• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Idler wheel "magic"...

Plus 1, Ray is the king. All hail Ray.

That's really not necessary. Please rise. :D

For years I've daydreamed about a hydraulic drive platter with hydrostatic suspension and possibly a hydrostatic bearing. It would be gravity fed relying on just the total dynamic head of the pump storage reservoir. The control system would be nothing more than a fixed orifice. Theoretically nothing would/could be simpler or deliver contant torque more stably than an incompressible liquid and gravity. Admitted this design would not work in space. Maybe I should have been a ME instead of an EE?

A few pages back I suggested that Newman use a hydrodynamic drive. That's basically what I was talking about. :thmbsp:
 
This may not come as any surprise to anyone, but I've also considered a hydrodynamic drive. Not with any sort of seriousness, but kind of have it planned out in my head. My DIY turntable is a big enough project, as is.
 
Just got through doing a mat mod I have been wanting to do. I am using that rubberized open cell kitchen shelf material that others have been using. I can only say I am shocked that a 4 dollar mod could do that much for 3 different tables with different drive systems
 
I wish you guys would stop talking about how great idler TTs are, prices are high enough as it is.
 
As for a test I saw it done. I said in an earlier post that I was at a TT clinic that had a measuring device that gave a printout of stylus drag. I found it made sense when you had a bunch together because they all showed variations at points where simple and complex passages were played on the test record.

What turntable was it? I hope it wasn't a Rega RP1 turntable but something with a decent motor and platter.

Would you care to elaborate more please? This is interesting.
 
Cogging is frequency driven, not pole driven. If you put 24 poles in there and drive at 60hz, it will have the same amount of cogging as a 4 pole motor running at 60hz.

This is not correct at all. Quite the opposite, there are formulas to compare potential cogging of a motor based on the number of poles and slots that you want to use (search "cogging least common denominator".)

There are many factors that influence cogging, for example the inertia of the moving system, the hysteresis effects on the rotor, the operating torque of the motor, and yes, the amount of poles and slots in the motor. Some types of motors, like the shaded pole induction motor, or the hysteresis synchronous motor, have dramatically inferior levels of cogging than a straight synchronous motor operating at the same freq and with the same number of poles. Most powerful idler drive tables use the induction motor, btw.

I don't know where do you found the information you are repeating above. If it was from an specific web page please point it out, because it is not correct.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure I buy that this is the only explanation. When I read it, my conclusion is that it's very likely not the explanation. I'll re-read and see if I am just missing something.

I agree. There is something more important that changes the sound. However small or better or worse the sound may be. Idler drive tts sound different. The reason is not torque. Will elaborate tonight.
 
This is not correct at all. Quite the opposite, there are formulas to compare potential cogging of a motor based on the number of poles and slots that you want to use (search "cogging least common denominator".)

There are many factors that influence cogging, for example the inertia of the moving system, the hysteresis effects on the rotor, the operating torque of the motor, and yes, the amount of poles and slots in the motor. Some types of motors, like the shaded pole induction motor, or the hysteresis synchronous motor, have dramatically inferior levels of cogging than a straight synchronous motor operating at the same freq and with the same number of poles. Most powerful idler drive tables use the induction motor, btw.

I don't know where do you found the information you are repeating above. If it was from an specific web page please point it out, because it is not correct.

Maybe I didn't add enough caveats into my response. For a typical AC synchronous motor used on turntables, the cogging is frequency driven. If I have a 4 pole AC sync 2 phase motor, it will cog half as often per revolution as an 8 pole motor, however, it's running twice as fast, so over the same period of time, the cogging remains the same.

You are correct that different motors types handle cogging differently and I should have been more specific. Induction motors are a different story, but one interesting thing about induction motors is they exhibit a lot of slip. Which very likely reduces cogging, but the stators inducing the poles on the rotor are always in a state up catching up. I've seen a number of induction motors rated at 1740-1750 RPM on a 4 pole motor. 50-60RPM of slip.
 
I feel at a disadvantage from most others in this room as I am running solid state and I know a lot of you are running tube equipment, which if I had the bucks I would have also. I know tubes generate a very real warmth to the sound , so when I get my system sounding almost tube like by tweeking my tables I am a happy camper.:banana:
 
dnewma44 you stated above: I've seen a number of induction motors rated at 1740-1750 RPM on a 4 pole motor. 50-60RPM of slip.
My question is did they slow down to reflect that 50 rpm decrease and make the sound effected in any way?
And by slipping you mean completely dropping those rpm or wavering between 1800 and 1750?
 
Last edited:
What turntable was it? I hope it wasn't a Rega RP1 turntable but something with a decent motor and platter.

Would you care to elaborate more please? This is interesting.

Well around 1987 a store just north of me run by a friend held a TT clinic. He sold Oracle, Kef, Bryston etc. the Clinic was most of the day and basically you brought your own table from home and hooked it up to this unit the size of a large suitcase. The clinic was put on by Ortofon if memory serves. I also knew the guy doing the clinic he had had been a Linn dealer here in town.

They played a test record that was sweeps and combinations of frequencies for around 10 minutes and this suitcase gave a printout that showed what the table was doing at all the checkpoints. Honestly it sort of reminded me of a lie detector. But when we compared everyone's at the end it was clear that not all the tables (there was around 30 tables and there was no junk) behaved the same. The thing that I clearly remember was the understanding that belt drives (which I think everyone was) all were suppose to run fast, and you could clearly see the points that the speed dipped when complex or deep bass passages were played.

Marc mc
 
Completely dropping them. Sometimes they include built in eddy current brakes to stabilize the speed at the published specs. They'll be consistently at 1740 RPM, for instance and the idlers get appropriately sized.
 
I feel at a disadvantage from most others in this room as I am running solid state and I know a lot of you are running tube equipment, which if I had the bucks I would have also. I know tubes generate a very real warmth to the sound , so when I get my system sounding almost tube like by tweeking my tables I am a happy camper.:banana:

Tubes need not produce a warm sound, that is often times a design choice.
 
If we look at stylus drag, the largest instantaneous drag would be when stylus is on the onset of mistracking. This happens normally when trying to cope with torture test tracks to test trackability. Then the drag is about the same as the VTF for a very short time, I think.

But when I look at the energy needed for this and compare the energy available only by the record itself, I cannot see that it could slow down the speed even 0.01%. It would be, as I see it, far too small variation to be significant. And then normally we can add the energy from platter, mat and drive system.

I will see if I could do a test with a torture track and compare to a silent groove.
gusten
 
Things like cogging and drag are clearly factors to be considered by engineers, else the same Technics that built the 1200 with a light platter would not have bothered with a heavy platter model for broadcast.

I like the idea of having two arms for testing, one to play a continuous tone into a spectrum analyzer, and another to drop onto various kinds of tracks to induce speed variation, if possible.

I'm betting against intuition on this one. I bet it is not possible to predict the results either from the drive type or from the price of the TT.
 
The speed of an induction motor doesn't vary it just lags behind the magnetic synchronus speed. Fractional hp induction motors run about 5% slower than synchronus speed. A 2 pole sync. motor on 60 hz runs at 3600 rpm. A 1/2 hp induction motor at rated load will run at a constant 3450.

dnewma44 you stated above: I've seen a number of induction motors rated at 1740-1750 RPM on a 4 pole motor. 50-60RPM of slip.
My question is did they slow down to reflect that 50 rpm decrease and make the sound effected in any way?
And by slipping you mean completely dropping those rpm or wavering between 1800 and 1750?
 
Tubes need not produce a warm sound, that is often times a design choice.

Just noticed the quote in your signature, LOL. Mitch obviously wasn't a serious foosballer. I minored in Foosball on hollow rod Deutschmaster tables in college in the mid seventies. Spinning was definately a no-no. :nono:
 
I tested the spin down time on a 1200II.

Platter freely:24s
Silent groove:20s
Highly modulated groove 180Hz :20s.
Tested 3 times, exactly the same each time.

No difference between silent groove and highly modulated, means no extra drag depending on modulation.
gusten
 
How does the antiskate work in all this since it is supposed to compensate for the outer groove and when properly set places the stylus in the middle of the valley in the groove<sweet spot>?
 
Back
Top Bottom