Use back-coated BASF or Agfa stock. Those tapes were the best in terms of wind uniformity. At AES shows we set up three Studer recorders with pancakes of BASF SM900, Ampex 499, and 3M 996 being fast wound forwards and backwards. The Ampex and 3M pancakes would fall off the recorders within 15 minutes or so. The SM900 (or SM911 when we ran that) stayed in place the entire day with a fairly decent wind even at the end of the day.
For storage purposes all tape is better wound at play speeds to avoid building up tension within a tape pack. Uneven winds are due to a combination of imprecise tape guidance, non -uniform winding speeds, non-uniform slitting, and--most of all--air trapped between the layers of the tape pack that is not allowed to escape at high winding speeds.