• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

6V6 SE build problem...

I think you said a while back that the amp was not oscillating when you had the OPT out of the chassis. Was that true? If true, that does lead one to the conclusion that it is lead dress related. And do you know at what frequency it's oscillating? I assume at this point you've tried grid stoppers on both 12AX7 grids, and screen stoppers on the output tube?

Have you tried clipping in an alligator lead directly on the first tube's grid to ground, just as a test to see if that first grid is picking up stray noise?

Finally, I assume it will stop oscillating if you only connect the second 12AX7 stage (meaning remove the first stage from the circuit)?
 
By the way, I had a EL84 (push pull) amp I built several years ago that would "squeg" (bursts of high frequency oscillation then settle, then burst again, etc., on a cycle of about twice a second). I put in 1K grid stoppers on grid #1 of the output tubes, and 470 ohm screen stoppers on the screens of the output tubes, and it killed that problem stone dead. I can't remember if it did this with or without the feedback though.
 
Gadget,,,
Exactly my thoughts,,, made some progress tho,,, Put a 1k on both grids of driver, 5.6k on 6V6 grid... PS readings are: 1st node(OPT) 346VDCV,,, 2nd (Scrn) 295VDC... The driver had 165-162V on the plates, However the amp had too much gain even on the lo input, so I reduced the driver Vp to about 120v but still has too much gain,,, distorts at about 3 on VC..., I'd like to see it get to 6-7 at least... Output tube Vp is 337v, and Scrn is 291, K is right at 18V,,,so its in the ballpark...
I tried it with a 12AT7 also,, read where some use the lower gain tube, and got some what less gain, actually closer to where I believe it should be...
I want to try to lower Vp to about 320V, and figure out why the FB (22K) has no effect at all...I think getting the FB to work properly would drop the gain to the sweet spot...
I ran a tape deck thru it for a couple hours, VC set low, and on the lo input, and tried the guitar thru all the PUPs, and both amp inputs,,, seems to distort too soon... but really sounds good with the VC set lo... doesn't distort as soon with the humbucker as it does thru the single PUPs... Its no wonder Zappa and the boys liked it, and guys are still building versions...
 
I think you said a while back that the amp was not oscillating when you had the OPT out of the chassis. Was that true? If true, that does lead one to the conclusion that it is lead dress related. And do you know at what frequency it's oscillating? I assume at this point you've tried grid stoppers on both 12AX7 grids, and screen stoppers on the output tube?

Have you tried clipping in an alligator lead directly on the first tube's grid to ground, just as a test to see if that first grid is picking up stray noise?

Finally, I assume it will stop oscillating if you only connect the second 12AX7 stage (meaning remove the first stage from the circuit)?

I bolted the OPT back, and removed it problem didn't change... I didn't short the 1st grid, but I may be passed that now! I was thinking of removing the 1st stage, and connecting the input to just one stage, like a typical audio power amp,,, but the grid stoppers seemed to kill the distortion....
 
By the way, I had a EL84 (push pull) amp I built several years ago that would "squeg" (bursts of high frequency oscillation then settle, then burst again, etc., on a cycle of about twice a second). I put in 1K grid stoppers on grid #1 of the output tubes, and 470 ohm screen stoppers on the screens of the output tubes, and it killed that problem stone dead. I can't remember if it did this with or without the feedback though.

Well, 6V6 screen stoppers are on my list of things to try!! I kinda deviated from "the list" when I got it running decent again!! I think my next major hurdle is getting the FB operating... mentioned what I tried so far in a previous post...
Thanks for the input!
 
Spent most of my "tube time" yesterday reading guitar amp forums, specifically about this 5F1 amp... seems some of the git gods used these for some recordings and they are still highly regarded, altho usually modified...
So I figured its time to follow suit! I ended up with 1k grid stoppers on both triodes,,, 5.6R grid stopper, and 1k screen stopper on the 6V6... Lowered both the 2nd triode, and 6V6 cathode caps to 22uf (may try even lower)... I went back to the first OPT I had tried, a smallish maybe 5W 6.6k/4R that seems to fit in pretty well, (its even mounted in place!!) One of the mods I was hesitant to try was replacing the 12AX7 with a 12AT7, which isn't necessarily a direct sub, but a couple resistor changes makes it work fine... Vp is 320VDC to K,,, screen is 290,,, and the driver is around 100v, down from 135 with the 12AX7....
I took out the FB resistor, and replaced it with a 25K pot, which the git gurus use to modify the tone, and distortion, which it does nicely... this little amp really has a distinct voice, and now can be turned up to 12 using the pot, and PU selection to determine where the distortion kicks in...
Now the biggest problem I have is where to put the pot!!! there's no room left in the chassis, and I already built the cabinet... thanks to everyone that contributed, so far... I get by with a little help from my friends!!!
Some fun, eh?
 
Not sure if this is helpful, but "Uncle Doug" has a series of educational videos on YouTube pertaining to the basics of vacuum tube operation and one of the series is the on the Fender Champ 5F1.
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="
" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Also, in this particular video, he talks about grid leak and grid stopper resistors: <iframe width="560" height="315" src="
" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
 
Not sure if this is helpful, but "Uncle Doug" has a series of educational videos on YouTube pertaining to the basics of vacuum tube operation and one of the series is the on the Fender Champ 5F1.<

Thanks for posting the links,,, I had seen some of his videos, didn't see the grid stopper/grid leak explanation tho... very clear and well done... since I figured out the problems with this amp yesterday, it made more sense when I watched it!!
My black cat, doesn't come near the work bench tho...
 
Glad you fixed the problem, @knockbill. I didn't realize these little guys can cause so much trouble! I've built a few Champ clones, but I always build the 5C1 because I love the sound of the pentode front end. I build them into 5F1-style cabinets, though :-). You can see an example of one that I still need to cover with tweed in my profile photo. The classic Champs are great.
 
In the PS? I have 10uF 1st, 47 2nd, and 22 or 33 (IIRC) 3rd,,, it hummed way too much with the stock values...

In my Champs, I always use 20, 20, and 8 for the filter caps. 20 is the rated max for 5Y3, and the only reason Leo used smaller is because high voltage electrolytics were expensive! Champs don't draw enough current to need anything bigger. I prefer the power supply topology of the 5C1 because the plate has an extra filter and thus less ripple. A properly-build 5C1 is hum free until you plug your Tele into it. \m/
 
The current being pulled thru the rectifier determines its cap rating more than anything else,,, book ratings are for maximum design... I used 10uF in the 1st stage cause its what I had, and fit in the cap can with the other two caps!! Generally, I've not experienced hum in my builds, it can usually be easily fixed, lead dress is very important... This amp is just about silent...

I'm currently working on a split chassis so the controls can be in the original position, but the amp can sit on the floor of the cabinet for better weight distribution (lower center of gravity), and to have more room to experiment with bigger speakers... so far, a Maggy 6x9" 4R speaker sounds great... still need to try 8" and 10" ...
Some fun , eh?
 
OK,, thanks,, I'll try one next time I see ya... Just got it back together, and connected to the new control panel,,, didn't think it worked at 1st, darn thing is dead quiet! FB brings on the distortion right about where it should be, and can adjust enough to run a CDP in the lo input with decent sounds... I'll try to draw up a modified schematic as it is now,,,, but the OPT seems to be the most important piece of the puzzle... I never saw an original a 5F1 amp, but this seems to be a pretty close cousin to what I read about it... Maybe I can get Clapton to audition it for me?
 
If you need some 12's, I've got a couple of 12" console pulls around here you're more than welcome to.

That's really the secret for getting big sound out of a Champ -- the speaker. I've build a couple as a head unit that are run into twin-12" cabinets with 98dB sensitivity Celestion speakers and holy cow they are loud.
 
I've tried a 12" and 6x9" so far... read where someone used 2x 6x9"s in a Champ cab and really liked it... I'm using a 4R OPT, so I figure a Maggy console speakers should work OK, worthy a try any way... Seems the 1st Champs used 6", 5F1 went to 8"....
 
That said, don't be afraid of using 8" speakers. I have two amps with "identical" speakers (Jensen C8Rs; Champ has 1 4 ohm speaker, the Magnatone 109 clone has 2 8 ohm speakers in parallel). The Magnatone circuit has much fuller low frequency (for guitar) response than the Champ. I'm not exactly sure why (the coupling caps in both are large enough to pass a decent amount of LF). Actually, cabinet could be having an impact here... my Magnatone cab is considerably larger
 
I'm of the "Apollo 11" school of design, use what ya got! I would expect the 2x 8" box to have a fuller, lower tone with the bigger cab and two speakers... An 8" (or 10") Jensen may be ideal, that's what Fender used here, have to see if I can find one.... I think Jensen worked at Magnavox before building his own speakers, that's why the 6x9 Maggy sounds right, I guess... I built the cabinet just large enough to fit a 12" if its not too deep and hits teh PT.... we'll see how it turns out!
Thanks for the input...
 
Here's a couple pics of it mounted in the cab, it still needs edges rounded, and sanded...
Ordered a 3/4" round over bit today...I cut out 2-3 speaker boards, and have enough grill cloth to cover them,,, still trying out speakers, to decide what will sound best... I'm thinking a pair of 6x9" or an 8", which I don't have, will work good here... I'll try the 12" Gadget has, when I get it...
PS,,, Typo should be Apollo 13 in last post..
 

Attachments

  • P9250001.JPG
    P9250001.JPG
    77.6 KB · Views: 23
  • P9250005.JPG
    P9250005.JPG
    62.7 KB · Views: 22
Think its possible P2P wiring is causing the oscillation? seems these were originally built on turret boards, with 20 or so long wires connecting to the switches, jacks, etc... I figured P2P would eliminate the long wires, and help with the oscillation problems I've read about with these amps, specially around the 12AX7s tight socket... another reason I'd rather use 6SL7's, if it will fit the chassis... Octals are easier to work with...
I'm thinking with two pre amp stages, these instrument amps are similar to a phono amps' high gain, and suffer the same build problems...
Didn't expect this to be a whole winter project!!!

Yep, the 6SL7 is a superior tube anyhow IMHO, and if you find some, the 6SU7 (which kicks ass will drop right in). 6SL7 are cheap and plentiful too, give me a shout if that's what you use and I'll turn you on to some "advice" umhu. :) BTW, that's beautiful man, check out that fricken lam stack on the PT, holy chit..
 
I agree,, I usually put 6SL7s in anything scratch built, save the 12AX7s for restores/rebuilds... I had this little Webcor chassis I used for this, and it was punched for a 9pin socket,so I used it! I may try again with the octal driver (6SJ7??) schem,,, don't know how they sound til ya try em!!!!
 
Back
Top Bottom