I remember hearing about an oil filter that uses a roll of toilet paper back in the 70s. I think it is still available, but never really took off. I am not sure how well it works, but some people swear by it. Seems like it would be cheaper than buying a new filter each time.Random thought: Have there been any major inventions that the public just refused to accept?
FrantzI remember hearing about an oil filter that uses a roll of toilet paper back in the 70s. I think it is still available, but never really took off. I am not sure how well it works, but some people swear by it. Seems like it would be cheaper than buying a new filter each time.
That some people would not instantly recognize this as a bad idea just proves that stupidity is not a modern invention.Frantz
Problem was no quality control in various toilet papers. Engine rebuilders reported finding paper fibers in engines.
One page article on the history of the oil filter... synopsis: invented in 1923 named Purolator, it was seven cotton twill covered perforated metal plates in a canister, that filtered only 10% of oil at a time. 1943- first paper/cellulose filter drop in canisters that filtered 100% of the oil, but nobody was building cars until after WWI ended, so they were not really available until 1946 . In 1954 Wix invented the spin on filter... not much change since then other than the type of filter media.Frantz
Problem was no quality control in various toilet papers. Engine rebuilders reported finding paper fibers in engines.
I remember it well. Usually, an extension hose was fitted from the original location of the oil filter up to the fender where the TP holder was installed for easy access. I saw actual cars with this installed. My guess would be....that it interfered with oil pressure requirements for some or many cars.I remember hearing about an oil filter that uses a roll of toilet paper back in the 70s. I think it is still available, but never really took off. I am not sure how well it works, but some people swear by it. Seems like it would be cheaper than buying a new filter each time.
I always assumed it was just an urban myth. But it turns out it is real: toiletpaperoilfilter.com It is a bypass setup where only some of the oil goes through this filter.I remember hearing about an oil filter that uses a roll of toilet paper back in the 70s. I think it is still available, but never really took off. I am not sure how well it works, but some people swear by it. Seems like it would be cheaper than buying a new filter each time.
I remember some years ago, hearing about the water canister. Electrodes from both sides of the battery are inserted into a canister of water to separate the hydrogen and oxygen. The hydrogen is fed to the engine. The claim is that this will cause all of the gasoline to be used/burned instead of only 20%. Theoretically, this should result in 5 times the fuel economy. So even if your car only gets 20 mph as is, it should get 100 mph with the canister. I had reservations, so I did some research. Gasoline burns at approximately 400° F. Hydrogen burns at 1100° F, at least according to the articles I read. So, immediately it occurred to me that the gasoline engine probably can't handle 1100° F. Sure enough, this was ruining engines and if one of these canisters was under the hood of your car, the dealer would void your warranty. Quite a few people added a canister to their cars without stopping to think and check it out first. So, you're right Wayne! Stupidly is nothing new. If I was planning to market such a product, I would test it on at least 5 vehicles I didn't care about for at least 2 years first. Only if all of the vehicles came through the test unharmed would I market the product.That some people would not instantly recognize this as a bad idea just proves that stupidity is not a modern invention.
I wonder how many people thought the automobile wouldn’t really make it when it was invented. There have been times when I was stopped in bumper to bumper traffic on an eight lane each direction freeway. I have pondered what someone like Henry Ford would think if he could come back to life for a day and see how many cars there are and how far they have advanced.Random thought: Have there been any major inventions that the public just refused to accept?
From the very little bit of reading I did, it looks like only a little oil at a time goes through the TP filter. This keeps the pressure up and allows it to clean over time.Maybe this is urban legend, but I heard that a TP filter DOES work. The problem is, it takes a lot of time, which in an engine depending upon constant and significant amount of oil flow for both lubrication and cooling, slow flow is bad, making the application unacceptable.
On the other hand, if you were to do a clean capture of the drained used oil, and passed it through a multi-staged TP filter, the oil would emerge as clean as it was when fresh. The other problem was with the worn out additives -which are trade secret and not available.
I recall seeing some time ago, refurbished motor oil for sale but that was back in the days of metal canned motor oil.
-k
You can't use Charmin, you have to use that industrial strength sandpaper type found in public restroom... There was a guy that owned the NAPA store in town and he used those rolls in the canister filter in his 1946 BuickFrom the very little bit of reading I did, it looks like only a little oil at a time goes through the TP filter. This keeps the pressure up and allows it to clean over time.
8 quarts of full syn 5W-30 isn't cheap. Throw in labor and it doesn't seem unreasonable.I paid $143 last week for an oil change on the Yukon. 8 qts of syn 5-30. Seemed like a lot. No extras.
I buy my Pennzoil Platinum Pure+ (or Mobile One) 5W-20 at Wally World for $24 for a 5 quart jug and change it myself. This oil costs $34 at O'Reillys and AutoZone8 quarts of full syn 5W-30 isn't cheap. Throw in labor and it doesn't seem unreasonable.

