• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

Take 5 so darn good at Jazz too, only the magic texture is up the frequency range from the DMIIs, which I think is a significant advantage to the W70E on that particular album.
Ya, that was one of the first albums I played after I got mine restored:) Curious, what make is that reel to reel? It looks like a Tandberg.
 
Yeah, a prodigious amount of cast aluminum in that period of tape decks. I have an otari that's over ~100lbs.

Btw, meant to ask you earlier on the crossovers you re-designed for the W70Es/Rosedales... Are the crossover points the same (600 & 5000hz) or are they somewhat different?
 
Last edited:
Btw, meant to ask you earlier on the crossovers you re-designed for the W70Es/Rosedales... Are the crossover points the same (600 & 5000hz) or are they somewhat different?
According to the on-line RLC calculator, the combination of 4uF cap, .3mH inductor, and 6 Ohm load give a value of 4594Hz for the tweeter. The Mid starts at 1125Hz with a value of 16uF, 1.25mH inductor, and 6 Ohm load (so the mid is covering 1-5KHz range with some overlap at the top end of the mid-range driver with the tweeter). The woofer is rolled off at 1258Hz, so just a little overlap with the mid, with a value of 4mH inductor, and 4 uF cap with 6 Ohm (DC) load.

I don't know where you got your crossover values from, but given the component values on your board, they don't look right. Modeling your mid using a first order Butterworth calculation, and 8uF cap would indicate the mid is starting at around 3KHz. The tweeter starts at around 5KHz if the inductor is .15mH (which I believe is a good guess on my part). Now the wildcard in play is the series resistor (potentiometer) that changes the mid's crossover point lower as you turn it down.
 
Another update and I feel a bit silly having missed this.. Listening up close, I finally noticed the right woofer was weak and perhaps intermittent. Thinking I had a crossover wiring issue, I started to disassemble, when I notice that the riveted strip of circuit board (only one rivet in the center) that holds the tinsel leads had been rotated (probably from wire being pulled when positioning the woofer) such that the terminal nearly making contact with the basket frame, grounding it out to the basket.

Thankfully, that was a quick, easy fix.

Listening again, and you are right, the bass can become boomy as the volume goes up. I'm wondering if the sand filled back might have been helpful here. Going to listen some more, but thinking some deadening of the back panel might help tame any potential resonance. Not a scientific theory with a known basis, just a thought.
 
Last edited:
Listening again, and you are right, the bass can become boomy as the volume goes up. I'm wondering if the sand filled back might have been helpful here. Going to listen some more, but thinking some deadening of the back panel might help. Not a scientific theory with a known basis, just a thought.
I don't think sand has too much to do with it. These woofers just produce a lot of bass. I can't even use my sub with them. The best thing you can do is move them around the room to get the least amount of bass cancellation and they will really shine. My W70e's have a natural peak at around 37Hz. I leave the bass tone control flat.

Edit: let me just say you will feel the bass these produce through every part of your listening room, the floor, furniture, windows will all vibrate, and that is how it should be:)
 
Some improvement in the bass "boominess." The woofer that was not operating prior seems to have now broken in or "woken up" or whatever and overall the experience has improved greatly. Reconfiguring the room has also helped a fair bit as the adjoining rooms have zero soft materials and are copius collections of large flat surfaces of wood, glass and drywall.

Tried my Altec model 14s and even added in a velodyne servo sub in the room with the same receiver, since tubes seem to exacerbate this phenomenon when present. Both speakers are completely non-resonant and NO boominess in the room. Certainly I'm not expecting them to compete with these speakers as they are in another league and have at least 3x to 5x the density and far better components, but I feel that something is off with my 70Es.

The stuffing used for damping seemed sparse and matted, with a fair bit of room, even with all 5 'sheets' in each speaker. I'm thinking that perhaps the original was replaced and not enough purchased or the original is not all there or somehow compromised. Either way, don't know the origin of this stuffing, nor its condition/performance.

Will try some known acoustic poly-fill and perhaps a thin layer of sound deadening mat on the back wall, if that doesn't work. I don't feel that my particular speakers are all that well braced and feel hollow when rapped. I feel I'm hearing that echo chamber inside the cabinet and needs to be addressed. While I previously thought the absence of the sand back may have been a design choice, through now I am wondering if it was indeed a cost cutting measure. These are some of the lightest speakers I've owned and dimensions wise, It doesn't seemingly have any more volume than the W60DMKII I had, which were taller and deeper, but not as wide. It's possible that some of that extra mass took up more volume inside the cabinet though. Don't know and didn't check, though.

Have had luck in the past for similar situations, following a tip of using sound deadening with a layer of carpet underlayment glued to the top. Will try the acoustic poly-fill first, to see if that helps.

Here is one after treating the tops with some barkeepers friend to get out some black water or perhaps planter soil stains and a coat of clear danish oil. You can still see a faint bit of the stains, but much better than the stark black marks in geometric shapes all over before.

w70e oiled.jpg

The other, having cleaned the baffle and mid/woofer cones with a microfiber towel. You can see the aftermarket tweeter and the little ferrite magnet strips used to hold on the front grill covers. Also, note the inverted rubber surround on the woofer. Once you account for the overhangs and inset baffle, it's a fairly diminutive cabinet for a 15" woofer, unless counting kabuki speakers, though I don't think the cabinet volume is an issue.

baffle right.jpg
 
Last edited:
Ran across this handbook by GA Briggs on cabinet design

http://ukhhsoc.torrens.org/makers/Wharfedale/Wharfedale_cabinet_construction_sheet_October_1965.pdf

Some really interesting brick and concrete constructed speakers and covers materials, finishing, bracing, damping and reverbation management.

With respect to the 70E, tried new polyfill and some pink r-30 insulation I had lying around in differing amounts and this made no appreciable difference and a temporary brace has helped. Put the original yellow stuff back in. Polyfill didn't seem to work as well as the original stuff or fiberglass. (not a surprise)

Placed a square 1" dowel, just friction a tight fit with a bit of rubber cement to try it out, at the point in the center where the woofer, tweeter and midrange meet. Headed in the right direction, as I can go a bit louder without booming. Don't get me wrong, at low listening levels, these speakers are fantastic, but as the volume passes beyond polite level, the booming starts to show itself in greater abundance. At low levels with loudness on, these are fantastic. I just want these to be just as inert at the range above "polite" to just below "bad neighbor" as that's my listening range and I prefer a tighter overall bass (particularly mid-bass) presentation.

Ordered some kilmat to try on the bottom and back first as to minimize impact to the flat rear surfaces and minimal internal volume changes.

I'll line the inside top, sides, mid-range enclosure and bottom in that order to add more damping until I get the sound I'm looking for and try and minimize changing the internal volume much. The kilmat is 1.3mm thick, so I doubt it takes up too much space, but perhaps I might add an extra square foot or 2 of insulation with the paper facing removed, if the sound changes.

May also consider stiffening the large rear panel the rear by gluing/screwing a layer of MDF, but will try the easy and easily reversible changes first, as these are all just try it and see experiments to see if I can get these sounding to my particular tastes.

One final note, the grill covers that came with these may or may not be original, but are are not fabric and are made from some sort of nylon filaments. Feel like very thick fishing line and removing them is a big improvement that you might expect from moving a lawn chair or wicker basket out of the way, so had to bring the treble and mids down a good bit. Will have to seek out some better speaker cloth for these and maybe change those ferrite magnets over to neodymium so to improve the looks of the front baffles.
 
Last edited:
beyond polite level, the booming starts to show itself in greater abundance. At low levels with loudness on, these are fantastic. I just want these to be just as inert at the range above "polite" to just below "bad neighbor" as that's my listening range and I prefer a tighter overall bass (particularly mid-bass) presentation.
I think what you're observing as boom is actually the fault of the crossover. Briggs used the phase of the speakers to help flatten the audio. That trick works within limits but fails as the volume is increased as the woofer starts to dominate the mids and becomes somewhat "peaky" in that part of the spectrum. I don't see the dramatic boominess that you are talking about on my version of the W70Es. What I do hear is a bass peak around 37Hz. When I use the loudness button I have to dial the bass tone control back about -3db.
 
Thanks infullview. The kilmat arrived today, so will see if that helps or not. (unrelated aside, kilmat product origin is "Russian federation" - don't see that too often for branded stuff)

If that doesn't adjust the resonance I think I'm hearing, I'll try your crossover design out as the next step.

On another, note, perusing through the design handbook, I see Tygan as one of the approved grill protector materials. Perhaps those speaker grills are original, but they sure aren't acoustically transparent by comparison to modern fabrics and I wonder if that was part of the intended sound signature, a la the ls3/ls5s and some folks who prefer the muted effect of the material or perhaps the historic or nostalgic aspects of the material and sound. I don't like them so far, but, will try degreasing the existing 'cloth' and make a 2nd pair with a lighter modern fabric, using the old ones as a template to keep the originals intact. I found taking them off gave a much better sense of realness to the vocals in particular and an overall clearer sound.
 
Well jeez, that worked a charm! Perhaps my particular cabinet was somehow compromised, but I am very happy with the improvement!

Started with just the exterior bottom and back, so as not to lose any internal cabinet volume.

Also took the opportunity to use some double sided tape to lightly adhere the stand to the bottom as these are a bit of a pain to get lined up as they are so light and have pivoting legs, so everything moves around. This was a nice time (and back) saver. I do recall a PDF with construction instructions for the original Wharfedale legs that tilt back slightly, so may have to make a set of those sometime in the future.

Material was very easy to work with and cut with scissors.

kilmat.jpg

Not a subtle change by any means, a night and day difference. Did quell some of the bass and I had to further dial back the mids and a bit of treble, though the bass levels, while slightly reduced, has greater 'weight' and authority. I might describe the difference as follows:

Before: An abundance of bass, but the type that sort of vibrates hard objects all over the room that aren't secured. The room buzzes.

After: Cleaner bass and things aren't vibrating. A different, more focused and refined feeling of power. Rather than vibrating, if there's things moving on the walls, they've been knocked off, and you know exactly which beat in the song was the 'culprit.'​

The large rear panel on mine had a very hollow, echoing sound when rapped and now sounds similar to the smaller side and top panels. Decided to do the bottom as well, in case the wood speaker was coupling to the wood floors via the wood stand. After this picture, I also put some of the damping material on the hard plastic feet as well, just as a paranoid precaution.

Going to listen for a while and If I do need add'l damping, I'll start with the inside of the mid enclosure and sides, then top and bottom, but very, very happy with the sound so far. The woofers are inset almost 1/4" as to the surface of the front baffle, so I could double/triple up on the woofer frame gasket, using the original as a template to gain back some of the lost volume and might also try removing the temporary braces I put in, but we'll see.

The bass is much more controlled, much more like I remember the DMKIIs sounding and much, much more to my preference. Though, I can see how the resonance inherent in my speakers might be very appealing music that has a lot of wood and stringed instruments, adding a natural and euphonic like dimension to the sound for everything from oboe to guitar to grand piano.

Hopefully this is as far as I have to go, but will listen particularly closely and also particularly for jazz quartets and other 'wood heavy' types of music to see what I might be giving up there.

edit... as an early near term update. The added cleanliness of the sounds helped identify a couple of small problems that were masked earlier. First, I could hear a slight rattling from the left woofer and it turns out the cables were contacting the basket (prior owner extended the woofer leads about 6"- a welcome change as it greatly eased re-assembly). An easy fix gluing it down to the frame. Second, a couple of screws on one of the mids had rattled their way loose. A little light duty threadlocker and playing a Windham Hill record after these fixes, my respect for these speakers has drastically improved.... These are pretty darn good speakers and now I can really feel the bass 'hit' and pressurization of the room. The 15's now feel like 15s.
 
Last edited:
Hello, I am an absolute newbie, have never refurbished nor done any work with old audio equipment before. I do have some experience working with electrical equipment from my education though. Anyways, a while ago my partner and I inherited old speakers (I believe they are Wharfedale W60s) from my partners Grandma. Right now we are using them as end tables in our living room, but it has always been in the back of my mind that I would like to eventually use them as real speakers again some day, which has brought me here! I don't really have any idea of where to start though. So I guess I am just desperately looking for any kind of resource or guide that will get me started towards making these speakers work again. Thanks for any and all advice or help you might be able to give me.
 

Attachments

  • 20211230_174515.jpg
    20211230_174515.jpg
    92.1 KB · Views: 11
Back
Top Bottom