• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What determines speaker efficiency?

JohnMac

Addicted Member
I've been reading about speaker efficiency and I understand how it's measured and why it can important. Can someone explain what it is about the components or design determines the efficiency?

Thanks,

John
 
Register to hide this ad
Harmon's JBL and Altec woofers are typically quite sensitive with most in the >= 90 dB per watt range.
In reconing these drivers, I've found they are somewhat unique in their construction in that they have very small air gaps. I have to resort to 7.5 mil shims; whereas most other brands easily accept 10 mil shims. I suspect the small air gap is there by design to provide a smaller distance for the electrons to travel. However, I'm sure this is only one aspect of efficient driver design. Those brands typically have very heavy magnet systems as well. Other factors may also contribute, but hey, I'm not a woofer designer, just a repairer.
 
On a component level, I think that ultimately it is about the design of the voice coil and its interaction with the magnet. A speaker cone moves because you have two magnets in close proximity to each other - a permanent magnet and an electro-magnet (the voice coil, driven by alternating current). The intensity of the magnetic field produced by the electro-magnetic will depend on the voltage, amount of current flow, the number of windings in the voice coil, some characteristics of the coil wire and the physical arrangement (air gap). The permanent magnet size and material matter. The right combination of quality materials and manufacturing techniques will produce a speaker that is more responsive to lower levels of current flow than different designs.

Then these individual components need to be assembled into a system in a manner that manages current flow between components. That is the job of the cross-over. Cross-overs can contribute to your perception of sensitivity by emphasizing certain components of the sound spectrum.

So there is both art (your reaction, perceptions) and science involved.
 
Last edited:
.
In reconing these drivers, I've found they are somewhat unique in their construction in that they have very small air gaps. I have to resort to 7.5 mil shims; whereas most other brands easily accept 10 mil shims. I suspect the small air gap is there by design

This is correct, though it's to focus the magnetic field rather than anything to do with electrons.

The closer the pole piece and top plate are the the coil, the stronger the magnetic field. Magnetic strength over a gap is inversely proportional to the SQUARE of the distance between the poles... you can see how a close distance can greatly increase the magnetic field strength.

JBL did indeed use a very tight magnetic gap, to increase efficiency, in their earliest woofers (before 1960). However, due to demands for increased power handling, these gaps were somewhat "opened up" around 1960 or so, to accommodate "high power users" such as Dick Dale and other musicians, which were beginning to use lots of JBL drivers in musical instrument applications- the larger gaps allowed better air flow, as well as a bit of expansion of the coils (due to heat) without rubbing or other failures. These slightly larger gaps were gradually implemented in all JBL speakers; to maintain field strength, stronger, larger magnets were required, compared to the early models, to maintain similar efficiency and to keep other parameters in similar ranges.

To more generally address the question- there are several factors that interact, to give the sensitivity of a given driver. Sensitivity is inversely proportional to moving mass (i.e, a perfectly efficient- 100% conversion of electrical energy to acoustic energy- driver would necessarily have to be completely weightless), and proportional to magnetic field strength TIMES the number of coil windings in that magnetic field at any point. This is why high-efficiency speakers will pretty much always have light-weight cones, large magnets, fine-wound coils, or some combination of more than one of these factors.

However, a light-weight cone oftentimes has very little "bass resonant support"... and can oftentimes require a large cabinet volume, to get enough air to "leverage" good low bass extension and response. Same goes for large magnet assemblies, in a sense- they oftentimes "damp out" the natural bass response... requiring equalization (shaping of the driver response by electronics, whether it be passive crossovers or active electronic devices) and/or increases in cone mass and increases in cabinet volume to achieve extended low-bass output...

In essence, it's a trade-off. Suffice it to say, if you CAN readily fit in a large speaker cabinet, it's oftentimes in your benefit to do so... higher efficiency and better low bass response are there to be had, with larger enclosures...

Regards,
Gordon.
 
Efficiency or sensitivity?

While there may be some crossroads where they're related, they're two very different things.

Efficiency refers to how much of the electrical input is converted to acoustic output.

Sensitivity refers to how much acoustic output is generated by a known/given amount of electrical input, but should NOT be confused with or substituted for efficiency.

Here's a little wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudspeaker#Efficiency_vs._sensitivity

There are better explanations out there, this one was just easy to find.
 
Last edited:
Efficiency or sensitivity?

While there may be some crossroads where they're related, they're two very different things.

Efficiency refers to how much of the electrical input is converted to acoustic output.

Sensitivity refers to how much acoustic output is generated by a known/given amount of electrical input,

Yes, with the caveat that it's oftentimes defined "in a certain range of directions". In essence, if you limit the amount of coverage angles the speaker has to address, you can "concentrate" the output in the remaining angles of space... making it louder in a smaller "cone of output".

Also, sensitivity is oftentimes referenced to the VOLTAGE an amplifier would have to produce, to result in a certain dB level of output within the stated dispersion area. You will oftentimes see measurements specified as dB/2.83v, instead of the more traditional dB/1w measurement. This is typical for speakers other than 8 ohms... for a speaker that is EXACTLY 8 ohms over its usable range, the two measurements exactly coincide. However, for a 4 ohm speaker... at 2.83v, the input power will be TWO watts, rather than the one watt into an 8ohm speaker. This is sort of 'cheating' a bit... since you are actually drawing more power... but, with many amps that will maintain roughly the same output voltage into 4 ohm loads (i.e, "4 ohm stable" amps with big power supplies), this can result in an situation where up to twice the amp power can be had, before clipping of the amp starts to occur. One BIG caveat here, is that this COMPLETELY DEPENDS ON THE AMP IN QUESTION... some will start to "sag" in available output voltage... at which point, there's very little gain to be had, by using lower-impedance speakers such as 4 ohms and such...


but should NOT be confused with or substituted for efficiency.

Nope. Efficiency is simply how well the speaker converts electrical watts into acoustic watts. Most speakers are amazingly IN-efficient (for example, to even be 1% efficient playing into an omnidirectional space, the speaker has to be 92dB/1w sensitivity into full space!)... it's not until you get into HUGE cabinets (usually involving horns) that you get reasonable efficiency levels. I think the absolute highest I've ever seen or heard about, is around 50% efficiency... and that was a HUGE horn array... I mean, something that occupied the space of a few tractor trailers... and was made to only play down to maybe 60 Hz or so...

Regards,
Gordon.
 
Gordon is quite informative here and correct! In speaker efficientcy there seems to be several contributintg factors. A given speaker has electrical and mechanical properties that combine to give it certain efficientcy and sound products. As a general rule I have found that flat wire voice coils, on high temp formers, with small magnet gaps, large magnets and relatively light cones tend to offer the higher efficientcy.

You will notice that pro audio speakers are typically higher in efficientcy than home audio components-BUT the home audio components typically offer the better fedelity or overall sound product! Getting the comnination of both is desired effect I would think.
DC
 
Back
Top Bottom