All things considered, mine doesn't look THAT bad ;-) Mine has some random "swirlies", scratches and dinged corners on the face but, like you said, 4+ feet away and all that disappears. Someone did inscribe their SSN on the bottom plate so I'm considering having the top and bottom covers powdercoated. I guess I'll wait for a reply from the eBay guy. BTW, is your faceplate engraved/stamped? I was surprised that mine was.