• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Idler wheel "magic"...

Gusten,

I think you'd need a very high speed oscillographic recording to see the proposed slur or difference in attack and a lot of samples. Ideally I'd think using a idler drive turntable with an easily removeable drive belt and a high end external motor "pod" would be as apples and apples as you could get, provided the idler doesn't make contact with the platter in a neutral position.
 
The more complex a subject is the more we try to use our intuition in addressing it, sometimes it can work, sometimes not. The case of stylus drag contra instantaneous speed variations it´s not easy to visualize, at least not for me. One of the problems is the very high vinyl velocity effecting the stylus, and how the force vectors are pointing when tracing the groove at this very high speed.

Another thing is that groove angles are normally rather small, and even when tracing larger angles, everything happens very smoothly, there is no instantaneous change in vector forces or needle velocity, as I see it.

What one can see and feel, when trying in tracking test tracks with high amplitudes, is vibrations, nearly everything on the TT is heavily vibrating, at least on my TT. I suspect that really good heavy TTs make the difference in the respect.
gusten
 
The more complex a subject is the more we try to use our intuition in addressing it, sometimes it can work, sometimes not. The case of stylus drag contra instantaneous speed variations it´s not easy to visualize, at least not for me. One of the problems is the very high vinyl velocity effecting the stylus, and how the force vectors are pointing when tracing the groove at this very high speed.

Another thing is that groove angles are normally rather small, and even when tracing larger angles, everything happens very smoothly, there is no instantaneous change in vector forces or needle velocity, as I see it.

What one can see and feel, when trying in tracking test tracks with high amplitudes, is vibrations, nearly everything on the TT is heavily vibrating, at least on my TT. I suspect that really good heavy TTs make the difference in the respect.
gusten

Or very light TT's that let the vibrations dissipate quickly.

I guess the thing I have trouble visualizing is that there is enough resistance in the groove to slow down my reasonably heavy platter, the flywheel on my motor, and the motor itself of course, but not enough to rip the very small, fragile stylus from its mountings.
 
Or very light TT's that let the vibrations dissipate quickly.

I guess the thing I have trouble visualizing is that there is enough resistance in the groove to slow down my reasonably heavy platter, the flywheel on my motor, and the motor itself of course, but not enough to rip the very small, fragile stylus from its mountings.

I agree, this is very hard to visualize. As I see it, the rotational energy of a record itself, is enough to keep the record from slowing down, but it will vibrate.
gusten
 
I agree, this is very hard to visualize. As I see it, the rotational energy of a record itself, is enough to keep the record from slowing down, but it will vibrate.
gusten

I hear what you are saying.

But vibrations to the record and platter are apparently not an issue. If it was a major issue, then dd tables would be the worst sounding (motor directly coupled to the platter), idlers second worst and belt drives, where the motor is totally isolated, would be king. But it don't always work that way.
 
I hear what you are saying.

But vibrations to the record and platter are apparently not an issue. If it was a major issue, then dd tables would be the worst sounding (motor directly coupled to the platter), idlers second worst and belt drives, where the motor is totally isolated, would be king. But it don't always work that way.

I think vibrations is one of the the major issues with all TTs, if not the major. Neglectable vibrations would be what´s separate the good ones from the mediocre ones, IMO. I mean why does a 1200II sound like it does?
IME, it´s vibrations.

Regarding light weight TTs, IMO it doesn´t work as You say, a light TT will vibrate with higher amplitudes, but at different frequencies compared with a heavier one. The key parameter is how one deals with damping.
gusten
 
Last edited:
I think vibrations is one of the the major issues with all TTs, if not the major. Neglectable vibrations would be what´s separate the good ones from the mediocre ones, IMO. I mean why does a 1200II sound like it does?
IME, it´s vibrations.

Regarding light weight TTs, IMO it doesn´t work as You say, a light TT will vibrate with higher amplitudes, but at different frequencies compared with a heavier one. The key parameter is how one deals with damping.
gusten

I guess we are on the opposite side of this issue. I think the light weight Regas, at least P2/3 up, sound quick clean and dynamic, while the 1200 has impressive bass, with an otherwise, comparatively, dark and muddy sound.

But let's not turn this one into another technics vs Rega thread.
 
If you were to over-damp the Rega I would think that you'd would ruin it. It's designed to allow unwanted energy to quickly leave the system, with the thought that you aren't going to totally get rid of it so let it go away quickly. At least, that has always been my (possibly incorrect) assumption. The BBC thin-walled speakers are similar in approach. They do have a quick, musical sound to them.
 
I guess we are on the opposite side of this issue. I think the light weight Regas, at least P2/3 up, sound quick clean and dynamic, while the 1200 has impressive bass, with an otherwise, comparatively, dark and muddy sound.

But let's not turn this one into another technics vs Rega thread.

I wouldn´t dream of it. I guess I just mean it´s not obvious for many why there is a difference between some TTs, and an intuitive thinking might give the wrong answers.
gusten
 
If you were to over-damp the Rega I would think that you'd would ruin it. It's designed to allow unwanted energy to quickly leave the system, with the thought that you aren't going to totally get rid of it so let it go away quickly. At least, that has always been my (possibly incorrect) assumption. The BBC thin-walled speakers are similar in approach. They do have a quick, musical sound to them.

Exactly.

There was an interview with Roy Gandy about that. I'll see if I can dig that up.
 
Arkay, welcome back! You stated this:You won't ruin it running it a bit over-voltage, but it will last longer if you run it at (or nearer) the correct voltage. Most motors are safe to run within 10-20 percent over voltage, and you may get a bit of a performance boost (a little higher torque), depending upon the motor, but they will break down faster that way. I'd suggest running it at the recommended voltage, for best results overall. Using a step-down transformer would also add a bit of noise isolation and cleaner power, which won't hurt.

If I am getting a boost it might leave when I started using the step down voltage converter, or in other words the motor not spin up to speed enuf after being boosted so long, lol

And on the other hands I might have to fight hum induced by the converter. ,god how I hate fighting hummers>

Years of experience kinda tells me that the latter is more probable than everything will be ok with the voltage converter

I really don't think that having been "overdriven" for a long time will make one whit of difference, if you now decide to drive it with the intended voltage. Not one teensy bit; it will not suddenly run too slowly; it will simply run at the intended speed, with the correct voltage input. I might suggest putting a variac in the circuit, and adjusting the voltage that way. (Just be sure you never bump the variac control knob, and suddenly send 300V surging through it! :D)

So, hypothetically, would putting a magnetic eddy current loading on the rim of the non-ferrous alloy platter accomplish the same sort of dynamic loading as the idler? This is do-able with a couple of properly aligned scarce dirt super-magnets.

Should be do-able. For a pretty easy-to-understand explanation of the principle involved: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddy_current_brake

It might be a mistake to assume this is the same as the idler, though: it would be testing only the respects in which it IS similar to an idler wheel. IF, for example, the effect of the idler was due to some kind of mechanical damping, then the eddy current brake would not have the same effect. But the brake would put drag upon the platter at a much higher level than stylus drag, which would render the stylus drag effects relatively insignificant. But that's the whole purpose of doing this experiment, isn't it(?) - to find out what is, and what isn't, causing the results we hear with idler wheels.
 
But let's not turn this one into another technics vs Rega thread.

Why not? I still have some popcorn left...

Now, getting back to the discussion, i am not really convinced by the "dynamic stylus drag" theory. Not with a half-decent turntable with a platter of 2.0kg or more and a half-decent motor. I wish it was true, that's why i called for tests to be made on the PFM forum thread.

As for light plinths to make the resonances dissipate quickly, i'd say this is true but a bit misleading. Probably with a light plinth the resonant response to a hammer tap would be brief (= dissipates quickly), but pronounced (=strong). While a heavy and dense plinth will have a much much much more damped response (=weak resonance), even if in theory the resonance is lasting longer. Exactly the same as a cartridge with a strong LF resonance peak versus the same cartridge in an arm with fluid damping.

As for the "(plinth) damping kills the sound" claim made often in forums by many people, i always thought that was plain nonsense (i don't mean to offend anybody). What could 'kill' the sound is a lack of rigidness in the coupling between the tonearm pivot and the turntable bearing, and i think that most TT designers would agree with me. That's why the guys at Rega are now including a steel plate that couples both on some of their newer models. That's why the armboard choice is crucial on TTs with removable armboards.

You want a lot of rigidity but damping for the resonances. Just like when you design a tonearm.
 
Last edited:
Why not? I still have some popcorn left...

Now, getting back to the discussion, i am not really convinced by the "dynamic stylus drag" theory. Not with a half-decent turntable with a platter of 2.0kg or more and a half-decent motor. I wish it was true, that's why i called for tests to be made on the PFM forum thread.

As for light plinths to make the resonances dissipate quickly, i'd say this is true but a bit misleading. Probably with a light plinth the resonant response to a hammer tap would be brief (= dissipates quickly), but pronounced (=strong). While a heavy and dense plinth will have a much much much more damped response (=weak resonance), even if in theory the resonance is lasting longer. Exactly the same as a cartridge with a strong LF resonance peak versus the same cartridge in an arm with fluid damping.

As for the "(plinth) damping kills the sound" claim made often in forums by many people, i always thought that was plain nonsense (i don't mean to offend anybody). What could 'kill' the sound is a lack of rigidness in the coupling between the tonearm pivot and the turntable bearing, and i think that most TT designers would agree with me. That's why the guys at Rega are now including a steel plate that couples both on some of their newer models. That's why the armboard choice is crucial on TTs with removable armboards.

You want a lot of rigidity but damping for the resonances. Just like when you design a tonearm.

Exactly! To make a lightweight TT it needs to be cleverly made, but there is no benefit per se, as I see it. A heavier that is cleverly made is better.
gusten
 
Since sanity and logic have returned to the thread and my posted comment responded, I'm back to contribute.
First, resonance management is paramount to getting a good uncolored and detailed result. I think it the major factor in perceived differences between TTs and the thrust of my H-K mod project. Bill Firebaugh's Well-tempered arm and TT are the exemplary expression of resonance management over sheer mass and absolute rigidity.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Pio1980;
"So, hypothetically, would putting a magnetic eddy current loading on the rim of the non-ferrous alloy platter accomplish the same sort of dynamic loading as the idler? This is do-able with a couple of properly aligned scarce dirt super-magnets.
Should be do-able. For a pretty easy-to-understand explanation of the principle involved:

Arkay responds;

"http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddy_current_brake
It might be a mistake to assume this is the same as the idler, though: it would be testing only the respects in which it IS similar to an idler wheel. IF, for example, the effect of the idler was due to some kind of mechanical damping, then the eddy current brake would not have the same effect. But the brake would put drag upon the platter at a much higher level than stylus drag, which would render the stylus drag effects relatively insignificant. But that's the whole purpose of doing this experiment, isn't it(?) - to find out what is, and what isn't, causing the results we hear with idler wheels."

Me;
The point exactly, and without the rumble potential of the freewheeling idler. I still agree wholeheartedly with Arthur Salvatore on the advantage of a properly realized idler drive independent of what-ever rim damping may or may not be also taking place which can be done effectively by other means. The combo of the mat and record should accomplish this in reality and often does. Changing out the mat is a coloration crapshoot without keeping platter damping in mind in many cases of a potentially ring-y platter. Ring-resonance testing without a record on the mat is invalid. I think that modulation-loaded belt-drive pitch droop can be an audible reality with extended heavily modulated mid-bass-rich passages, platter speed recovers during the following quieter passages.
 
Last edited:
Why not? I still have some popcorn left...

Now, getting back to the discussion, i am not really convinced by the "dynamic stylus drag" theory. Not with a half-decent turntable with a platter of 2.0kg or more and a half-decent motor. I wish it was true, that's why i called for tests to be made on the PFM forum thread.

As for light plinths to make the resonances dissipate quickly, i'd say this is true but a bit misleading. Probably with a light plinth the resonant response to a hammer tap would be brief (= dissipates quickly), but pronounced (=strong). While a heavy and dense plinth will have a much much much more damped response (=weak resonance), even if in theory the resonance is lasting longer. Exactly the same as a cartridge with a strong LF resonance peak versus the same cartridge in an arm with fluid damping.

As for the "(plinth) damping kills the sound" claim made often in forums by many people, i always thought that was plain nonsense (i don't mean to offend anybody). What could 'kill' the sound is a lack of rigidness in the coupling between the tonearm pivot and the turntable bearing, and i think that most TT designers would agree with me. That's why the guys at Rega are now including a steel plate that couples both on some of their newer models. That's why the armboard choice is crucial on TTs with removable armboards.

You want a lot of rigidity but damping for the resonances. Just like when you design a tonearm.

I'm trusting Roy Gandy on this one. Because I've actually spent some time listening to the results.

Same reason that I'm not going to throw out the possibility that Salvatore is right about the idler effect. It 'seems' complete nonsense to me given the respective forces involved, but I've not heard one of these tables myself so I'll defer to those who have and trust that they're hearing something amazing just like they say.
 
Seems to me we have some that believe the instantaneous drag effect is real, some think it can´t happen that way and some that are leaving the door open.

Actual proof is what is needed, I think.
gusten
 
It's not instantaneous in a resilient belt drive, it's a slow effect of the momentum of the platter being affected against the resilience of the belt. "String" and tape drives should behave more as idlers in this respect and not exhibit modulation induced pitch droop.
 
Seems to me we have some that believe the instantaneous drag effect is real, some think it can´t happen that way and some that are leaving the door open.

Actual proof is what is needed, I think.
gusten

I just need to hear it for myself. There's no "proof" for me of anything in this hobby. My ears have called BS on pretty much every spec out there, as long as a basic threshold of competence was reached.
 
It's not instantaneous in a resilient belt drive, it's a slow effect of the momentum of the platter being affected against the resilience of the belt. "String" and tape drives should behave more as idlers in this respect and not exhibit modulation induced pitch droop.

There are several explanations why this 'drag' should be an audible effect. Sometimes it´s very short transients, sometimes it´s a longer term effect. It doesn´t matter in principle, nothing is proven, and intuition doesn´t prove it, it´s speculations. Nothing wrong with that, but the issue is not getting clearer by guessing.
gusten
 
Back
Top Bottom