Exactly-maybe Andy's solo was short, but it says more than many guitarists whole bag of tricks. In addition it actually has relevance to what is happening thematically in the song. I sense the ramblings of someone very musically unedumacated or vastly over to the point of being a critic, yet not a player. Most importantly, it's art-subject to personal opinion. Now if you analyze these pieces of music based on phrasing, note choice, harmonic content, time feel, tone, etc and tell us why they make you so uncomfortable......