• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Idler wheel "magic"...

Why not? Why isn't it necessary to demonstrate the existence of a speed defect before discussing it's importance? The actual phenomenon --if any-- might be unrelated to drive type.
 
If a rock is tumbling down a mountain side, the friction from the air is going to have a miniscule effect on it's fall compared to the same rock tumbling in a vacuum. Perhaps so small that an observer would never visually notice a difference and perhaps the difference would be something that could be measured. You can debate whether or not the friction made a perceivable difference in the rate of the fall. You can't debate that it had an effect. Very clearly, it has. Adding even a 1/1000 of the resistance of stylus drag will have some effect on the speed. I'm very much of the opinion from my experience that the stylus drag is an effect below the threshold of human hearing, however, that doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
 
My Trio 350 uses a oil wick resovoir system to oil the motor bearings. Has anyone else seen this kinda system for turntable motors before?
 
So the drag effect exists to some theoretical extent. What if I assert it is worse on idler turntables. How are you going to prove me wrong without doing measurements?
 
I think John's point is that the amount of friction will remain the same regardless of drive type. What you are seeking out is the measurements comparing the effect of that friction on different drive types. I suspect there is a way to measure it, I'd have to give some thought to how you could isolate a measurement to really show the differences.
 
This might be heresy, but at some point we all have to decide what is:

neg·li·gi·ble/ˈneglijəbəl/
Adjective:
So small or unimportant as to be not worth considering; insignificant.
Synonyms:
insignificant - trifling - trivial - inconsiderable

Even if there's zero perceptible dynamics induced groove drag, delay, pitch error (whatever you want to call it) in the drive system there will be some in the cartridge. There isn't an infinitely accurate transducer that's going to reproduce those dynamics perfectly. Of course the cutting lathe isn't infinitely capable of taking a bigger bite of the mastering blank so there will also be a difference between the mastering disk and the input signal. So how far do you go chasing the perfect playback of an imperfect facsimile of the original signal? At some you just have to listen to the music instead of the system. As somebody said once their system gets out of the way that's enough and then they are there. Anything beyond that is negligible.
 
I assume the amount of friction is not affected by drive type. It never occurred to me otherwise.
I assumed what would be measured would be speed fluctuations.
 
I think variations in the drive system, issues with the pressing (off center records), bearings, etc are all probably going to contribute to speed variation in a stronger fashion than the stylus sliding through the groove. Just a guess on my part.
 
I assume the amount of friction is not affected by drive type. It never occurred to me otherwise.
I assumed what would be measured would be speed fluctuations.

The wording of the question had me confused, in referring to the friction instead of the effect of the friction. It does seem to me that it should be measurable.
 
Salvatores´explanation is his intuitive explanation for something he thinks addresses a difference between drive systems. That doesn´t mean this is a fact. Instantanious drag is very hard to picture as it´s in 3D and the question is if there are forces other than friction forces when playing music instead of just playing a silent groove.
If these are significant they would show up in a test of platter spin down time between silent groove and a heavy music groove. I have not seen this in the few tests I have done, but I´m not sure, maybe this should be tested more.
gusten
 
...It does seem to me that it should be measurable.

This was big hoopla in the (positive) marketing of the direct drive tables, although I have a strong feeling there are plenty of belt drive and idler drive tables that perform equally as well.

I've translated some Japanese sites, and among some groups, this was a big topic and something they tested, and paid attention to.

I wish I could add more- but according to some japanese audiophile sites (and some manufacturers), it's both important and measurable.


Honestly, I personally am not up at night worried or concerned about it. But some circles are!
 
Okay, I'm only tossing this in here because I'm familiar with this particular model.

Technics claimed their SP10MK2 (and possibly the lesser models) would not be affected by stylus drag of 500 cartridges at 2g VTF. That's 1000g, or 2.2lb.

Some European sites discuss converting SP10MK2 tables to cutting lathes.

The Lathetrolls website:
http://lathetrolls.phpbbweb.com/

The SP10MK2 as lathe:
http://lathetrolls.phpbbweb.com/lathetrolls-post-15241.html
 
If stylus drag is a real phenonenon, it should be incredibly easy to measure.

I have posted a possible method to measure dynamic stylus drag on the PFM thread. It requires a turntable with two arms. Moreover, many turntable with dual arms, an idler drive one, belt drive, etcetera, to be able to compare.
 
Oooh, this thread has taken some interesting turns since I last visited. In an attempt not to write another "book", I'll make a few comments:





I'm only making that comparison because its the kind of thing that comes up in these discussions. "All belt drives have XX problem" and so forth. No, they don't all have XX problems. I think every drive system is capable of sounding similar if not indistinguishable from another depending on the context.
...

Oh, YES THEY DO ALL have certain problems. Those problems are not insurmountable, and engineers have worked out ways around them, sufficient to lead to the second part of your statement that every system is capable of sounding similar, if not indistinguishable. No drive system is perfect; they all have some (albeit different) problems. It's how you compensate for those problems, the compromises you make, that can make them all sound similar in the end.

That doesn't mean, however, that you have completely overcome the problems. Sometimes you've solved one, but there may remain a problem that another system addresses better. For example, the "flywheel effect" of a large platter goes a long way to overcome the potential for "stretch and rebound" (basically, "cogging"!) sound of a belt drive... but momentum isn't quite the same thing as torque, over time in the real world.

I think there's also a danger in interpreting differences as improvements. When sometimes, they're just differences. You could start at either end point, and think an improvement has been made when you arrive at the other option.

This is very true. Salespeople know this, and set those U-shaped equalization curves to make gear sound more "exciting" to shoppers. It isn't really better, but most people will think so. This is also a reason --beyond actual changes in gear-- why we should allow a "break in period" before writing reviews, unless we are clear up-front that we are only giving initial impressions. Initial impressions are often skewed, because we focus on what is "new and different" to us, which we may like, but often ignore other, equally important things in the process.

This a a slice from Arthur Salvatore's reference components section on his web site. ....


Effective Torque- The Idler-Drive's Unique and Ultimate Advantage
A well-designed and executed idler-drive has more effective torque (ET)* than any other type of drive system. It's that simple....
Effective torque, in effect, is required to properly "initiate" a musical note (or passage). Since a continual stream of new notes must appear while the LP is being played, adequate ET is a necessity at all times. Without the proper amount of ET, the sound will vary, depending on the amount, and type, of notes (resistive changes) coming into play (as various physical changes in the groove). It's this variance, or musical inconsistency (distortion), which good idler-drives diminish better than any other design.

Marc mc

I basically agree with AS on this. If you read the rest of that section, he pretty much isolated nearly all other variables in multiple tests using otherwise-identical gear, before reaching this conclusion. Not 100 percent scientific, but close. I did something similar, and came to a very similar conclusion, although I had a few other considerations and still have one (perhaps two, not sure yet) other possibilities to test.


I think Mr. Salvatore needs to learn a bit about drive systems and motors.

Why do you say that, specifically? I found a few possible nits to pick in his process of reaching his conclusions, but I didn't think this kind of ignorance was really a factor (in fact, it might have been a benefit -?). His conclusions were based on keeping all else equal, and paring away until he was left with this. He got there against his initial skepticism, and by a fairly astute (albeit not perfect) process of elimination, even using the same motor in two different type systems, to eliminate differences due to, say, "cogging" in the motor.

If Arthur Salvatore's can back or has backed up what he is saying with truthful testing then we can assume what he is saying could be true but does he have proof is all I want to know.

Do read his full text on his website, not just the extract above. He deals with a lot of the other questions or issues, and explains how he reached that conclusion. The process may not be perfect, and I believe some additional experiments are needed to "prove" it, but I also believe that, in essence, he is correct. My own experiments point at the same thing, although I went through a different process, and also do not (yet) have "proof".

There is also a lot of common-sense logic to back it up, if you think about the sonic differences being widely perceived that are "characteristic" of idler-wheels vis-a-vis most others, and what is actually happening within the materials and at the stylus-groove interface.

I'll see if I can come up with a good way to explain without confusing the issue anymore. The stylus drag that Salvatore references is something that would be a real phenomena. During dynamic passages of music, there would be more drag than something that wasn't dynamic. We are talking *very* miniscule changes in speed but some claim to be sensitive to miniscule speed variations. So how do you combat it? With a heavy platter like many turntables use, you are reducing the magnitude of the speed variation, but making the variation last longer. With a lighter platter, you have more magnitude of variation but with shorter periods. Designers who prefer both exist, which is subjectively better will likely depend on the listener. The other approach is to add more torque to the drive system (regardless of type) but then you have to deal with a compromise. Increased torque = increased cogging effect so there is a balance that has to be considered. Another balance is with the amount of compliance present between the drive system and the platter. A rubber belt will have more compliance than most idlers, but some idlers will have more compliance than a tape belt or one of the string drives systems. No matter what, you are forced to pick your poison.

I mentioned using an eddy brake earlier to stabilize speed. It's an excellent way of effectively dominating the effects of stylus drag by making the overall drag orders of magnitude higher than stylus drag, with a huge majority of that drag coming from a very consistent source rather than a variable one.


Basically, I completely agree with what you say, but there is one statement that needs further examination and consideration, when put into practice: " Increased torque = increased cogging effect so there is a balance that has to be considered." First of all, does increased torque ALWAYS HAVE TO mean increased cogging, or are there aspects of motor design that can create motors with higher torque, yet not so increased cogging? Are the two automatically inversely related, and is that a straight-line inversion? Secondly, what happens to the "cogging effect", as the motion is transmitted? Do, for example, idler wheels or belt drives transmit the "cogs" to the same degree, or in the same way?

I do agree with the logic of an eddy brake. It is one good way to reduce the relative significance of stylus drag effects, and a better way than relying upon the momentum of a flywheel (which doesn't work quite as well as one might wish).

How about a relatively high-torque motor, one with minimal cogging, using a well-designed idler wheel AND an eddy brake, with a decent platter and a massive plinth designed for vibration dissipation? How about a precisely- and rigidly-fixed tonearm, again with proper vibration controls? Might be heading in the right direction here, towards that dream "giant killer"...
 
Last edited:
I'll see if I can come up with a good way to explain without confusing the issue anymore. The stylus drag that Salvatore references is something that would be a real phenomena. During dynamic passages of music, there would be more drag than something that wasn't dynamic. We are talking *very* miniscule changes in speed but some claim to be sensitive to miniscule speed variations. So how do you combat it? With a heavy platter like many turntables use, you are reducing the magnitude of the speed variation, but making the variation last longer. With a lighter platter, you have more magnitude of variation but with shorter periods. Designers who prefer both exist, which is subjectively better will likely depend on the listener. The other approach is to add more torque to the drive system (regardless of type) but then you have to deal with a compromise. Increased torque = increased cogging effect so there is a balance that has to be considered. Another balance is with the amount of compliance present between the drive system and the platter. A rubber belt will have more compliance than most idlers, but some idlers will have more compliance than a tape belt or one of the string drives systems. No matter what, you are forced to pick your poison.

I mentioned using an eddy brake earlier to stabilize speed. It's an excellent way of effectively dominating the effects of stylus drag by making the overall drag orders of magnitude higher than stylus drag, with a huge majority of that drag coming from a very consistent source rather than a variable one.

Thanks for this post. Curious as to: "increased torque=increased cogging" is this true of all potential drive motor types? Aren't there some tables using magnetic drives now? Are they in any way impervious to this effect? Sorry if veering to far off course here...
 
I cut the tiny excerpt from Arthur's idler findings because I figured it was the only way any points would be read. I should point out that when dealing with Arthur and his audio process, you should understand that his circle of audiophile friends and colleagues is off the charts and their gear is staggering. I mean consider that Sonic Frontiers was founded by employees of his.

As for a test I saw it done. I said in an earlier post that I was at a TT clinic that had a measuring device that gave a printout of stylus drag. I found it made sense when you had a bunch together because they all showed variations at points where simple and complex passages were played on the test record. But what I now understand is those changes have a continuous and detrimental effect on sounds. I also remember the guy saying that a TT must run a bit quick (33.8) if memory serves. The reason was that the stylus would be slowed by complex passages and if it was simply at (33.3) then that slowing would be noticed. So the test also tracked speed and as I remember 80% of the tables all ran fast and the ones that ran slower ( still faster than 33.3 ) were considered to not be as good to face those passages.

I noticed that the focus seems to be from the motor side of things. And how minuscule stylus drag and the effect on speed variations would be in comparison. But I don't think that way, I think of how small the groove modulations are and how easy it would be for that detail to be altered. I personally felt that massive platters, inertia, elaborate suspensions, isolation tables and keeping the motor seperate was far more than enough for the job. But the simple fact for me is I can say without exception that what Arthur is talking about is audible to a good old fashion pair of ears on a Lenco with competent arm and decent cartridge.

BTW I don't think the guys at Lenco were the cutting edge trying to make the best TT in the world. I don't think they factored things like stylus drag into their equations. I don't think they ever understood what they had really done. If they had they never would have done everything else the way they did.
Marc mc
 
Last edited:
Oh, YES THEY DO ALL have certain problems. Those problems are not insurmountable, and engineers have worked out ways around them, sufficient to lead to the second part of your statement that every system is capable of sounding similar, if not indistinguishable. No drive system is perfect; they all have some (albeit different) problems. It's how you compensate for those problems, the compromises you make, that can make them all sound similar in the end.
You seem to be talking theory and I'm talking execution. Yes, in theory, all drive systems have their own issues. In practice, I've heard many ways in that sounded good enough for my purposes. Is one more perfect than another? In some slight way to a particular person's taste, quite possibly.
 
But is it slight and are all points equal?

I remember the guys on the speaker forum talking about using multiple subs. At the time I had a number of subs doing different things but I had always felt that using 2 subs was good and adding more would make a mess of things. But with much prodding I finally tried 4 subs and to my shock discovered that the mids and highs is where I noticed the improvement. So what I thought would make a small difference has turned out to be anything but a slight advantage.

Here is another section of Arthur's article.

First, you must think of the original stock Lenco, even if it's still in mint condition, as a "jalopy". However, this particular jalopy has an unexpected fluke, which takes it far out of the ordinary. For some unknown reason, the manufacturers decided to use a Formula One racing engine and drive train! Of course, this engine is completely wasted if no "modification" is ever made to the rest of the car, but all that matters to us is that a modification is possible. It's just a question of what modification will fully optimize that outstanding engine. Still, we must never forget that this automobile, without any change, will always be a jalopy, regardless of its engine etc.

In effect, when you purchase a stock Lenco, you must only look at its basic drive system, platter and bearing, and forget all the rest, because it will be eventually replaced. (Like Michaelangelo "seeing" David "imprisoned" in the huge piece of marble, and then carefully removing all the "excess".) In short, when you purchase a stock Lenco (or any other vintage idler-drive turntable), you are also making a long-term commitment to take the necessary measures for it to reach its fullest potential, at the least possible expense, in time and money. Without that commitment, you have nothing special, a common mediocrity at best, while its dormant potential is relegated to the theoretical and the irrelevant.


Marc mc
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom