There's accurate bass and there is deep bass. I want my bass accurate in that I want a bass guitar to sound like a bass guitar. And you should be able to hear the difference between a Fender Jazz or Precision bass as opposed to a Chris Squire's Rickenbacker or Paul Mc Cartney's Hofner. And I don't want it confused with electronically produced bass from a synth or analog bass from a Fender Rhodes.
While a JBL 2235 15" goes lower than a 2241 18", the 18" with its accordion edge better reproduces real bass instruments in their timbre and overtones.
Listen to the Doors and while Ray is credited with playing bass on the Fender Rhodes, there are many times when a bass guitar player sat in and you should be able to hear a distinct difference.
———————————————————————-————————————-
So, these posts motivate me to reply on something that I have been thinking about since this thread started.
I think that
@Hobie1dog makes a good point. There could be posters here that simply like the bass in a particular song without giving much thought to “How low does it go”.
Then again, I like where
@toddalin is going with this as he too is correct in that there are those of us (myself included) that are looking for “accurate” sounds such that one can
really hear the differences between the
particular bass players (of which I am one), the
axes that they are using and in some cases the
actual amps that they are using (which tends to happen more on live stuff).
When I posted my original suggestions, I would like to believe that they were a combination of my comments above. I will add them again to provide context to my statements:
- Lou Reed: “Take a Walk on the Wild Side” (original recording or as close as you can get)
- Pink Floyd: “Dark Side of the Moon” (pick it!)
- Michael Jackson: “Thriller”
- Joe Jackson: “Look Sharp”
- Elton John: “Take me to the Pilot”
- Stanley Clark: pick it
- Earth Wind and Fire: Early albums
- Jefferson Airplane: opening track to “Bless its Pointed Little Head”
- The Who:”Who’s Next”, “Behind Blue Eyes”
- Clapton: “Let it Rain” or Bell Bottom Blues”
- Beatles: “Oh Darling”, “Taxman”, “Day Tripper”
- St. Saens Symphony No. 3 in C minor
- Toccata and Fugue in D minor
- Charles Mingus: early albums (if you can get remastered, a plus)