• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

Yes that works now. Quite a collection!

So I'm still trying to get to the bottom of this driver identification problem. The best I can manage so far is that my W3 should have WLS /12's , 5" W3's and Super 3's. Obviously my mid and high-end are missing. Where on earth will I get 5" W3's (I've not seen them mentioned anywhere before.) Super 3's do seem to be about but most are in poor condition and will probably need complete restoration which will be costly.

My other option would be to find suitable Wharfedale replacements from a period a little just a little later, keep the crossover and woofers, and refurbish the cabinets. My thinking is: as I don't have the original mid and top units anyway, and I can't find replacements I can afford, what harm is there in at least getting the W3's as close to original as I can for now and them being used (and hopefully loved) rather than them sitting unused? I only paid £100 for these so I'm not feeling disheartened, and If I can get them sounding as good as the W2's I'll be a very happy bunny.

I did find this: http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/Wharfedale_cat_files/Wharfedale_CabinetModels_1962_page1-8.pdf

which is from 62. Interestingly it mentions the polystyrene foam-filled drivers PST/12 for slimline cabinets, which I have also seen on other W3's but are definitely not fitted to mine.

So, can anyone:
  1. Confirm those woofers are WLS/12's? and
  2. Suggest suitable replacements for the mid and high units?
 
  • Confirm those woofers are WLS/12's? and
Do you need new woofers? They are WLS/12's. As you can see, they are 12 Ohms on the schematics you have, and they were used in other models in the same time period. You will never find any definitive reference that specifies internal components on these speakers. They just don't exist. Wharfedale made so many changes during production it's difficult to find two sets of the same model that are exactly alike inside. You should be able to find replacements from other models such as the 5 inch from a newer pair of Dovedale 3-ways. It will probably have a paper cone with a ferrite magnet, but will be very close in sound to the original 5 inch that was in your W3 as it is a descendant of this design.
 
Do you need new woofers? They are WLS/12's. As you can see, they are 12 Ohms on the schematics you have, and they were used in other models in the same time period. You will never find any definitive reference that specifies internal components on these speakers. They just don't exist. Wharfedale made so many changes during production it's difficult to find two sets of the same model that are exactly alike inside. You should be able to find replacements from other models such as the 5 inch from a newer pair of Dovedale 3-ways. It will probably have a paper cone with a ferrite magnet, but will be very close in sound to the original 5 inch that was in your W3 as it is a descendant of this design.
My thoughts exactly. I don't think I need new woofers, but I was thinking of using the mid and high from either a Dovedale three-way or Unit 5 three-way kit, and see how they sound. I think at least one of the tweeters that has been replaced already is from an E30,50,70 or similar (with the brushed alloy surround) but I'd like to get back to the 70's at least.

I've got enough woofers to replace them too if need be, as mentioned previously, I'm confused as to why the same woofers in my W2 and Unit 4 cabinets sound so different. The unported cab is much bass-ier, is that what you would expect?
 
Update, I have located and bought a pair of tweeters (purple fried egg), and so far just one 5" ferrite mid/tweeter from a Dalesman, I'm guessing the same as a Dovedale, for not too much money. I also now have more 12" Ferrite magnet drivers than I know what to do with, I just seem to get another one or two in each deal! Useful to have I suppose. Just need a second mid and I can put the W3's back to something like how they should be. I have been doing a LOT of listening to them in their present configuration and it is clear that they have not been used much at all for a long time. The alnico woofers were at first very reluctant but have freed up significantly and are starting to round up and punch again. They are a very different proposition with the mid and top-end drivers being outside the main enclosure and pointing, well, like a cross-eyed lion. The effect is quite difficult to describe, the soundstage is softened, quite intimate. I am beginning to really like them but at the moment there is still a lack of smoothness to the midrange, I'm thinking it may be those dreaded caps again, I have done nothing to the crossovers yet. But they are definitely a project in motion.

I also did some testing with those bass-heavy unit 4 speakers, and have concluded it is the lack porting which creates a boombox, there is a massive amount of wadding in them so obvoiusly someone has tried to tame them before. I might just strip out the units and scrap the cabs. Though they are good and very well constructed, they are not Wharfedale and probably have no real value.

I was wondering if anyone here has ever made a direct comparison between the Dovedales and the Ditton 44, them being similar spec. The Dittons seem to be more esteemed (over here in the UK at least, fetching bigger money than the Dovedales) and I wondered why? So much so that I have bought some! When they arrive I will compare and report.
 
The Dittons seem to be more esteemed (over here in the UK at least, fetching bigger money than the Dovedales) and I wondered why? So much so that I have bought some! When they arrive I will compare and report.
OMG, you're becoming an addict!:) You'll be just like everyone else on AK when you start running out of space to put stuff, and don't have enough time to get to all the "projects" you've started. I've been there for over a year now. It's tough to see really great deals on a pair of speakers and you have to look away cause you're already over committed.
 
OMG, you're becoming an addict!:) You'll be just like everyone else on AK when you start running out of space to put stuff, and don't have enough time to get to all the "projects" you've started. I've been there for over a year now. It's tough to see really great deals on a pair of speakers and you have to look away cause you're already over committed.
Personally I don't think I'll ever run out of space...my wife on the other hand.....:oops:
 
Thought one or two of you may appreciate these...
The W3's have been on the bench for the last two weeks. I managed to pick up an early pair of Tritons from 1971, and used the purple dome tweeters and 5" mids to swap out those horrid and wrong units someone had butchered in. They are much more in keeping and should retain the vintage wharfedale sound. I couldn't find a matched pair of either the super 3's or earlier 5" drivers for sensible money, but these will do for now. Had to use a little creativity... I have also been refinishing. Some lovely grain on these. I decided not to go too far, I've left any small chips and wear in the veneer, and just restored the french polish to protect them. I've used some period looking fabric to restore the grilles, and decided to reuse the original 60 yr old rope bindings to retain the period look. I think it was the right decision. The end result: I'm very pleased that they still look 'old' but beautiful I think. How do they sound? In short, amazing. I have not replaced any of the old capacitors. Not yet anyway. I will run them for a while and see how they fair but the crossovers are doing their job. Those upward firing tweeters certainly create an atmosphere but the mids I think are doing most of the high end work and the staging is fantastic. I think the old caps may be draining a little bass response, I will need to get them checked out, but Jeez, these are from 1959! I'm in love!
 
Yes, that is the next job, should I try sourcing oil/paper or metallised paper caps or wax/paper, or go for more reliable modern alternatives like the mundorfs (expensive) or just branded film capacitors. ? The originals from 1959 (Aug and December) changed from flat box to round cannister between the two cabinets showing how quickly technology progressed) and are 13uF for mid and 3uF for tweeter at 50V. But as I've changed the mid and top drivers, should I change the caps too? (the crossovers for the triton I note use completely different values but are a more complex crossover.) Or I could just use the triton xovers I suppose. I'd appreciate any advice here...
 
Yes, that is the next job, should I try sourcing oil/paper or metallised paper caps or wax/paper, or go for more reliable modern alternatives like the mundorfs (expensive) or just branded film capacitors. ? The originals from 1959 (Aug and December) changed from flat box to round cannister between the two cabinets showing how quickly technology progressed) and are 13uF for mid and 3uF for tweeter at 50V. But as I've changed the mid and top drivers, should I change the caps too? (the crossovers for the triton I note use completely different values but are a more complex crossover.) Or I could just use the triton xovers I suppose. I'd appreciate any advice here...
That tweeter you have was typically crossed over with a 4uF cap so stay with the 3 as your mid will handle the upper range OK. It really doesn't matter what type of non-polar cap you use. If you want long term durability use film. Don't change the crossovers as these were designed specifically for this enclosure.
 
Thanks for the help infullview, are you're right of course. For info the original caps are 2 and 12 uF.

Last night I finally received the new caps for the W3's and installed them.


Oh Wow.


I had thought that these were sounding great, but in a 'well that's all you can expect from a speaker made in 1959!' sort of way. I was doing the nostalgia trip. But my accommodations were premature. The new caps have completely changed the sonic sphere of these. That familiar W-series Alnico confident bass is there in spades, but there is also an eerily present upper-mid sweet presentation from the combination of upward-firing tweeters and forward-firing upper-mid. I thought the soundstage would be unfocussed but clearly, Gilbert knew it was the mid and high mid that matters, who am I to argue, he was proved right. I simply cannot believe that this level of performance had been achieved before 1960 (it still sounds phenomenal today). It must have seemed supernatural to the public of the time! How much wage must they have had to invest to buy these? 3 months? six months??


So- to the sound. To me, these have a familial lineage within the signature Wharfedale sound. Bass - no question, deep and engaging. It envelops you without you knowing where it is coming from like someone has mischievously hidden a subwoofer somewhere to fool you, but it is never overly prominent, most of the time only there to help the presentation then occasionally physical. Maybe it is the full range being fed to the woofer which creates, albeit unintentionally perhaps, the illusion of these speakers being more than the total of their parts. The mid-range and top-end are very grown-up, developed, and almost forensic in the way it finds instruments you hadn’t noticed before. I am glad I managed to find period-appropriate replacements for the mid and tweeter section. The huge magnets on these drivers just seem to take everything without fuss or bother. The sound is similar but different to my W2’s in a way that is difficult to quantify. Perhaps slightly more refined and less teenage-angst. With careful positioning, they fill the room like a theatre surround and are easy to get on with. I would love to hear them under valve power!

It is interesting to me that there are a few months between these cabinet production dates, a story I have read somewhere on here before about buying a single speaker in the late ’50s and then stereo becoming more popular so enthusiasts bought a second. Either way, they have been paired all their lives since then.

I’ve read quite a lot since I started restoring these W3’s. There was obviously quite a lot of variation during their production. Some had the woofer cones filled with polystyrene to produce a flat face! Almost every crossover I’ve seen has been slightly different, but clearly original. I am led to believe the super 3 tweeters at this age are unlikely to give much service without expensive recoils etc, and people are asking £150 a pair for burnt-out ones! These late 60’s drivers may of course only approximate the originals but are still 50 yrs old, original Wharfedale and sound wonderful, and should give years of service.

In terms of work, I’m somewhere between restoration and conservation. I’ve been fairly conservative, simply removing the cracked shellac polish back to wood without removing any age or witness marks and re-polishing them to a low sheen. They still look 60 years old, but like they have been well looked after, and I’m pleased with the choice of cloth. I have left all the original and interesting caps in place and simply bypassed them, (I found poly film caps for the tweeters as is only right, and high-quality bi-polar Alcaps for the mids) The old components have value as artifacts. But I think I was right to restore them so they can be enjoyed again as daily working pieces. Will I keep them? As has been pointed out I am getting obsessed and can’t keep them all, I’ve enjoyed the journey… maybe it’s right to pass them on. To me, they look magnificent but to my wife, they look out of place in our modern home, and as always it’s a joint decision that I think I might be losing. And I’ve still got the Ditton 44’s to work on next!
 
Will I keep them? As has been pointed out I am getting obsessed and can’t keep them all, I’ve enjoyed the journey… maybe it’s right to pass them on.
I kind of like the MCM look of these - not for everyone I guess. The one thing that haunts me is who do I pass mine on to when I'm ready to move on (one way or another)? I put a lot of time and energy into restoring these, and I sure as hell don't want them to be used as loud speakers at a teenage party. It took me about two months to build up parts of the cabinet that had been damaged by ratchet straps, carefully replace and patch veneer, and remove water stains on the top from a plant pot someone had left on it.

It envelops you without you knowing where it is coming from like someone has mischievously hidden a subwoofer somewhere to fool you, but it is never overly prominent, most of the time only there to help the presentation then occasionally physical.
I was listening to Runnin' Blue by Boz Scaggs (2004 Greatest Hits Live) and this song has a wonderful bass line throughout. Bass dynamics range from very quiet to loud. I noticed that when have the sub on the dynamics are nowhere near as pleasing as the bass just seems to dominate the piece. I think subs are great for movies, but there's nothing that can beat a speaker with amazing full range capabilities. Subs tend to inflate the bass and make it sound tubby.
 
I kind of like the MCM look of these - not for everyone I guess. The one thing that haunts me is who do I pass mine on to when I'm ready to move on (one way or another)? I put a lot of time and energy into restoring these, and I sure as hell don't want them to be used as loud speakers at a teenage party. It took me about two months to build up parts of the cabinet that had been damaged by ratchet straps, carefully replace and patch veneer, and remove water stains on the top from a plant pot someone had left on it.
It's sometimes difficult. Usually, for me, I don't own the thing I'm working on so who I pass it on to is not a choice. If anything haunts me there, it is the things people ask me to do to already lovely artefacts! (Usually: can I strip this table, fill the holes and paint it grey!!!! What is wrong with these people? They read the latest 'on-trend' magazine and beautiful antiques are forever lost. Not by me, they're not!).

If I buy a piece it's because I'm curious about it, either how it works or how it was made or how well it performs. In the W3's case, it was all of those things. I like to become more knowledgeable in my interests and my latest is vintage audio. There is something very satisfying in learning and knowing about something like that, but I don't know why and I can't explain it to my wife either! But you're right, I will need to find someone I can trust to become the guardians of these. It's a bit like being forced to rehome a pet, I would be more cautious about that than a potential spouse for my daughter.

As for learning, I too must accept that for many years I was ignorant in the sense that I didn't have the opportunity to experience what non-inflated, truly represented bass sounds like. I was a victim of the manufacturer's trends to impress potential purchasers in hi-fi shops. (Remember Studiocraft by Bose? Late '70's I think. Massively over-inflated bass and low impedance so in cheek by jowl comparisons in a sterile shop environment they sounded rich and louder than the competitors. Get them home and everything sounded the same through them: Fluffy and stifled. That seems to be what today's audience is looking for, though I suspect it is one reason why people don't seem to engage in recorded music like I did when I was their age, more and more it just seems to be something they have on in the background )

In truth, I hadn't heard a speaker like these in many years and had forgotten just how much more realistic they are. But I already have identical W2's in both my listening rooms and they are something my wife can much more easily live with aesthetically, I count myself lucky for that.

Sometimes.....
 
Back
Top Bottom