• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Idler wheel "magic"...

WOW!! I an going to have to quit my job now to keep up here!!

After some tinkering last night, I changed my theory a bit. Besides dampening vibrations, the spinning idler wheel also colors the sound to some extent while also adding a bit of bass. Think rumble. I get it with too much bass whereas without idler FREEWHEELING ON OUTSIDE OF THE PLATTER, there is no rumble, no matter how much bass. (within reason of course) Marcmc's post about 4 subs makes sense. Adding low frequency sounds makes all frequency's clearer. Idler adds low frequency sound in a small way. Wish someone could suggest a way for me to test this theory. A microphone near speaker into some computer program?

Idler torque the reason for the idler turntables unique sound? I DON'T BUY THAT THEORY!! Direct drive turntables would make more torque to the platter IMHO. Is there any way to test this too? I say Torque, Schmorque!! The spinning rubber idler wheel colors the sound in a good way! There you have it. Suggestions on how to either prove or disapprove my theory are more than welcome. A.S suggests the idler driven turntable sounds better. I think he is correct but for the WRONG reasons.
 
Btw, I am not talking fantastic unbelievable gains but noticeable for sure, and "different"
while being an "improvement"! No doubt in MY mind!
 
Dominicl the only table I have to test this out would be a dual cs 616q direct drive quartz. All my other tables already modded and would be impossible to do them anyway. I don`t have any spare idler wheels tho! Can`t afford to buy any. very limited income here , I am truly sorry that I can`t help you test this out.
 
Dominicl if you are hearing rumble then the idler free wheeler IS coloring the sound. The only thing is its an overall smearing , Kinda like the music is just almost out of phase somehow. If this is the case please check the shaft your idler is spinning on is light oil ONLY. Believe me on this I went thru it on my Trio:banana:
 
A.S suggests the idler driven turntable sounds better. I think he is correct but for the WRONG reasons.

Let me guess. You did not read his entire essay or realize the table he compared it with. Besides the fact that he found what so many others have, which is to say utter shock the first time you hear one. He also found what so many of us have. There is no other explanation! All you use from the original is motor, idler wheel, platter, bearing and mechanical switch. That's it. There simply is no other explanation.

Read this, go listen to one and then see what you think. :thmbsp:

http://www.high-endaudio.com/RC-Lenco.html

Marc mc
 
Dominicl the only table I have to test this out would be a dual cs 616q direct drive quartz. All my other tables already modded and would be impossible to do them anyway. I don`t have any spare idler wheels tho! Can`t afford to buy any. very limited income here , I am truly sorry that I can`t help you test this out.

let me see if I have an extra when I get home. Thanks for helping out. I would like to measure this some how too. To be proved right or wrong. Btw, the difference seemed less prominent with the direct drive I tried. Maybe my belt drives are not as good as they could be? Empire 598 runs like a top, has 7 lb platter if I remember right. Still an improvement with silly idler spinning on the outside!
 
One of the albums I use to test my tables is Kenny rogers -eyes that see in the dark album. On it their is a song that Dolly parton sings with him on. Her voice on this song is so shrill that with any other table but the Trio her upper high peaks are blurred on. She doesn`t have a defined space in the sound stage until the Trio plays her . lol
 
Let me guess. You did not read his entire essay or realize the table he compared it with. Besides the fact that he found what so many others have, which is to say utter shock the first time you hear one. He also found what so many of us have. There is no other explanation! All you use from the original is motor, idler wheel, platter, bearing and mechanical switch. That's it. There simply is no other explanation.

Read this, go listen to one and then see what you think. :thmbsp:

http://www.high-endaudio.com/RC-Lenco.html

Marc mc

I did. That's the reason I bought 2 bogen tts (rebadged L 70) of which someday I planned to modify. However , I have other stock cheaper idler drives that blow the lenco away, so I may just sell them so as to not spend time and money to get what I already have. I may be forgetting something since I read his theories a year and a half ago, so maybe I should not have used him as a reference. My theory still stands. Prove me wrong! Or show me how to prove myself wrong. Or right for that matter.

And I do agree with your findings with the extra subs. Thought I was complimeting by referencing that. Silly me!
 
That's the reason I bought 2 bogen tts (rebadged L 70) of which someday I planned to modify. However , I have other stock cheaper idler drives that blow the lenco away, so I may just sell them so as to not spend time and money to get what I already have.

Wow, this is a long and active thread. I'll admit, I skipped most of it.

I think you are lost in the details and not looking at the 10k ft. picture.
You have two stock L70's and are comparing them to other 'tables. Simply put, the stock Lenco is at best mediocre, especially in the original plinth. The other tables may have a more sturdy/bulky plinth, which could of course lend to them out performing the stock Lenco. I have no idea which other idler models you have (maybe you stated it earlier in the thread and I missed it) or their build quality.

Since you have no desire to refurb and upgrade the Lenco's, I (as someone who dearly loves them and respects them) will happily take them off your hands to give them the treatment they deserve and a spot next to my own L75. :thmbsp::D

Also, I readily admit a complete bias toward Lencos in this reply. :music:

Jeff
 
Thanks for this post. Curious as to: "increased torque=increased cogging" is this true of all potential drive motor types? Aren't there some tables using magnetic drives now? Are they in any way impervious to this effect? Sorry if veering to far off course here...

Generally speaking, within the same style of motor, yes, that relationship will exist. I suspect that moving to a 3 phase motor like a maxon EC or some of the new thin gap motors would allow more torque for a given level of cogging vs the standard 2 phase AC sync motors.

There are ways of smoothing out the cogging, as well. The eddy brake method does just that.
 
Thanks for this post. Curious as to: "increased torque=increased cogging" is this true of all potential drive motor types? Aren't there some tables using magnetic drives now? Are they in any way impervious to this effect? Sorry if veering to far off course here...

Try thinking of it as an analogy...Think of a merry-go-round with 4 push handles and 4 guys standing around it pushing. They can only push when the handle comes to them so it's not a continuous drive system. In order to get more torque you have to get 4 stronger guys. If these guys are pushing harder each time the handle comes to them then there will be more cogging.
 
I'm not sure I buy that this is the only explanation. When I read it, my conclusion is that it's very likely not the explanation. I'll re-read and see if I am just missing something.



Save you some time. I only quote Arthur for the sake of convienance. Everyone who owns one of these things describes what he talks about in his review. People were talking about it long before he even heard one. I noticed it in 30 seconds on mine. I did not even grab a reference album, I grabbed a Roy Buchanan album. It's completely obvious to my ears.

The "bottom line", or the ultimate conclusion, of the above is thus inescapable: A large amount of effective torque is an absolute requirement to reach the highest level of turntable performance. Idler-drives, when well designed and executed, are the only type of drive system that can produce this required amount of effective torque, thus only idler-drive turntables are capable of achieving the "highest level of turntable performance". However, all of the remaining parts of the turntable must also be of outstanding quality to reach this ultimate potential. If not, there will be the usual sonic "trade-offs" (between the various turntable designs), which we audiophiles find so frustrating (and sadly, the norm). So, in other words...

When everything is otherwise basically equal (isolation, plinth, suspension, bearing, platter interface etc), a good idler-drive will outperform all the other turntable designs. Unfortunately, things are rarely equal in audio, which is the main reason why idler-drives are now rare, grossly underestimated and vastly unappreciated. One purpose of this review/essay is to redress this regrettable state of affairs.

Marc mc
 
Last edited:
Generally speaking, within the same style of motor, yes, that relationship will exist. I suspect that moving to a 3 phase motor like a maxon EC or some of the new thin gap motors would allow more torque for a given level of cogging vs the standard 2 phase AC sync motors.

There are ways of smoothing out the cogging, as well. The eddy brake method does just that.

Yes, thanks again for the post. It got me thinking more clearly on the trade-offs and issues with all the drive systems. As you point out perhaps newer/different motors might offer benefits though they likewise may have some deleterious issues as well or cost constraints too.

Try thinking of it as an analogy...Think of a merry-go-round with 4 push handles and 4 guys standing around it pushing. They can only push when the handle comes to them so it's not a continuous drive system. In order to get more torque you have to get 4 stronger guys. If these guys are pushing harder each time the handle comes to them then there will be more cogging.

Thanks Ray, I'm aware of that aspect but I'll display some ignorance and ask why not put 12 or 24 puny guys in there to minimize the surge/cog issue? I need to do some serious electric drive motor learnin'...:scratch2:
 
Cogging is frequency driven, not pole driven. If you put 24 poles in there and drive at 60hz, it will have the same amount of cogging as a 4 pole motor running at 60hz.

With an AC sync motor, the number of poles are primarily just determining the RPM the motor spins at. With a 60hz frequency, a 4 pole motor spins at 1800 RPM, 2 pole at 3600 RPM. 20 pole at 360 RPM, etc.
 
Another possibility is that your Trio, mat, arm, cartridge combo just happens to attenuate the offensive content in a bad record. Call it BSD (Benevolent Sysnergistic Distortion). I'd think you need a bigger sample. :D

One of the albums I use to test my tables is Kenny rogers -eyes that see in the dark album. On it their is a song that Dolly parton sings with him on. Her voice on this song is so shrill that with any other table but the Trio her upper high peaks are blurred on. She doesn`t have a defined space in the sound stage until the Trio plays her . lol


Plus 1, Ray is the king. All hail Ray. For years I've daydreamed about a hydraulic drive platter with hydrostatic suspension and possibly a hydrostatic bearing. It would be gravity fed relying on just the total dynamic head of the pump storage reservoir. The control system would be nothing more than a fixed orifice. Theoretically nothing would/could be simpler or deliver contant torque more stably than an incompressible liquid and gravity. Admitted this design would not work in space. Maybe I should have been a ME instead of an EE?


Ray is the king of analogies.
 
Elcholic I`ll go with that or anything that pleases the ears better I don`t care if it has 100% thd and wow&flutter of 100% . Ears mean more than figures to me.

And I do have a few more albums that I use some just to test tight bass and some for the soundstage
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom