capacitors the W35 is easily to convert to a crossover for the W45.
 
Thanks for your input. I am assuming the drivers I need will have been used in other models, I just need to find out which and I can start searching. Do you know if the W3 I found was ever, in any guise, sold in the US? Or anywhere else for that matter? What model of drivers am I looking for do you think? Any help in identifying them would be appreciated, I'd like to get these back to their original form to see what they should sound like. If they are really such early models that they are too un-evolved compared to my W2's I will then need to decide what to do next. Keep them original and sell them or upgrade and keep.
 
Thanks for your input. I am assuming the drivers I need will have been used in other models, I just need to find out which and I can start searching. Do you know if the W3 I found was ever, in any guise, sold in the US? Or anywhere else for that matter? What model of drivers am I looking for do you think? Any help in identifying them would be appreciated, I'd like to get these back to their original form to see what they should sound like. If they are really such early models that they are too un-evolved compared to my W2's I will then need to decide what to do next. Keep them original and sell them or upgrade and keep.
Pretty sure that tweeter is a super 3 which is the same one used in early W90's. There's one on e-pay right now for $75 (6/8 Ohms as marked) which looks to be a good price considering all others listed are > $100. Also, if you need woofers, there's also a W12 FRS Bass Speaker in original box listed 11.6 Ohms (12 Ohms) for $56 each.
 
Sorry to bring up an old subject, but I’m not sure I found the ‘final’ answer (pg 49 or so talks about coating the cloth surrounds). I’m still waffling about taking on that effort on what could be a perfectly fine set(s) of woofers. W90D pair, sound decent but bottom end of disappointing. Replaced the tweeters, but have the originals (3 out of 4 work) and also replaced the caps. Here’s a close-up of one of the surrounds:

IMG_4667-L.jpg


I’m thinking these might be better suited for someone else but could be talked off the ledge….
 
Sorry to bring up an old subject, but I’m not sure I found the ‘final’ answer (pg 49 or so talks about coating the cloth surrounds).
From everything I've read on speakers with cloth surrounds, coating the surround improves the bass response. I have no idea how dramatic the change would be on the W90's. One thing you also have to account for is bass cancellation in your room. These are sensitive to placement. My W70E's produce loads of bass, but in order to hear it I had to put them about 4-6 inches from the wall, and about 6 feet apart on the same wall, and at least 3-4 feet from the corners of the room. Even after getting placement right, I had a lot of cancellation right on center, but it suited my seating arrangement perfectly. One sure fire way to know if you have cancellation problems is crank up the bass, put on a record that produces bass, and walk around the room. If you hear concentrations of bass in the wrong spots (I.E. where you don't sit) then you probably need to work on this.
 
I guess my hesitance stems from whether or not to “modify” stock/OEM drivers. Perhaps I’m ascribing too much value to these speakers - overall - and shouldn’t be concerned about potentially violating any perceived net worth. For instance, in replacing the tweeters, I 3D-printed adapter plates to mount the new ones without modifying the box. And I still have the originals as I mentioned.

I’m half tempted to sell the OEM bits and use the boxes for a new build.
 
W90D pair, sound decent but bottom end of disappointing.
I think one has to take a leaf out of Brigg's book on this. In his tome on Sound Reproduction, he basically argued that tone controls have such utility now that achieving a flat sound response was the best outcome, so you could adjust the tone to suit your room and tastes. When you say the bass is disappointing, is that with defeated or flat tone controls? The Wharfedale's are renowned for not being bass-heavy. If everything is in order, that is not to say they are not capable of reproducing it, just that they have a balanced delivery.

I must admit I have never really bought into the 'keep the tone flat' camp. I don't want to add or remove perfectly useful furnishings just to adjust the tone in a room, I have very good tone controls for that purpose. My W2's do need a little help in the bass department because of where out of necessity I must site them, but when it is set to my liking, the sonic structure of the bass they deliver is far better (to me) than the over-inflated waffling bass delivery of many high-end speakers set ups I've heard. Strangely, I also have a pair of Unit 4 kit speakers which have very similar drivers in, and they are very bass-heavy, to the point where I am removing bass not adding it. Once I do, they are exquisite.

Of course, I am aware there are lots of high-end amps with no tone controls at all, and I must admit to smiling when I see such an amp, wondering how I would get on with it. Perhaps I am missing the point. But as Infullview correctly says, the position is everything with these speakers, and well worth the time experimenting. You may well find other speakers which provide more bass tone for a given input, but I seriously doubt there are many which can provide the insightful, visceral and gutteral way it is delivered by a good 12 inch Wharfie in full song. Simply adjust to taste and enjoy! Personally, I wouldn't be coating the annulars with anything, it may well increase the bass response, but will it improve it?
 
Of course, I am aware there are lots of high-end amps with no tone controls at all, and I must admit to smiling when I see such an amp, wondering how I would get on with it.
Very much in agreement with your sentiments above. I have to smile when I think about the purist wars here on AK about introducing, OMG, Tone Controls into the signal path. Interestingly, I used to use the bass, and treble controls, but from the day I got my W70Es sorted out I set them flat and for the most part never touch them now.
 
The original instructions for setting the level controls on the speakers are very simple.you turned the level pot’s all of the way down. In your listening position you than had someone turn up each pot’ until you can just hear that speaker, with that you are set.
 
ziggydave, I tend to run flat controls myself. It’s rare for me to adjust bass for instance (simple system, no multi band processor) as my collection of media spans a somewhat broad range of genres and decades.
But when I last had the W90D’s running in earnest, I could switch between the K-Horns and them. But to be fair I was also running a SW-15 sub and got hooked on that (absolutely required with the K-horns in my use).
So part of my issue is the large gap from now (AVR 3000 or SX-780, with a sub) and 20 years ago (KR-9600 and Rectilinear III’s, 5’s and 7’s). Yep, bad comparison. But I have ordered the cloth surround goo, and hope it helps fill in the bottom end a smidge. I’m not expecting sub level, but my other reference is a pair of Dynaco A25’s. On these, the sub helps but I could get by without. I didn’t quite get that with the W90D’s. I will use the SX-780 as my primary source driver.

I will also work on placement - moved everything to a new room.
 
ziggydave, I tend to run flat controls myself. It’s rare for me to adjust bass for instance (simple system, no multi band processor) as my collection of media spans a somewhat broad range of genres and decades.

It really is an interesting subject and this difference of opinion exactly highlights the subjectiveness of it. We do different things for the same reason!. Of course the important thing is achieving the sound you like, love, can't do without, in whatever way you must do to get there. Every set of speakers will give a different result at a given voltage, and I for one am more than happy to even use the 'dreaded' loudness button if I happen to be listening late when the rest are asleep and I need to keep it low rather than listen to a weakened bass due to the human condition of non-linear response to low volume in my ears. I am also quite happy to apply a little sonic adjustment to some recordings which subjectively sound to me like they need a little fine-tuning, because my media spans a somewhat broad range of genres and decades and one-size definately does not fit all.

In his day I'm sure Briggs would have wholeheartedly endorsed your trials with 'Goo' to try to improve things, him being the innovator he was! He broke every known rule in attempts to try new things, because if it didn't work he could easily scrap it and start again, having an almost unlimited supply of new drivers. (What interesting work it must have been!)

I just question (very humbly) the thought process by which you chase this. In what way do you want the sound to be quite exactly not quite like a Wharfedale? If the driver is spoiled and this goo is an attempt at restoration there is little to lose, but if the driver is working as intended and you simply don't like the sound and want to change it then one could argue you should change the speaker or perhaps adapt the enclosure or porting in some way.

In my work as a conservator, (of a completely different type of musical instruments...stringed) it is the first rule to do no harm. These drivers are a valuable and limited resource. Yours, in a different environment, to a different pair of ears, powered by a different system, may be perfectly good examples. In that sense they do have some value. I know from experience that different wharfedale 12" drivers do have different responses, maybe you could look to borrow another unit before permanently adapting these is all I am saying.
 
ziggydave, I think we are on the same page. I do NOT want to modify the drivers outside of their original design. If that is what came across, then I’ll strive harder to communicate more effectively.

The real question is this: did the cloth surround have a polymerized component to it originally (and thus behave airtight) or was it merely mesh cloth (and breathable)? You see, my goal with the vintage-ar “goo” is an attempt to return it to (as close as) like-new condition. If the woofers were indeed not designed to have a sealed surround, then I will gladly donate the polymer stuff to someone who should use it and find someone to take the Wharfies, complete with the 4 original purple egg tweeters. I’ll focus my attention on other avenues.

If the surrounds did have a polymer (sealant) component that has been lost over time, then I’d welcome any discussion on how best to refurbish it more “authentically”.

Lastly, if nothing conclusive can be determined I may decide to experiment anyway. I’ve previously listed these locally (planning to move and these things are heavy) with 0 interested parties. They are not Alnico drivers and they aren’t worth SX-1980 money (these are ‘D’ models). Nothing I’ve done has modified these in any way that can’t be returned to original (save for the caps). That includes the wood screws and tweeters (in a conservator way). :)
 
f the driver is spoiled and this goo is an attempt at restoration there is little to lose, but if the driver is working as intended and you simply don't like the sound and want to change it then one could argue you should change the speaker or perhaps adapt the enclosure or porting in some way.
The "Goo" does not last forever. It could also be cleaned off with the right solvent, so this is reversible. He's not going to damage the authenticity of the woofer by trying it.
 
Well, I am grateful for the dialogue, I am learning all the time. I completely understand what you are trying to do now Homemadesin, please accept my sincere apology if I came across as a shmuck. I have all manner of strange potions in my toolkit, but this goo is new to me. What exactly is it?

I am also interested in the driver variations. I have different pairs of 12" drivers, some are the familiar red round alnico I think, and found in my W3's, the others are different (see pics) possibly not alnico, and appear in both my W2's and Unit 4 cabinets sounding completely different in each guise. Possibly due to different crossovers, or more likely because the Unit 4's are not ported. I cannot stress how much more bass the Unit4's produce.

Clearly evolution has taken place, and there are many different driver model numbers that serve to confuscate ( I don't know what an SX1980 is).

Is there an encyclopedic reference of the various Wharfedale drivers (with pictures) available? I understand that a lot of information was lost in the factory fire at some point. My two variants are here, perhaps someone can identify them for sure?

 
Back
Top Bottom