Prices falling: The Tale Of Two Banks
- First Republic Bank
- Western Alliance Bancorp
The story of what happens when banks become "propping up schemes" for Tech and other sector start ups via their ties to venture capital (VC) institutions and willy-nilly back IPO and SPAC vehicles that go BOOM at the heights of a Free Money Party.
First, around November 2022, the NASDAQ plunged 30%, resulting in the collapse of dozens of IPO and SPAC vehicles whose VC backers "banked" @ (of course and by now famously) @ Silicon Valley Bank, but also suchfinancial services institutions as FIRST REPUBLIC BANK and WESTERN ALLIANCE BANCORP.
Here we are as of today -- Tuesday, 14 March 2023.
FIRST REPUBLIC BANK: P/S VALUE, Q1/2011 THROUGH 14 MARCH 2023 (7:10am Eastern)
Source: YCharts, 2023
COMMENT
Note that shares, currently at around $31, are back their level of 2013. Why? Because properly managed financial services institutions are intended to "serve" as government-regulated taxpayer-backed financial utilities ...
not as stock pumping schemes.
First Republic Bank is not a conservatively run bank. It represents
one of the worst excesses in the Free Money Party. Bank of America acquired FRB when it bought up Merrill Lynch, which had acquired it in 2007. In 2009, Bank of America sold FRB to a group of investors, most notably equity firms Colony Capital and General Atlantic, which sold FRB to the public via an IPO in December 2010. And so began the Free Money Party @ FRB.
WESTERN ALLIANCE BANCORP: P/S Q1/2011 THROUGH 14 MARCH 2023 (7:10am Eastern)
Source: YCharts, 2023
COMMENT
Note that shares, currently at around $28, are back where they’d been in 2014 and again, albeit briefly, in 2020. Why? Because -- again -- properly managed financial services institutions are intended to "serve" as government-regulated taxpayer-backed financial utilities ... not stock pumping schemes.
Western Alliance Bancorp is another magnificent stock-pumping font and proud member of the Free Money Party whose shares more than doubled between early 2020 and peaked in November 2021, after having multiplied by a factor of six since 2014. A bank stock. Where else to go
but DOWN?
The Big Watch: where are Bank Of America, CitiGroup, JPMorgan Chase, and Wells Fargo now?
As of 7:20am on Tuesday, 14 March, they are FOR THE DAY SO FAR:
What has JP Morgan / Chase "done right" -- thus far -- to have performed so well vis-a-vis the other Big Boys of the financial services sector?
One hunch is that they did not aggressively (read: willy-nilly) back VCs pushing IPO or SPAC vehicles for TECH and other sector start ups during the Free Money Party, maintained a more conservsative stance consistent with the traditional expectation that properly managed financial services institutions are intended to "serve" as government-regulated taxpayer-backed financial utilities ... not stock pumping schemes.
Another hunch is being based NOT in California also contributed to more sober institutional management.
* CITIGROUP, also
NOT based in California, ought to have followed JPM's example, eh?
PS: Dr. Paul Craig Roberts’ column today claims that
five “too big to fail” banks are holding $188 trillion in derivatives, twice the total GDP of the world.
Who runs these banks, the
Marx Brothers?