As indicated in posts # 3086 and # 3091 from last week, I’ve been playing with a pair of Paradigm PV-160 in wall/ceiling speakers as open baffles.
Yesterday I made up temporary cardboard baffles from a spare tri-fold display board. The board was 3’ tall, 4’ wide. I cut in half into two pieces each 1.5’ tall, and cut 7x10” rectangular hole in middle of center panel of each to fit the frame of the PV-160 speakers. Center panels are 2’ wide (~4x the width of the woofer). Wings are 1’ wide. As this is temporary, I used double-sided foam mounting tape to hold the speaker frames to the cardboard baffle. See photo below.
One issue I am unsure about using the PV-160s is that, as a ready-made 2-way wall/ceiling system, there is a frame surrounding the integral baffle the drivers are already mounted on, and this frame has a lip on it that stands about 5mm above the integral baffle (this lip helps to hold the removable grilles, and forms a flange for wall/ceiling mounting). The integral baffle plate and the cardboard baffle end up being co-planar, but that 5mm-tall lip stands between them. I don’t know if this has a sonic effect, but the fact that by the mid 1980s better speaker manufacturers were eliminating cabinet projections above the front baffle makes me think it might.
Anyway, playing them on the dining room table, as before (post # 3086), there was a significant change in the sound of the PV-160s with the added baffle. Much more of a resonant, full room-filling sound, with significantly increased lower frequencies, and overall louder. The change was noticeable when I first tried it with just one speaker fitted with a baffle, and increased with both done. The increased presence of the bass was such that at first I felt it was too pronounced, and perhaps somewhat flabby, and began wondering if I had acclimated too much to the baffle-less setup, but then I recalled I had left the bass tone control boosted from the prior setup. Once I returned that to flat, the balance was more natural. After more extended listening, I think there is still a little too much resonance/slop at lower frequencies, and from touching the baffle while playing, it seems the flimsy cardboard baffle might be contributing to it. That will presumably disappear with a proper build. Placement with the baffle directly on the table probably enhances bass response as well.
Next I moved them over to the living room where I have my main system is set up, where naturally I have more listening experience. Initially I tried placing them on chairs to elevate the drivers, but could not support the floppy baffle, so I had to place them on the floor, with only a modest separation, as shown in this photo. It is not ideal for dispersion, but it is what I could do with the space and limited time I had.
View attachment 1567186
I was able to play them along side a pair of DCM TW1s that you can see to the left and right of the Paradigm PV-160s. The TW1s are supplemented by a 10” NHT sub. Not a fair comparison, I agree, but I am very familiar with the sound of this system, so it was useful for me to compare it to the PV-160s. I fed each set up from a common source but different preamp/amp.
The PV-160s sounded quite good in this set up. They were quite transparent (simply disappeared) and played very sweetly. They were lacking in the lower bass in this room (but see further testing below). What I noticed most was that whereas the sound was fairly tightly localized in the space between them, they admirably filled the space behind them, creating a very pleasing fullness in the room. In comparison, the TW1s had a much broader presentation, with sound spread beyond the space between the speakers, but did not have the depth of sound field that the PV-160s displayed (i.e., the TW1s were more 2-dimensional in comparison). I take it that this is one of the major strengths of an open baffle.
As to the narrow presentation of the PV-160s, I did have them placed rather close together (as well as low on the floor); afterwards I moved the other speakers partly out of the way and separated the PV-160s further. With this, the breadth opened up very nicely (not as impressive as the TW1s, but that is their forte), but because the PV-160s no longer had as clear a shot to the wall behind them with this particular positioning, the illusion of depth behind the speakers was lessened.
Lastly, I hooked up the PV-160s to what was driving the TW1s, so they would have the benefit of a sub. I did not try to tune the sub to the PV-160s, just use it the way it was set for the TW1s in terms of overall level and crossover points (75Hz). The PV-160s now sounded much closer to a proper balance (or my perception of it), but some fuzziness/flabbiness at low freq was evident when there was a lot of low freq content. This likely has at least one if not two sources: the sub needs to be tuned properly to the PV-160s, and a sturdier baffle is needed.
Overall, I’m convinced that the excitement about open baffles is justified, even if the ones I’m working with at the moment are far from ideal. And I haven't even played around with overall size, wing size, or angle. I’m planning to build a better but smaller, modest-sized set of wood baffles for these sometime in the months ahead, for use in a smaller room, and see how it goes from there.
Many thanks to all contributors to this thread; it has been very informative and interesting.